The 1973 Roe v. Wade case that legalized abortion in the U.S. painted an inaccurate picture of abortion at the time the 14th Amendment was adopted, according to Justice Samuel Alitos draft opinion overturning Roe.
More than half of Alitos 98-page draft opinion, in the pending Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization case, explores the history of U.S. abortion law in order to establish that the right to abortion is not deeply rooted in this nations history and tradition as it would have to be in order to be protected by the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment. He wrote that until the latter part of the 20th century, such a right was entirely unknown in American law.
In his discussion of the history of abortion law, Alito cited Joseph Dellapenna, Villanova Law professor emeritus and author of Dispelling the Myths of Abortion History who filed an amicus brief in the case.
Dellapenna told the Register that Roe gave an argument about the history of abortion in order to come up with a conclusion that there is an unenumerated right to choose abortion that is protected by the Constitution. Justice Harry Blackmun devoted between a third and a half of his Roe opinion rooting the idea that there is a constitutional right to choose to abort in his version of the history.
In the Roe decision, Blackmun wrote, it is undisputed that, at common law, abortion performed before quickening the first recognizable movement of the fetusin utero, appearing usually from the 16th to the 18th week of pregnancy was not an indictable offense. He also concluded that at common law, at the time of the adoption of our Constitution, and throughout the major portion of the 19th century, abortion was viewed with less disfavor than under most American statutes currently in effect.
In contrast, Alito wrote that under common law, abortion was criminal in at least some stages of pregnancy and was regarded as unlawful and could have very serious consequences at all stages, and that American law followed the common law until a wave of statutory restrictions in the 1800s expanded criminal liability for abortions. By the time of the adoption of the Fourteenth Amendment, three-quarters of the States had made abortion a crime at any stage of pregnancy, and the remaining States would soon follow.
Dellapenna said there are many examples of the common law restricting abortion throughout pregnancy. He noted that Blackmuns source for his claims was Cyril Means, a professor at New York Law School who was also the general counsel for the National Association for the Repeal of Abortion Laws (NARAL). As is apparent from his connection to NARAL, Means was hardly an unbiased historian. During the court proceeding for Roe, the legal team for the anonymous Jane Roe plaintiff circulated an internal memo admitting that Means conclusions sometimes strain credulity and fudge the history, but are useful because they preserve the guise of impartial scholarship while advancing the proper ideological goals.
Dellapenna said when Roe was handed down in January 1973, he was curious about this history that Justice Blackmun so heavily relied on, but it became apparent to him that whatever the historical truth was he wasn't interested in telling it. He said that after questions arose about Means historical account in Roe, he set out to recover the history of abortion in the common law world and found abortion cases in the colonies going back to the 1640s in Maryland and later dates in other colonies.
Alito cited some of the cases listed in Dellapennas book in his opinion and also quoted famed 18th-century English jurist William Blackstone who explained that abortion of a quick child was by the ancient law homicide or manslaughter and at least a very heinous misdemeanor. Alito wrote that English cases dating all the way back to the 13th century corroborate the treatises statements that abortion was a crime and noted that manuals for justices of the peace printed in colonies in the 18th century typically restated the common law rule on abortion.
Alito concluded that although common law authorities differed on the severity of punishment for abortions committed at different points in pregnancy, none endorsed the practice. Moreover, we are aware of no common law case or authority, and the parties have not pointed to any, that remotely suggests a positive right to procure an abortion at any stage of pregnancy.
Dellapenna also said the claim that abortion was only criminal in the common law after quickening was a false narrative, as statutes from the early 1800s call abortion a crime of a woman quick with child a term that was not the same as quickening. It's a late confusion or worse to equatequick with child with quickening, he said. Quick simply means alive. Dellapenna cited Henry de Bracton, an English jurist writing in the 13th century who was the first legal text writer on abortion and used formed and animated, noting that we get the word quick from animated...It means alive.
Dellapenna said the early abortion statutes do not say quickening, they say quick with child, meaning a live child. She could have a live child before quickening.
He referenced a common law case from the 1200s where the mother was attacked by two men who beat her with sticks until she aborted and nearly died and the baby was delivered. The baby was, according to the report of the case, of one month gestation. That couldn't possibly have quickened. ...The men involved were convicted of homicide and the homicide was the homicide of the child, so there's pretty clear, unambiguous evidence that quick child does not mean quickening, or movement by the child.
Justin Dyer, professor of political science and director of the Kinder Institute on Constitutional Democracy at the University of Missouri and author of Slavery, Abortion and the Politics of Constitutional Meaning, told the Register that his understanding of quickening was that to the extent that that it actually did mean something like felt fetal movement and mattered for abortion prosecutions, it was based on evidence for the presence of life and then that some act was the cause of death, it was not as the way that it's been commonly framed some kind of marker in pregnancy, at which point anything before that made abortion licit or actually protected as a liberty or a common law right of some sort.
Justice Alito wrote in a footnote in his opinion that the exact meaning of quickening is subject to some debate but that it suffices for present purposes to show that abortion was criminal by at least the 16th or 18th week of pregnancy and that during the relevant period i.e. the period surrounding the enactment of the Fourteenth Amendment the quickening distinction was abandoned as States criminalized abortion at all stages of pregnancy.
Dellapenna also contended that contrary to any notion that women were widely successful in quietly obtaining abortions pre-quickening, until sometime in the late 1700s, there was no safe way to do an abortion. Abortion was tantamount to suicide if it were voluntary. There was evidence through history in Europe and elsewhere around the world of infanticide and relatively little evidence of abortion until the late 1700s, he said.
He said that while pro-abortion rights historians will point to records of herbal methods to back claims about abortion being common, that didnt mean these methods were effective or safe. What he found was that these methods were either utterly ineffective like parsley or garlic or all too effective, working not by attacking the fetus or the embryo, but by debilitating the mother. In other words, killing her or nearly killing her so she loses the baby.
A recent Washington Post article looking at Alitos historical account noted that of the plant extracts believed to induce abortion savin, which comes from juniper bushes, was particularly effective and also plentiful in the United States. But it came with high risk; too much could be lethal to the woman. The article also noted the prevalence of infanticide, quoting British historian Kate Lister who found numerous British trial records for women accused of killing their newborns; between 1700 and 1800, there were 134 of these cases in a single London court.
Distorting History
Another element at play in the Supreme Courts examination of abortion history since Roe was the willingness on the part of some historians to back Roes historical narrative.
Dellapenna pointed out that in the 1989 Supreme Court case Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, there was an amicus brief signed by 281 historians attesting that as the Court demonstrated inRoe v. Wade,abortion was not illegal at common law and, Through the nineteenth century, American common law decisions uniformly reaffirmed that women committed no offense in seeking abortions. They also contended that concern over unborn life became a central issue in American culture only in the late twentieth century.
The briefs lead author, Sylvia Law, a law professor at New York University, wrote in an article afterwards that one of the briefs objectives was to support a political mobilization of pro-choice voices. She acknowledged a tension between truth-telling and advocacy, admitting to most serious deficiencies as truth-tellers on the part of the historians involved in the brief. An example of this that she gave was the failure of the briefs authors to grapple with the fact that most 19th-century feminists supported laws restricting access to abortion. She said the silence is distorting and added that there are also other distortions of the truth which are not simply a function of page limits or inability to agree, but rather flow from the advocacy form.
James Mohr, now a professor of history at the University of Oregon, who signed on to that brief, acknowledged afterwards that the brief was a political document. The brief seemed to contradict his own past work.
While he acknowledged in his book Abortion in America that abortions were illegal after fetal movement, the brief stated that the Court demonstrated inRoe v. Wade,abortion was not illegal at common law. And while the brief asserted that 19th-century laws restricting access to abortion were not based on a belief that the fetus is a human being, Mohr wrote that in the 19th century, physicians felt very strongly indeed on the issue of protecting human life. And once they had decided that the human life was present to some extent in a newly fertilized ovum, however limited that extent might be, they became fierce opponents of any attack upon it.
In 1990, Mohr told Notre Dame law professor Gerard Bradley that where inconsistencies exist he stood by the book rather than the brief, and he confessed that he was uncomfortable with the way his work was cited for some of the briefs claims.
In his draft Dobbs opinion, Alito pointed out issues he took with the amicus brief filed by the American Historical Association and their weak response to the fact by 1868 when the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified, three-quarters of the States, 28 out of 37, had enacted statutes making abortion a crime even if it was performed before quickening. The historians argued that Horatio Storer, a physician and proponent of strengthening anti-abortion laws, was motivated with his allies at the American Medical Association by the belief that abortions were endangering what he saw as the ideal America: a society of white Protestants in which women adhered strictly to their proper duties marriage and childbearing.
In response, Alito wrote, recall that at the time of the adoption of the Fourteenth Amendment, over three quarters of the States had adopted statutes criminalizing abortion (usually at all stages of pregnancy), and that from the early 20th century until the day Roe was handed down, every single State had such a law on its books. Are we to believe that the hundreds of lawmakers whose votes were needed to enact these laws were motivated by hostility to Catholics and women? There is ample evidence that the passage of these laws was instead spurred by a sincere belief that abortion kills a human being. Many judicial decisions from the late 19th and early 20th centuries made that point.
Visit link:
Correcting Roes Flawed Revision of Abortion History - National Catholic Register
- THIS DAY IN SPORTS HISTORY: 8/20 - Region Sports Network - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- This week in Loveland history for Aug. 20-26, 2023 - Loveland Reporter-Herald - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- August 20: ON THIS DAY IN HISTORY - Brooklyn Daily Eagle - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- How to Keep Track of Changes in Google Keep With Version History - MUO - MakeUseOf - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- This Week in History: Vienna Homecoming welcomes native sons ... - Warren Tribune Chronicle - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Avatar: The Last Airbender: The History of the Water Tribe - GameRant - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Edy Tavares and Cape Verde poised to make history at 2023 FIBA ... - Olympics - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- 10 all-time worst trades in Baltimore Orioles history - Birds Watcher - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Artists Komar and Melamid Give Lessons in History - The Moscow Times - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Butler welcomes the most diverse freshman class in university ... - WRTV Indianapolis - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Crow Fair 2023 packed with history and culture, and all are invited - Q2 News - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- The sunset of Sonic Youth: An oral history of the band's final U.S. show - NPR - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Russia, Ukraine and Versailles: Bogus lessons from history won't ... - Salon - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Opinion | The Georgia Indictment Speaks to History - The New York Times - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- UNC Football: A look at the 2023 schedule through the lens of history - Tar Heel Blog - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Types of public transports: Brief dive into history - Daily Sabah - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Red Sox infielder Luis Uras makes history with back-to-back grand ... - Yahoo Sports - August 20th, 2023 [August 20th, 2023]
- Ranking the top 10 running backs in Georgia football history - Red and Black - June 16th, 2023 [June 16th, 2023]
- The history of cyclical bull markets suggests the S&P 500 could rise ... - CNBC - June 16th, 2023 [June 16th, 2023]
- A history of healing | Hub - The Hub at Johns Hopkins - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- J. Harrison Ghee and Alex Newell on Making Tony History - TIME - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Pee Dee archaeologists hope to unearth Native American history - Charleston Post Courier - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Studying slavery and the history of Juneteenth | Rowan Today ... - Rowan Today - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- In a City of Monuments, History Lives Onstage and in the Streets - The New York Times - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Dua Lipa's Dating History: From Anwar Hadid to Romain Gavras - PEOPLE - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Kentucky Baseball's Homefield History In The NCAA Tournament - KSR - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Association of international scholars turns focus to history of women ... - Global Sisters Report - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Pat Mann Phillips makes Houston rodeo history as first woman elected to lead board of directors - Houston Public Media - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Tom Dwan Wins Largest Pot in Live-Stream Poker History ($3.1 ... - PokerNews.com - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- The history of spy animals; 'Blue Ribbon Kitchen' offers award ... - NPR - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- LOOKING BACK: A Vicksburg home with Stamps on history - The ... - Vicksburg Post - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- The Oldest Olympic Champions In Swimming History - SwimSwam - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- 'Tenacious' Guyer softball team aims for more history at second-ever ... - Denton Record Chronicle - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- HISTORY: Tennessee Towns That Failed to Launch - Main Street Media of Tennessee - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- A look at the history and influence of downtown San Diego's ... - ABC 10 News San Diego KGTV - May 31st, 2023 [May 31st, 2023]
- Learning the History and Customs of Martinsville Speedway - WSET - April 12th, 2023 [April 12th, 2023]
- World History Portal | Britannica - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Abstract paintings by Cleveland native John Moore reflect erasure of personal history as part of being Black - cleveland.com - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- My first day was a sex scene: the disturbing history of teen actors and nudity - The Guardian - January 10th, 2023 [January 10th, 2023]
- Local historian brings Oakland Countys history back to life with online lectures - C&G Newspapers - January 10th, 2023 [January 10th, 2023]
- VCUs medical college history found to be intimately connected with slavery, report finds - WRIC ABC 8News - January 10th, 2023 [January 10th, 2023]
- Dolphins Super Bowl history: When is the last time Miami made it to, won the Super Bowl? - NBC Sports - Misc. - January 10th, 2023 [January 10th, 2023]
- At the San Diego History Center, a historic donation - The San Diego Union-Tribune - January 6th, 2023 [January 6th, 2023]
- Arrest of squeegee kid reveals history of run-ins with drivers and police, records show - Fox Baltimore - January 6th, 2023 [January 6th, 2023]
- Tesla is now worth less than Exxon as stock plunges toward worst month, quarter and year in history - MarketWatch - December 21st, 2022 [December 21st, 2022]
- On this day in history, Dec. 21, 1945, Gen. Patton dies in Germany after he was paralyzed in auto crash - Fox News - December 21st, 2022 [December 21st, 2022]
- Vikings stun Colts: Matt Ryan has now been on the losing end of these four biggest blown leads in NFL history - CBS Sports - December 18th, 2022 [December 18th, 2022]
- What time will National Treasure: Edge of History air on Disney+? Release date, plot, and more details about the action-adventure series - Sportskeeda - December 12th, 2022 [December 12th, 2022]
- Mendocino County history: Willits Grade lumber spill, and other news from November 1948 - Ukiah Daily Journal - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- The Renaissance Run: Bruce Boudreau Named 14th Head Coach in Franchise History On This Day 15 Years Ago - NoVa Caps - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Qatar Make World Cup History As First Host Nation To Lose In Opening Game - Sports Illustrated - November 21st, 2022 [November 21st, 2022]
- History is best told through relatable human stories. - Monterey County Weekly - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- History made in China as Xi Jinping to serve third term - breaking decades-long precedent - Sky News - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- No matter who wins, the next Governor of Arkansas will make history - KNWA - October 21st, 2022 [October 21st, 2022]
- Ole Miss vs. LSU history: Last time they played, who has won the most games, best moments - DraftKings Nation - October 21st, 2022 [October 21st, 2022]
- What is witchcraft? The definition, the types and the history. - USA TODAY - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Women Reflected in Their Own History - Notes - E-Flux - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- History in the making: Wells is new museum director - Sent-trib - Sentinel-Tribune - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- And the West is History: Train Crossing 12th Street - 1966 - The Durango Herald - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- The Intimate and Interconnected History of the Internet - The Nation - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- The Haunted History of New England Presentation ~ October 23 - thebedfordcitizen.org - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- An Oil Company Planned to Bulldoze Black History. This Community Fought Back. - Earthjustice - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- New Tourist Attraction to Educate Tourists, Community on Manistee History - 9 & 10 News - 9&10 News - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- WATCH: Phillies' J.T. Realmuto hits inside-the-park home run, first catcher in postseason history - CBS Sports - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Mother-daughter race duo make history in Las Vegas: 'I hope we do it again' - Fox News - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- This week in history Oct. 14, 1922: Winter arrives and slows seasonal mining business - Summit Daily - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- LeBron James record watch: Where the Lakers star stands in history books before the season - CBS Sports - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- The history of Quinsippi Island | History | whig.com - Herald-Whig - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Miles grad makes largest alum donation in school history, hopes to be catalyst for giving to HBCUs - AL.com - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Investor Optimism Drops to One of 60 Lowest Readings in History - The Epoch Times - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Will short week hurt Chiefs vs. the Bills? Heres what history tells us - syracuse.com - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- The untold history of UC San Diego's terrible, weird and glorious single season of football - The San Diego Union-Tribune - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- The History Channel - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- What we risk by narrowly restricting our kids view of history and culture - Idaho Capital Sun - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- The history of Jewish admissions and experience at Stanford - Stanford Report - Stanford University News - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Snapshots of history coming to Glens Falls - NEWS10 ABC - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- How one Santa Cruz teacher teaches U.S. history and how she sees her role as a history teacher today - Lookout Santa Cruz - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- SDMHA Announce Cherokee History Event Oct. 15 And Other Upcoming Programs - The Chattanoogan - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- History book contest winners announced | The American Legion - The American Legion - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Christian Bale and Margo Robbie's 'Amsterdam' is on pace to lose $100 millionthese are the 10 biggest box office bombs in history - CNBC - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]