Following a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision closing the door on lawsuits for various violations of constitutional rights, the federal appeals court based in Denver has agreed an inmate may not sue a federal prison guard for allegedly assaulting him in his cell.
Anderson Coutinho Silva, who is incarcerated at the U.S. PenitentiaryAdministrative Maximum Facility in Florence, ran into resistancefrom the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit in his attempt to seek monetary damages from the guard who reportedly entered his cell while he was restrained, jumped on him, and called in other guards to cut off Silva's clothes.
Such lawsuits against federal employees are legally known as a "Bivens remedy," which the Supreme Court has applied to a limited set of constitutional violations. But after the Court's conservative majority in June severely restricted the scope of Bivens remedies to other constitutional rights, a three-judge panel for the 10th Circuit felt obligated to dismiss Silva's complaint.
"First and foremost, we are left in no doubt that expanding Bivens is not just 'a disfavored judicial activity,'" explained Senior Judge Bobby R. Baldock in an Aug. 1 order, "it is an action that is impermissible in virtually all circumstances."
The concept of a Bivens remedy stems from a 1971 Supreme Court decision, Bivens v.Six Unknown Named Agents.In that case, federal narcotics officers entered a man's home without a warrant, arrested and strip searched him. A majority of the Court decided plaintiff Webster Bivens could sue for a violation of the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures.
Since then, the Supreme Court has recognized a Bivens remedy exists for two other scenarios: sex discriminationunder the Fifth Amendment and deliberate indifference to an inmate's serious medical needs under the Eighth Amendment.
However, Baldock noted in the 10th Circuit's order, the Supreme Court subsequently"performed its own version of Bonapartes retreat from Moscow and progressively chipped away at the decision to the point that very little of its original force remains."
In early June, the Court handed down a 6-3 decision inEgbert v. Boule, in which the majority said a man who was allegedly beaten up by a U.S. Border Patrol agent may not sue for excessive force. While dissenting Justice Sonia Sotomayor believed theEgbertcase was "substantially similar" to that of Webster Bivens, the majority concluded Bivens remedies are not availablewhen Congress or the executive branch is "better equipped" to create a method for addressing constitutional violations.
For the Border Patrol, that amounted to an administrative process for handling grievances. Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for the majority, added that it is irrelevant whether such processes "do not provide complete relief" to someone whose constitutional rights are violated.
In Silva's lawsuit, he alleged corrections employee Brandon Shaw entered his cell, out of view of the security cameras, and beat him physically. Shaw reportedly radioed three other guards who "helped Officer Shawl (sic) hold me down and attacked me. ... They then took me to the restraint cell and cut my cloths (sic) off."
Silva, who represented himself, also claimed a guard threatened Silva if he did not drop his complaint. The lawsuit sought $10 million in damages, the discipline of all officers involved, and Silva's relocation from the Florence prison.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Michael E. Hegarty evaluated Silva's claims and recommended dismissing the lawsuit. A Bivens remedy, Hegarty concluded, was not available for the excessive force claim Silva was alleging, in large part because there was already a process for handling such complaints: filing an administrative grievance with the prison.
Silva protested that the prison's procedures were not as effective as a lawsuit.
"The institution grievance process has never worked since guards will not discipline other guards. That is why the defendant wants nothing more than to have everythingstay in-house where defendant's employer will sweep everythingunder the rug," Silva wrote.
Nonetheless, U.S. District Court Senior Judge Christine M. Arguello signed off on Hegarty's recommendation. Silva appealed to the 10th Circuit.
Represented by lawyersfrom Georgetown University Law Center and the nonprofit group Rights Behind Bars, Silva argued his claim of excessive force stemmed from the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Because the Supreme Court had already approved of a Bivens remedy under the same constitutional amendment failing to provide medical care to inmates Silva contended his lawsuit should be allowed to proceed.
"If this would be an extension of Bivens, it would be the most modest of modest extensions," attorney Samuel Weiss told the 10th Circuit panel during oral arguments in March. The government countered that excessive force and deliberate indifference to medical needs were not the same, and the court should not unilaterally permit inmates to sue for assaults by federal prison officials.
"It is certainly true that if there is a new claim and a new way for prison guards to be sued involving the use of force, they will have to hesitate and think twice," warned Assistant U.S. Attorney Karl L. Schock. "Now it may be that Congress decides thats a good thing. But that is a policy judgment that should be made by Congress."
Shortly after oral arguments, the Supreme Court issued its decision inEgbert.Baldock, writing for the panel, concluded the Supreme Court had given clear instructions not to expand a Bivens remedy to lawsuits like Silva's. Because excessive force is different from medical indifference, and given the existence of the prison's grievance process, Silva could not hold Shaw liable.
"We heed the Supreme Courts warning and decline Plaintiffs invitation to curry the Supreme Courts disfavor by expanding Bivens to cover his claim," Baldock wrote.
TheEgbertdecision reverberated through the federal judiciary almost immediately. In addition to Silva's case, a federal judge in Colorado recently dismissed a transgender inmate's similar assault claim against a prison guard, citing the restrictive new guidance from the Supreme Court.
"The law was already heading in this direction even beforeEgbert, but I thinkEgbertjust reinforces how rare the case will be today in which federal officers can be sued for damages for even the most egregious violation of our constitutional rights,"Stephen I. Vladeck, a professor at theUniversity of Texas School of Law, told Colorado Politics at the time.
The case is Silva v. United States et al.
Read the original:
SCOTUS decision prompts 10th Circuit to toss prisoner's lawsuit over alleged assault by guard - coloradopolitics.com
- Why Congress Must Reform FISA Section 702and How It Can - brennancenter.org - April 12th, 2024 [April 12th, 2024]
- CIA wants more power to spy on Americans - Washington Times - April 12th, 2024 [April 12th, 2024]
- Keyboard search warrants and the Fourth Amendment | Brookings - Brookings Institution - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Just Published: "Terms of Service and Fourth Amendment Rights" - Reason - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Can Texas police set up DWI checkpoints in Dallas-Fort Worth? Here's what to know - Yahoo News Canada - February 16th, 2024 [February 16th, 2024]
- The FBI's Lawless Raid on U.S. Private Vaults Shows Why the Founders Created the Fourth Amendment | Jon Miltimore - Foundation for Economic Education - February 16th, 2024 [February 16th, 2024]
- HCSO to release body cam footage to plaintiff alleging Fourth Amendment violation - Smoky Mountain News - December 19th, 2023 [December 19th, 2023]
- Section 702 surveillance doesn't belong in the NDAA - Defense One - December 16th, 2023 [December 16th, 2023]
- Valkyrie's Fourth Amendment for the Launch of a Bitcoin ETF - Crypto Times - December 16th, 2023 [December 16th, 2023]
- Digital justice: Supreme Court increasingly confronts law and the internet - Washington Times - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Trump and Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment: An Exploration ... - JURIST - October 13th, 2023 [October 13th, 2023]
- Expert Q&A with David Aaron on FISA Section 702 Reauthorization ... - Just Security - October 13th, 2023 [October 13th, 2023]
- A Constitution the Government Evades - Tenth Amendment Center - October 13th, 2023 [October 13th, 2023]
- First and Fourth Amendment Claims Over Arrest at Protest of Police ... - Reason - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Law enforcement violation of the fourth amendment - Daily Kos - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- D.C. Appeals Court weighs whether phone seizures from 2020 ... - Washington Times - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Opinion: Why you shouldn't turn on your phone in church Palo Alto ... - The Daily Post - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Court attorneys group hosts CLE seminar with esteemed Justice ... - Brooklyn Daily Eagle - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Former Dona Ana County Deputy Sheriff Charged with Federal Civil ... - Department of Justice - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Editorial: Renters rights ruling | Opinion - nwestiowa.com - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- U.S. Attorney's Statement Regarding Proposed Changes to Crime ... - Department of Justice - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- New Jersey provides a road map for fighting racially biased traffic ... - Slate - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Animal rights advocates sue after facing ongoing censorship and ... - Foundation for Individual Rights in Education - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Gerald Jako Pleads Guilty to Two Counts of Murder in Ohio County - Wheeling Intelligencer - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Supreme Court of Appeals Visits Campus The Parthenon - MU The Parthenon - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Securities and Exchange Board of India (Listing Obligations and ... - Tax Management India. Com - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Legal Strategies For A Strong Defense Against Bribery Accusations - American Judicature Society - September 25th, 2023 [September 25th, 2023]
- Police get new images of area break-in suspect - Southwest Virginia Today - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Napolitano: Is the CIA in your underwear? | News, Sports, Jobs - Standard-Examiner - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Bulletin: Maryland Juvenile Services Head Says Violence Among ... - The Trace - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Tased horseman's excessive force claims clear bar Rhode Island ... - Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- The absurdity of fact-checkers | Columnists | leader-call.com - leader-call.com - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Facial Recognition Technology and False Arrests: Should Black ... - Capital B - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Letter to the editor - Southeast Iowa Union - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Petition hopes to stop US government agencies from using ... - Cointelegraph - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Passing on the legacy of 9/11 to the next generation The ... - The Duquesne Duke - September 15th, 2023 [September 15th, 2023]
- Congress Should Reauthorize a Key Intelligence Tool - Foreign Policy Research Institute - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Kansas City police made arrests based on rescinded warrants ... - Kansas Reflector - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Tased horsemans excessive force claims clear bar - Virginia Lawyers Weekly - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Ball is in AL's court - newagebd.net - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Lawsuit against police chief just the latest shoe to drop in Marion ... - Kansas Reflector - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- In the wake of Idalia, residents of one Florida town are turning to ... - Poynter - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- NYPD using drones to monitor NYC backyard Labor Day parties, spurring privacy concerns - NBC New York - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- City of Grand Rapids dismissed, lawsuit against Christopher Schurr ... - FOX 17 West Michigan News - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- OSHA's Proposed Rule Would Allow Union Walkthroughs of All ... - Fisher Phillips - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Letters From Readers, Aug. 31, 2023 | Opinion | avpress.com - Antelope Valley Press - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Where are the Noah's Park animals? - The Pike County Courier - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- His hands were up: Attorney for football game shooting victim says civil rights violated - Yahoo News - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- NYC voters explain why theyre voting for RFK Jr. over Biden: Going ... - 1330 WFIN - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Houston Food Not Bombs in Court over Feeding the Unhoused - The Texas Observer - September 5th, 2023 [September 5th, 2023]
- Search and seizure Equal protection Discriminatory policing - Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- The Timing of Computer Search Warrants When It Takes the ... - Reason - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Councilmembers Inquired About Pretext Stops By Police One Year ... - Pasadena Now - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- BARINGS BDC, INC. : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Creation of a Direct Financial Obligation or an Obligation under an Off-Balance Sheet... - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Alabama appeals court reverses murder conviction of Ala. officer ... - Police News - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Oakland narrows town manager search to five | West Orange Times ... - West Orange Times & SouthWest Orange Observer - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- The Durham Report Is Right About the Need for More FBI Oversight - Reason - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Collective knowledge doctrine applies to a traffic stop - Police News - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Interpretation: The Fourth Amendment | Constitution Center - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Public Schools :: Fourth Amendment -- Search and Seizure :: US ... - January 2nd, 2023 [January 2nd, 2023]
- BSE : Securities and Exchange Board of India (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) (Fourth Amendment) Regulations, 2022 - Marketscreener.com - November 27th, 2022 [November 27th, 2022]
- Trump legal counsel vows 'Fourth Amendment based' challenge to Mar-a ... - October 21st, 2022 [October 21st, 2022]
- Get to Know the EFA: Digital Fourth - EFF - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Arguments heard in body in trunk case | News, Sports, Jobs - Minot Daily News - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Ormond Beach Planning Board to meet Thursday - Ormond Beach Observer - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Limiting the Power of Police in Schools - The Regulatory Review - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Letter to the Editor: What Republicans Believe - Door County Pulse - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Trump wants other presidents investigated - KRLD - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Trump Rally Speech Shows He's 'Guilty and Scared': Former Prosecutor - Newsweek - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Court Strips Immunity From Cop Who Shot A Dog Within Seconds Of Arriving On The Scene Of A Non-Crime - Techdirt - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Claiming to have 4.3 trillion readers, the Onion supports parodist and its writers' paychecks in SCOTUS brief - ABA Journal - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- INHIBRX, INC. : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Creation of a Direct Financial Obligation or an Obligation under an Off-Balance Sheet... - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- PennLive goes to court for records related to U.S. Rep. Scott Perrys cell phone - PennLive - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Rusty Hardin & Associates Strengthens Litigation Team with Addition of Attorney Aisha Dennis - PR Newswire - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Vancouver City Council asked to OK $725000 deal with family of man killed by police - The Columbian - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Govt plans to auction 22 mineral blocks in 3 states within next two months - Business Standard - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Fort Worth officers sued after being accused of violating rights - WFAA.com - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- LSU professors, students weigh in on constitutionality of room scans for online exams - The Reveille, LSU's student newspaper - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Solution for ideological division: Revising the Constitution? - The Christian Science Monitor - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Lawsuit says teen was thrown in solitary confinement and abused inside Maine's youth prisons - observer-me.com - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]