Bret Stephens wrote a New York Times column a few days ago where he attacked the progressive House members who voted against the billion dollars for the Iron Dome military program for Israel.
When objective people look at the votes against the Iron Dome legislation it is no mystery why those who voted against it voted the way they did. Agree with the nine or not (plus the two who voted present, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Hank Johnson), there is no reason to suspect that they didnt act according to their principles. They can make totally coherent arguments why the billion dollars should be spent elsewhere.
But look at how Stephens describes their motive. He called their vote a supremely foul piece of political grandstanding. Why does he need to do that? Why cant he grant his ideological opponents their own principles?
The answer to this question is that for Stephens when it comes to Israel there is no other side. For him there is no pro-Palestinian perspective. There is only a pro-Israel perspective and an anti-Israel/antisemitic perspective.
Bret Stephens cant imagine the pro-Palestinian viewpoint. The Palestinian perspective is only experienced as an anti-Israel perspective, in what I have called hasbara culture a construction of alternative reality centering on the victimization of the Jewish people. From that perspective these nine votes are antisemitic votes.
Thats why Bret Stephens called their vote and the successful progressive move a few days before the vote to block the billion dollars from a government spending bill a supremely foul piece of political grandstanding.
You will almost certainly not seeRepresentative Jamaal Bowmanof New York,Representative Pramila Jayapalof Washington,Representative Rashida Tlaibof Michigan or their fellow travelers in the House progressive caucus paying any serious reputational cost for this supremely foul piece of political grandstanding.
Similarly, in the article Stephens writes as it were self-evident that Rep. Ilhan Omar was guilty of a string of anti-Semitic remarks. Stephens believes that when Ilhan Omar looks at Israel she sees nothing more than a bunch of Jews not human rights abuses supported by U.S. aid. I have argued ad nauseum that hasbara culture journalists like Stephens, Bari Weiss, and Yair Rosenberg should be the last people whose judgment should be taken seriously on whats going on in Omars and Tlaibs heads when they consider the Palestine question. Its all hasbara culture projection.
Here is Stephens on what Michigan congresswoman Rashida Tlaib is guilty of:
Last month, Tlaib gave a talk to the Democratic Socialists of America inwhich she darkly alludedto certain people behind the curtain who make money by oppressing people from Gaza to Detroit. Wonder who she had in mind?
In plain English Stephens is accusing Tlaib of telling the DSA that it is the Jews who are behind the curtain making money by oppressing the rest of us. This is a very serious allegation. If his accusation is true, she should be drummed out of American political life.
But is it true? Any objective person realizes that its nonsense. Read what Tlaib said about oppressors behind the curtain:
We also need to recognize this is for me as a Palestinian-American. As I think about my family in Palestine, that continue to live under military occupation and how that really interacts with this beautiful Black city I grew up in, I always tell people that cutting people off from water is violence, andtheydo it from Gaza to Detroit, and its a way to control people, to oppress people, and its those structures that we continue to fight againstIf you open the curtain and look behind the curtain, itsthe same peoplethat make money, and yesthey do, off of racism. Off of these broken policies. There is someone there making money. You saw it, it was so exposed curing the pandemic, because all those structures, everything that was set up,they made record profitwhile we were having some of the most challenging most difficult times in our lifetime.
Agree with Tlaib or not about the 1%, she is voicing a common worldview on the left, that the rich are profiting from the misery of the rest of us, as I wrote when I defended her against the smears of Bari Weiss and ADL head Jonathan Greenblatt.
Of all the people watching Tlaibs speech to the DSA only a minuscule amount would think that Tlaib is thinking of or alluding to Jews at any point. However, the hasbara culture self-appointed experts on antisemitism interpret her words to mean that Tlaibs they does not mean the billionaires who are making record profits off those structures or getting rich off the pandemic. No, she means Jews. The experts say that Tlaib is saying: Just as the Jews are oppressing the Palestinians in Palestine, when you look behind the curtain in the U.S., its the Jews who fuel our misgivings here too.
As I have shown repeatedly, there are even lots of Jews who dont accept Stephenss Jewish authority for interpreting Omar and Tlaib. There are many Jews who defend them from these Jewish accusations:
Like all previous incidents with Tlaib and other members of the Squad, there were other Jews and Jewish organizations defending her and even expressing outrage at the antisemitism charges. For instance, Peter Beinart, Rabbi Sharon Brous and J Streetcondemnedattacks on Tlaib as reckless constituting vitriolic and divisive ads against women lawmakers of color.
These Jews detected no dog whistles about Jews when watching the same video. To these Jews its self-evident that the same people making record profits whom Tlaib is alluding to are not Jews.
So how should we make sense of the fact that anti-cancel culture warriors like Stephens and Weiss are making an accusation that most people would find libelous? Why doesnt it bother them that these dark allegations arent true? Isnt telling the truth among Stephenss high principles hes constantly patting himself on the back about?
The answer to these questions is that according to Stephens and Weiss, defamation and dishonesty are no vice when fighting the enemies of the Jews. Omar and Tlaib are guilty of being Jew-haters even before opening their mouths. Because being on the other side of Israel, or opposed to the special relationship between the U.S. and Israel, makes you an enemy of the Jews according to hasbara culture journalists like Stephens and Weiss. And there are no rules when hasbara culture journalists are fighting the enemies of the Jews.
The fact that all sorts of well-respected human rights organizations have labeled Israeli rule apartheid offers no protection to Rashida Tlaib when she does the same. Theyre antisemites and self-hating Jews as well.
Read what Hagai El-Ad of BTselem and Lara Friedman of Foundation for Middle East Peace say on this matter.
When @RepRashida speaks of Israels apartheid regime, she not only echoes her familys lived experience but is also articulating the growing consensus of Palestinian, Israeli, and international human rights groups, including @alhaq_org, @btselem and @HRW.
Friedman echoes the point:
As members of Congress from both parties gleefully pile on @RepRashida for using the word apartheid on the House floor to describe Israeli policies, great time to review who else has used the word in this context
But according to hasbara culture, Rashida Tlaib is using the apartheid accusation as an excuse for her Jew hatred. Thats how Yair Rosenberg and others frame the enmity Israels behavior causes among Palestinians and around the world.
Thus, from the hasbara culture perspective Stephens and Weiss can in good conscience attempt to destroy Tlaib by any means necessary.
And Rep. Ted Deutch of Florida duly rises in the House to castigate Tlaib as an alleged antisemite.
To understand more of Stephens and Weisss thinking its imperative to unpack the ideology behind the hasbara culture antisemitism discourse. What is the function of the trope and canard accusations, like those aimed at Omar and Tlaib, for hasbara culture? The answer is that when an enemy of Israel supposedly commits a trope and canard crime what it does is confirm an already held belief. According to hasbara cultures alternative reality Tlaib and Omar are already Jew haters. Them having a pro-Palestinian perspective is ipso facto anti-Semitic. According to ethnocentric hasbara culture, being on the other side of Israel is being guilty of hating Jews.
The tweet from journalist Mairav Zonzsein in response to Ted Deutchs attack on Tlaib makes the accurate observation that this view has conquered not only Jewish political culture but American political culture as well.
One of the biggest double standards in DC politics is Jewish American politicians being as pro-Israel as they want and not being called anti-Palestinian but Palestinian American politician @RashidaTlaib not being able to be pro-Palestinian without being called an antisemite
Thus, the supposed trope and canards transgression merely confirm that Omar and Tlaib are classic antisemites. They are no different than the antisemites that Jews are familiar with from European history. Thats the theme throughout Bari Weisss book on antisemitism. And again, thats because there are no two sides to the Israeli Palestinian conflict according to hasbara culture, its all about how you feel about the one Jewish state in the world, as Ted Deutch put it when he said that Rashida Tlaib was an antisemite.
Tlaib of course has a perfect right to oppose more funding for Israel. This is how JJ Goldberg puts the difference between Jew hatred of the past and Israel hatred of today:
[U]nlike classical anti-Semitism, which entailed the persecution of a minority for no reason that the victim could control, this new conflict has two active parties,each with claims against the other. The conflict has spillover effects on others around the world, Jews, and Muslims, who identify with one side or the other. It is ugly and getting uglier. But to call it merely a rebirth of the old hatred is to deny that there are two sides to the conflict.
Hasbara culture journalists have another weapon against critics of Israel whataboutism, or changing the subject to some other country. You see the same ideological, sociological, and psychological processes in their whataboutism argument. Whataboutism plays the same role that trope and canards play in hasbara cultures victimhood discourse. It confirms the bias of the Israel critic and supposedly proves that the criticism is really only about the Jews.
According to this view its never Israels behavior that induces outrage but rather Jew hatred. If antisemitism isnt behind the (undue) focus on Israel, why according to the whataboutism arguments are other countries human rights abusers overlooked and ignored?
Why dont left-wing academics boycott Indian products, Bret Stephens asks:
Why is it always the worlds only Jewish state that draws boycotts asks Eli Lake?
Why doesnt the left want to boycott China or Pakistan? Its always the worlds only Jewish state.
And Bari Weiss knows exactly why the silence is supposedly deafening when Hamas acts brutally.
Notice that total clarity, according to Weiss, is the ability to proclaim antisemitism when others find no such thing. Believing Israel critics are motivated by Jew-hatred is moral clarity for hasbara culture journalists.
As Bari Weiss explained on the Bill Maher show, the left only cares about Muslims when it involves Israel. Again, what about China.
There are a million Uighurs in China, Muslims in concentration camps. Somehow the Left who claim to care so much about Muslim lives dont talk about that.
And thats the same whataboutism argument that Weiss made to Joe Rogan and his audience:
Theres an obsession on the State of IsraelThese people say nothing generally about the genocide of Uighur Muslims in China
And according to Yair Rosenberg, there is no prize for guessing why the U.N. is preoccupied with Israel not China. No, the U.N. is preoccupied with Israel because it is a Jewish state.
Thanks to hasbara culture proselytizers hasbara culture tropes seen in this article have become a truism among American politicians. In fact, the most insidious political correctness that there is is the inability to challenge hasbara cultures sacred (macho) victimhood social construction of alternative reality.
In the real world, as we know (and countless Israelis and Palestinians have warned), Israel is going down a very dark road. But its antisemitic to talk about it, let alone do anything about it.
Recall President Obamas final, tepid reaction to Netanyahu and Apartheid: in December 2016 he allowed a U.N. Security Council anti-settlement resolution to go through with a U.S. abstention. Stephens said that Obama betrayed Israel.
The sacred victimhood culture I am anatomizing is holding Jewish and American politics hostage. Because Stephens and Weiss and other Hasbara culture journalists ask politicians and political actors one question: Are you on the side of Israel (the way they define pro-Israel) and all that is good in the world or on the side of its Jew hating enemies?
What politician wants to be known as being on the side of the enemies of Israel and the Jews? Which politician would choose to be on the receiving end of hasbara culture demonization like the sort poured over Rashida Tlaib by Ted Deutch?
Thats the real reason for all the lopsided pro-Israel votes in congress. What politician wants to be ritually defamed by the likes of Bret Stephens in the New York Times? Irrespective of AIPAC and hasbara culture money, if politicians were free to vote their consciences the votes would surely be a lot closer than 420 to 9.
But as more and more Americans consciences direct them to take the Palestinian side, more and more politicians (and their supporters) are sure to be branded asJew-haters by hasbara culture purveyors. As I have written before, Attempting to destroy politicians reputations on the altar of hasbara culture and Jewish political power is actually toxic for the American Jewish community and real living American Jews and non-Jews, too.
But the hasbara culture hatred that Stephens, Weiss, and others spew has no name. Because it comes in the guise of the fight against antisemitism.
Until Stephens and Weiss are made to defend, and answer for, their hateful delusions, they will continue to proselytize their hasbara culture venom. For American politics on Israel to change, the journalists who continue to transform pro-Palestinian into anti-Jew must be discredited before they do even more cultural damage.
So where are the Palestinian voices in mainstream media?
Mondoweiss covers the full picture of the struggle for justice in Palestine. Read by tens of thousands of people each month, our truth-telling journalism is an essential counterweight to the propaganda that passes for news in mainstream and legacy media.
Our news and analysis is available to everyone which is why we need your support. Please contribute so that we can continue to raise the voices of those who advocate for the rights of Palestinians to live in dignity and peace.
Palestinians today are struggling for their lives as mainstream media turns away. Please support journalism that amplifies the urgent voices calling for freedom and justice in Palestine.
Follow this link:
- Feehery: The honest contrarian | TheHill - The Hill - November 23rd, 2021
- First thoughts on the new President's Management Agenda - FCW.com - November 23rd, 2021
- Austin Preshko: Enforcing mandate with informants will encourage false reports against those who engage in 'wrong think' - Must Read Alaska - November 23rd, 2021
- Is the legacy of Monty Python being destroyed? - Far Out Magazine - November 23rd, 2021
- More Deferential but Also More Political: How Americans' Views of the Military Have Changed Over 20 Years - War on the Rocks - November 23rd, 2021
- Its American History: Its time to face the truth about what critical race theory actually means to the right - East Bay Express - November 23rd, 2021
- Thanksgiving is a holiday dedicated to gratitude and tolerance so the woke have their knives out for it - New York Post - November 23rd, 2021
- The Roustabouts Go for the Gut (Laugh) in 'For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls' - Times of San Diego - November 23rd, 2021
- 10 of the best new release Netflix series available coming in November - The Scotsman - November 23rd, 2021
- Book Spoilers, Sex Jokes and Other Letters to the Editor - The New York Times - November 19th, 2021
- Opinion | The Woke Student Is Just a Scapegoat - The New York Times - November 19th, 2021
- We need to get real about Islamist terrorism - Spiked - November 19th, 2021
- The thought police have arrived with 'trigger warning' alarm that goes off at every offensive remark - Telegraph.co.uk - November 19th, 2021
- 'The Sex Lives of College Girls' on HBO Max is a hilarious, sexy treat from Mindy Kaling - Mashable - November 19th, 2021
- An Archconservative Magazine Discovers Afrofuturism at the Met and Is Not Pleased - Hyperallergic - November 19th, 2021
- The Every by Dave Eggers review big tech is watching you - The Guardian - November 19th, 2021
- 10 of the best Netflix new release series available this November - The Scotsman - November 19th, 2021
- Chinese dissident warns Americans: Youre already in the authoritarian state...you just dont know it - Fox News - November 15th, 2021
- 'Legacy American' is the latest catchphrase in the racist lexicon | TheHill - The Hill - November 15th, 2021
- Too sensitive or too ignorant? The rise of political correctness in the US - Mesa Press - November 15th, 2021
- On Kashmir, Literature, and the Shroud of Political Correctness - The Quint - November 15th, 2021
- Despite laundry list of injuries, the Bucs should beat Washington 35-13 on Sunday - Creative Loafing Tampa - November 15th, 2021
- How will Eastern election results affect Utah? |Opinion - Deseret News - November 15th, 2021
- Andrew Sullivan on American political discourse and rescuing conservatism in 2021 - 60 Minutes - CBS News - November 15th, 2021
- AOC's 'Woke' Whine Is Why the Dems Can't Stop Losing - The Daily Beast - November 15th, 2021
- A Look At The Diversity Of Political Ideology In The United States : The NPR Politics Podcast - NPR - November 15th, 2021
- Letters to the Editor Many readers will miss Mallard Fillmore - The Dallas Morning News - November 15th, 2021
- GUEST VIEW: Dictatorial coaching should be in the past - Lockport Union-Sun & Journal - November 15th, 2021
- Making the effort to do what is right - The Jackson Sun - November 15th, 2021
- Cape Cod theater reviews: Romance, revelations and a different view of Thanksgiving - Cape Cod Times - November 15th, 2021
- Betsy DeVos to publish Hostages to the Cause, a book on misguided failures of US education system - Yahoo News - November 15th, 2021
- How on earth has Family Guy survived for 20 seasons in the supposed era of political correctness? - The Independent - November 3rd, 2021
- How on earth has Family Guy survived in the era of political correctness? - News Nation USA - November 3rd, 2021
- The Board of Ed Elephant in the Room and Other Passaic Elections Nuggets - InsiderNJ - November 3rd, 2021
- Deadlock at the pump | Opinion | wvnews.com - WV News - November 3rd, 2021
- Shared Loves and Strong Loyalties | R. R. Reno - First Things - November 3rd, 2021
- Larry Summers slams Democrats for failing to tax the wealthy - Salon - November 3rd, 2021
- How the Word 'Woke' Was Co-Opted And Weaponized - WDET - November 3rd, 2021
- The Head-Turning Gesture Donald And Melania Trump Made At The World Series - The List - November 3rd, 2021
- Lowell High, Alison Collins and the Sunset's rage against diversity - San Francisco Chronicle - November 3rd, 2021
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Respectful conversation easy to watch - Odessa American - October 24th, 2021
- Costumes, masks and things that go bump in the night - Cape Cod Times - October 24th, 2021
- Letter: McClaughry: Editor of The Tone Deaf Times - Brattleboro Reformer - October 24th, 2021
- Letters to the Editor, Oct. 22 - Marco News - October 24th, 2021
- Virginias Election Is Breaking the Rules - New York Magazine - October 19th, 2021
- Letters to the editor - Boston Herald - October 19th, 2021
- Ballot proposal would replace he with they in Grand Have n city charter - WOODTV.com - October 19th, 2021
- Dave Chappelle refuses to be cancelled | TheHill - The Hill - October 19th, 2021
- Keep Appreciation for Hispanic Heritage Alive With These Great Books - L.A. Weekly - October 19th, 2021
- History of the World Part 1 is Getting a Sequel - Book and Film Globe - October 19th, 2021
- AstonRep Theatre Presents GOD OF CARNAGE At The Edge Theater - Broadway World - October 19th, 2021
- Max Gillies talks satire, The Gillies Report and the future of political comedy - ABC News - October 19th, 2021
- 'The Office' Star John Krasinski Once Shared His Favorite Episode of All Time - And It's Pretty Controversial - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - October 19th, 2021
- Falling all the time Billy Connolly had to move out of New York as Parkinsons worsened - Express - October 19th, 2021
- Political correctness - POLITICO - October 15th, 2021
- Billy Connolly raged at politically correct mob who screwed it for everybody - Daily Express - October 15th, 2021
- PC Halloween: Here are the costumes parents agree no kid should wear while trick-or-treating - Study Finds - October 15th, 2021
- Science is the latest victim of cancel culture - Brunswick News - October 15th, 2021
- Sir Billy Connolly: I'd be cancelled by the woke brigade if I started out in comedy today - The Telegraph - October 15th, 2021
- Krull: Gruden is like other blowhards, lacking in common decency and courtesy - The Herald-Times - October 15th, 2021
- Peter Thiel bets on the far right: Tech tycoon spending millions to bankroll "Trump wing" of GOP - Salon - October 15th, 2021
- Lorraine fans delighted to see Billy Connolly looking so well as he plugs new book amid Parkinsons b... - The Sun - October 15th, 2021
- Letter to the Editor: Keep Seattle politics out of rural King County - Woodinville Northwest News - October 15th, 2021
- Back in the Day: This is my 500th Back in the Day column! - Fairfield Daily Republic - October 15th, 2021
- 'Forget the Alamo' Book Trashes Texas' Beloved Origin Myth - The Daily Beast - October 15th, 2021
- 'Cosplay Christianity': The sin is in the denial of the life God calls us to - Religion News Service - October 15th, 2021
- Diversification is the key to success - AV Magazine - October 15th, 2021
- Raila, Ruto must end political intolerance ahead of elections - The Standard - October 15th, 2021
- The Many Feints of The Sopranos - The American Prospect - October 15th, 2021
- Digimon Tamers Stage Play Accused Of Promoting Far Right ... - October 5th, 2021
- British Airways Accused of Political Correctness as it Abolishes Ladies and Gentleman From Onboard Announcements - Paddle Your Own Kanoo - October 5th, 2021
- America needs to get back to honesty, thinking about the group - EH Extra - October 5th, 2021
- Putin has hit us but will lose, says interior minister - The First News - October 5th, 2021
- Alejandro Zaera-Polo has been removed from his faculty position as Princeton continues its row with the former SoA dean - Archinect - October 5th, 2021
- Six Broadway Review: The Real Housewives of Henry VIII Put on a Show - Yahoo Entertainment - October 5th, 2021
- Jon Stewarts Back. Heres Why We Should Care. - POLITICO - October 5th, 2021
- The comedy in Olney's 'Thanksgiving Play' comes with a side of snark - DC Metro Theater Arts - October 5th, 2021
- Scottish theatre company apologises after backlash over 'cancel culture' and political correctness play - The Scotsman - September 29th, 2021
- 11 Examples Of Political Correctness Gone Mad - September 29th, 2021
- COMMENTARY: Woking the Boomer Cache Valley Daily - Cache Valley Daily - September 29th, 2021