(Photo by Andrew Burton/Getty Images)
It started with a tweet about President Trumps decision to pull us out of the Paris Climate Agreement. Professor Chaplin who is the Chair of American Studies Department at Harvard and the James Duncan Phillips Professor, tweeted this:
That tweet somehow got picked up by Senator Ted Cruz, who, in the spirit of curiosity and intellectual inquiry, sought to clarify what Professor Chaplin meant. He asked, Dear Professor Chaplin, your tweet struck me as odd, given that we all usually think of July 4, 1776, as the birth of our nation. Can you clarify what you mean?
Just kidding! He completely dismissed her, and then in the right-wing press, was described as having owned her.
That led to Professor Chaplins clapback:
I jumped in because it was clear that Senator Cruz wasnt looking for intellectual debate, or he wouldnt have started out with the ad hominem and condescension. As one of my colleagues wrote, What did Senator Cruz say that was wrong? My reply was:
And then discussion degenerated. I dont have time to do a thorough statistical analysis, but the vast of majority of replies (at least to me) were insults. There were a few who came to Professor Chaplins defense, seeking to elaborate on her points (if they went to her twitter feed, they would have seen some more discussion). Many came to Senator Cruzs defense. But, at this point, the discussion became partisan, and all hope for any understanding was lost.
So, let me try to sum up the two positions, not doing justice to either side.
A country requires international recognition to exist. I could declare myself the great state of LawProfBlawg, but no one is going to acknowledge my country. I wont be a player on any international arena, and I might very well get invaded. Throughout history there were many nations that lacked international recognition, such as the Republic of Lakotah, the Principality of the Hutt River, or other micronations. Some countries have varying degrees of international recognition, which makes the notion murkier, but it is still a necessary condition for statehood. Professor Chaplin takes a more eloquent position here.
A country begins at conception. Perhaps Orin Kerr said it best in his tweet:
In other words, the Declaration of Independence created the United Colonies, which then undertook a name change on September 9, 1776, to the United States of America. The only trouble here is that the founders spoke of free and independent states, so perhaps then we should be talking about multiple countries. Regardless, by the time of the Articles of Confederation and later the Constitution, it was very clear they were a single country, the good ol US of A.
Blog length makes my summary of both arguments incomplete, with many unanswered questions. For example, was the Confederate States of America a country? It did declare independence, and under the second standard, would have to be historically recognized as a country. Under the first standard, the Confederacy was not a country because it received no international recognition. But there are countries that exist without full international recognition. In short, its murky.
While the answer may be murky a few things about the great debate are clear:
I wondered about the gender implications of the debate. I wondered if this is what it is like to be a female faculty member at a University.
I wonder why Im even calling it a debate. Professor Chaplin was doing what most of us do on Twitter. She wasnt expecting a Cruzian call-out. She was expressing outrage at the United States, a member of the international community since birth, pulling out of that community. Even as other tweeters got involved, it was never a debate. It had all the trappings of the famous Monty Python Argument Clinic.
Thats not the fault of Twitter. Those with differing viewpoints refuse to seek common understanding, as traditional debate becomes an increasingly lost art. The loss will eventually destroy us, if it hasnt already.
UPDATE (2:45 p.m.): After hearing from Senator Cruzs staff members, I must add that I was remiss in not pointing out that Senator Cruz did lay out his argument in two subsequent tweets:
I would characterize this more along the lines of the conception argument, but might eliminate the problem of what to call the Confederacy (because they lost). Ill incorporate my previous assertions to apply to these tweets as well.
LawProfBlawg is an anonymous professor at a top 100 law school. You can see more of his musingshereand onTwitter. Email him atlawprofblawg@gmail.com.
Excerpt from:
When Did We Become A Country? The (Not So) Great Chaplin/Cruz ... - Above the Law
- Micronations 2023 - February 18th, 2023 [February 18th, 2023]
- The country that became a 'micronation capital' - BBC Future - October 25th, 2022 [October 25th, 2022]
- MicroWiki:Create page - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - October 25th, 2022 [October 25th, 2022]
- vMundus - World of Nations and Micronations - October 25th, 2022 [October 25th, 2022]
- Pole Countries Flag Pack Cooperation (With some Micronations) - July 13th, 2022 [July 13th, 2022]
- Richest European Countries 2022 - worldpopulationreview.com - July 13th, 2022 [July 13th, 2022]
- Leaders of 3 Unrecognized Nations Share Why They Formed Their Self-Proclaimed States - LX - July 13th, 2022 [July 13th, 2022]
- Top 10 Unrecognised Countries and How to Visit Them - April 25th, 2022 [April 25th, 2022]
- Order of the Golden Sun - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - February 15th, 2022 [February 15th, 2022]
- Opinion: No one will be able to subjugate Belarus - Belarus News (BelTA) - December 25th, 2021 [December 25th, 2021]
- Micronations, A World Tour Of 8 Bizzaro Spots Barely On The Map - Worldcrunch - November 28th, 2021 [November 28th, 2021]
- Republic of Kekistan - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - November 1st, 2021 [November 1st, 2021]
- The Great Micronation of West Indica - Posted in - SwordsToday.ie - November 1st, 2021 [November 1st, 2021]
- The Smallest Capitals in the World - Statista - June 24th, 2021 [June 24th, 2021]
- Join in on the Summit County treasure hunt - TownLift - June 4th, 2021 [June 4th, 2021]
- Breaking News - Peacock Orders Epic Science Series "The End Is Nye" with Emmy Award-Winning Host Bill Nye - The Futon Critic - March 7th, 2021 [March 7th, 2021]
- micronation | Law, Recognition, History, & Definition ... - August 8th, 2020 [August 8th, 2020]
- Australia has one of the largest number of micronations in the world - ABC News - August 8th, 2020 [August 8th, 2020]
- Hutt River micronation to rejoin Australia due to coronavirus pandemic - The Guardian - August 8th, 2020 [August 8th, 2020]
- Hutt River micronation to rejoin Australia due to debt caused by Covid-19 - The Indian Express - August 8th, 2020 [August 8th, 2020]
- Micronation rejoins Australia after 50 years of independence - Daily Express - August 8th, 2020 [August 8th, 2020]
- Micronation - Encyclopedia Westarctica - May 24th, 2020 [May 24th, 2020]
- Tourism collapse threatens Pacific islands with deepening poverty - PoliticalLore.com - May 6th, 2020 [May 6th, 2020]
- What Is A Micronation? - WorldAtlas.com - April 8th, 2020 [April 8th, 2020]
- MicroNations Fandom | Fandom - April 8th, 2020 [April 8th, 2020]
- Lilliputians in Gulliver's World - The odd world of the mini-state - Geographical - October 31st, 2019 [October 31st, 2019]
- Review: In Terra Firma, a Wee Wet Country on the Brink - The New York Times - October 11th, 2019 [October 11th, 2019]
- Micronation - RationalWiki - August 14th, 2017 [August 14th, 2017]
- Apple Says It Will Overtake Samsung Pay By Year's End - ChannelNews - August 4th, 2017 [August 4th, 2017]
- We met 27 people who claim to be the rulers of their own countries ... - VICE News - August 4th, 2017 [August 4th, 2017]
- Harnessing The Power of Decentralization: Max Borders of Social Evolution Speaks - Inside Bitcoins - July 29th, 2017 [July 29th, 2017]
- Hoagland - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - July 20th, 2017 [July 20th, 2017]
- Meet President of Molossia, a micronation of just 33 citizens with its ... - TUKO.CO.KE - July 5th, 2017 [July 5th, 2017]
- Australia's hidden micronations: It's not the size of the country but how you rule it - 9news.com.au - July 2nd, 2017 [July 2nd, 2017]
- Liberbeer Beer with a Taste of Freedom - Total Croatia News - June 29th, 2017 [June 29th, 2017]
- Micronations / Axis Powers Hetalia - TV Tropes - June 25th, 2017 [June 25th, 2017]
- Micronation - MicroWiki - June 8th, 2017 [June 8th, 2017]
- DAVID MURDOCK: On fascinating things - Gadsden Times - June 5th, 2017 [June 5th, 2017]
- List Of MicroNations No Trouble - Don't Mess - June 3rd, 2017 [June 3rd, 2017]
- How to create your own country - Stuff.co.nz - May 4th, 2017 [May 4th, 2017]
- Parliassam - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - April 19th, 2017 [April 19th, 2017]
- Inside the plan to replace Trump's border wall with a high-tech ... - The Verge - April 5th, 2017 [April 5th, 2017]
- Perisia - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - April 3rd, 2017 [April 3rd, 2017]
- An LGBTQ Micronation Declared War On Australia In 2004 And A Senator Is Still Mad About It - Huffington Post Australia - February 28th, 2017 [February 28th, 2017]
- Anthelia - MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - February 26th, 2017 [February 26th, 2017]
- Goodbye government: Six guys who started their own micronations - The South African - February 17th, 2017 [February 17th, 2017]
- Don't like your government? Just start a micronation like these 6 dudes - Mashable - February 11th, 2017 [February 11th, 2017]
- Talossa - Wikipedia - February 10th, 2017 [February 10th, 2017]
- Hetalia: The World Twinkle | Anime-Planet - December 16th, 2016 [December 16th, 2016]
- MicroWiki - micronations.wiki - December 15th, 2016 [December 15th, 2016]
- Micronation | Fifth World Wiki | Fandom powered by Wikia - December 9th, 2016 [December 9th, 2016]
- Micronation Wikipdia - November 21st, 2016 [November 21st, 2016]
- micronations! - wired.com - September 29th, 2016 [September 29th, 2016]
- Micronation - MicroWiki - Wikia - August 23rd, 2016 [August 23rd, 2016]
- List of Micronations - July 29th, 2016 [July 29th, 2016]
- 10 Bizarre Micronations - ODDEE - July 25th, 2016 [July 25th, 2016]
- United Micronations Multi-Oceanic Archipelago (UMMOA) - July 3rd, 2016 [July 3rd, 2016]
- MicroWiki - The Micronation.org Wiki - July 1st, 2016 [July 1st, 2016]
- Six Micronations You Can Join (Petoria, anyone?) - Neatorama - June 21st, 2016 [June 21st, 2016]
- Liste de micronations Wikipdia - June 19th, 2016 [June 19th, 2016]
- How to Start Your Own Micronation - June 17th, 2016 [June 17th, 2016]
- Micronation.org - The Micronation Site - June 17th, 2016 [June 17th, 2016]
- micronations! - WIRED - June 16th, 2016 [June 16th, 2016]