The allowance of postpetition interest in solvent debtor chapter 11 cases has become an important issue in recent years for corporate issuers, bondholders and other creditors. This post will examine a recent decision in the Hertz case by Judge Mary Walrath of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware on the rate of interest payable to unsecured creditors who are entitled under the Bankruptcy Code to full payment of their claims under a plan of reorganization. (Judge Walrath also addressed other topics in her decision pertaining to the allowance of make-whole premiums, which were examined in an earlier post.)
The Hertz Corporation filed for protection under chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code in May 2020, its business decimated by the Covid-19 pandemic. In little more than a year, however, it had recovered so successfully that it was able to propose a plan of reorganization that purported to pay unsecured creditors in full.
Hertz claimed that under its plan, the holders of its over $2.7 billion of unsecured bonds were unimpaired. Hertzs plan proposed to pay the bondholders the full principal amount of the bonds, and interest accrued during the course of the chapter 11 case at the federal judgment rate rather than the significantly higher rate set forth under the terms of the bonds and the indentures.
The bondholders disputed that their claims were unimpaired because, among other things, the plan did not provide for payment at the contract rate under the indentures. They also argued that a pre-Bankruptcy Code equitable doctrine commonly known as the solvent debtor exception entitled them to full payment of interest.
The two sides agreed to let the plan proceed to confirmation and have Judge Walrath determine afterwards what the bondholders were entitled to receive. Post-confirmation, Hertz moved to dismiss the bondholders claims for postpetition interest at the contract rate under the indentures.
Judge Walraths Analysis
In her decision on Hertzs motion to dismiss the claims, Judge Walrath looked at the Bankruptcy Code to resolve whether the contract rate or the federal judgment rate would apply on any allowed postpetition interest.
Non-Impairment Under the Bankruptcy Code, creditors claims are unimpaired if the plan . . . leaves unaltered the legal, equitable and contractual rights of the holder of such claim. Unimpaired creditors do not have a right under the Bankruptcy Code to vote to accept or reject a proposed plan, but are instead deemed to accept. The bondholders asserted that their treatment as unimpaired creditors under the plan entitled them to all of their rights under the indentures, including the payment of both the make-whole premiums and interest at the contract rate.
Judge Walrath disagreed. In most chapter 11 cases, section 502(b) of the Bankruptcy Code expressly disallows claims for unmatured interest, i.e, interest which had not yet accrued as of the commencement of the case. She cited a Third Circuit decision, PPI Enterprises, that held that a creditors claim was not impaired if the claim was limited or disallowed not by the plan itself, but rather by the Bankruptcy Code as a matter of law. Since section 502(b) disallows claims for unmatured interest, the failure under the plan to provide for payment of future unpaid interest would not constitute impairment.
Solvent Debtor Exception The bondholders cited a number of pre-Bankruptcy Code cases which held that where a debtor is solvent, creditors are entitled to contract rate interest on their claims and other contractual rights before any value should go to shareholders.
The bondholders pointed to a recent decision by Judge Marvin Isgur in the Southern District of Texas who, faced with similar issues in the case of Ultra Petroleum Corp., ruled that the solvent debtor exception remained good law and effectively overrode section 502(b)s disallowance of unmatured interest with respect to solvent debtors and required the payment of interest at the contract rate.
Judge Walrath acknowledged the solvent debtor exception, but interpreted it more narrowly than Judge Isgur. She pointed to section 726(a)(5) of the Bankruptcy Code, which provides for payment of interest at the legal rate in solvent debtor chapter 7 liquidation cases, and section 1129(a)(7) of the Bankruptcy Code, which mandates that impaired creditors be treated as well under a chapter 11 plan as they would under a hypothetical chapter 7 case.
Judge Walrath determined that the weight of caselaw authority viewed the legal rate under section 726(a)(5) as the federal judgment rate rather than contract rate interest. Reasoning further that Congress could not have intended for unimpaired creditors to be treated worse than impaired creditors, she held that the solvent debtor exception required payment of accrued and unpaid interest on the bonds at the federal judgment rate.
Judge Walrath recognized the solvent debtor exception to the disallowance of unmatured interest under section 502(b), but only to the extent of requiring payment of accrued postpetition interest at the federal judgment rate.
Value fluctuations stemming from the pandemic disruption and the subsequent rapid recovery, and ongoing economic volatility and uncertainty means that more solvent debtor cases can be expected moving forward into 2022. Given the influence of the Delaware Bankruptcy Court in large chapter 11 cases, Judge Walraths analysis in Hertz will inform the calculations of debtors and bondholders during plan negotiations in such cases.
Originally posted here:
- 'I would use the word terrifying' | Lessons learned 10 years later from Stockton's historic bankruptcy - ABC10.com KXTV - June 29th, 2022
- Laos Is On the Brink of Sovereign Bankruptcy - The Diplomat - June 29th, 2022
- Analysis: Meme stock investors bet on bankrupt Revlon being the next Hertz - Reuters - June 29th, 2022
- NYC Office Tower Ch. 11 Shines Light On Blocking Provisions - Law360 - June 29th, 2022
- The interplay between benefits under a trust and bankruptcy: A beneficiary cannot shield its obligations to creditors by hiding behind the terms of a... - June 29th, 2022
- Connecticut Bankruptcy Courts Rule That New Homestead Act Applies Retroactively to Claims Arising Before Acts Effective Date - JD Supra - June 29th, 2022
- [COLUMN] Is there life after bankruptcy? - Asian Journal News - June 29th, 2022
- ERGO Analysing Developments Impacting Business: Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) (Second... - June 29th, 2022
- Katie Price dodges another court date as bankruptcy hearing put back to 2023 - Yahoo News - June 22nd, 2022
- Injuries, Creative Bankruptcy Force WWE to Turn to John Cena, Brock Lesnar - Bleacher Report - June 22nd, 2022
- Artesian Builds auctions thousands of PC components to pay off bankruptcy - Wccftech - June 22nd, 2022
- Telangana on the brink of bankruptcy due to Central Govt, RBI curbs - The Siasat Daily - June 22nd, 2022
- The Powers Of The Foreign Bankrupt Company And The Foreign Bankruptcy Administrator To Act Before The Swiss Authorities In Case Of Fraud -... - June 22nd, 2022
- Debt Consolidation Vs. Bankruptcy: What Is The Difference? Forbes Advisor - Forbes - June 20th, 2022
- Imps Week In Wrestling Vince McMahon: Hush Money and Creative Bankruptcy - Wrestling Headlines - June 20th, 2022
- TPC Group files for bankruptcy with thousands still awaiting payouts; attorney Brent Coon responds - Port Arthur News - The Port Arthur News - June 5th, 2022
- Bankruptcy 101: Lease Assumption, Assignment, and Rejection - Bankruptcy Basics for New and Non-Bankruptcy Attorneys - JD Supra - June 5th, 2022
- Amber Heard can't file for bankruptcy to wipe $15 million she now owes Johnny Depp - Marca English - June 5th, 2022
- Why Now Is the Perfect Time to Declare 'Meeting Bankruptcy' and Rethink Your Schedule - Inc. - June 5th, 2022
- It's the Law: What can I keep in bankruptcy? - Post Register - June 5th, 2022
- Truth Social Buyer Warns of Bankruptcy Risk Given Trump's Past Failures - Newsweek - May 17th, 2022
- Canadian businesses bankruptcies surge and some fear this is just the beginning - Toronto Star - May 17th, 2022
- Violations of the Bankruptcy Discharge Injunction | Freeman Law - JDSupra - JD Supra - May 17th, 2022
- SCOTUS To Review Spending Clause, Overtime, and Bankruptcy Fraud - The National Law Review - May 17th, 2022
- Is BBBY Stock Headed for Bankruptcy? One Analyst Thinks So. - InvestorPlace - May 17th, 2022
- Ukraine Has Exposed The Bankruptcy Of Germany's "Never Again" Pacifism - Worldcrunch - May 17th, 2022
- Violations Of The Bankruptcy Discharge Injunction - Insolvency/Bankruptcy - United States - Mondaq - May 9th, 2022
- Total April Bankruptcy Filings Decrease 21 Percent Over the Same Period Last Year - GlobeNewswire - May 9th, 2022
- What's happening in Sri Lanka? Country facing worst economic crisis and on the brink of bankruptcy - Sky News - May 9th, 2022
- A&G Bankruptcy Sale Offers Over 50 Properties in and around Manhattan, Kansas - PR Newswire - May 9th, 2022
- Al Zawawi and 109(a): Parsing What It Means to Be a Debtor Under Chapter 15 - JD Supra - May 9th, 2022
- Sri Lanka Is on the Brink of Bankruptcy - The Diplomat - May 9th, 2022
- A Day Late and Nearly $5 Million Short?: Legislation Introduced to Make Permanent the $7.5 Million Subchapter V Debt Limit As Temporary Extensions... - March 29th, 2022
- [COLUMN] Bankruptcy: When you've done everything you can but it's still not good enough - Asian Journal News - March 29th, 2022
- New Slovak legislation on solving threatened bankruptcy - Lexology - March 29th, 2022
- Two Recent Chapter 15 Cases Clarify Just How Low the Bar Is for Recognition - JD Supra - March 29th, 2022
- The Parent Company of These Steakhouses Just Filed For Bankruptcy Eat This Not That - Eat This, Not That - March 26th, 2022
- Medical debt isn't all that indicative of bankruptcy - Washington Examiner - March 26th, 2022
- 'Broken heart': Read the CEO's letter to Black News Channel employees announcing closure - Tallahassee Democrat - March 26th, 2022
- Meet Nicole Barham: From Bankruptcy Court To Entrepreneur Helping Other Women Design Their Wealth - Black Enterprise - March 26th, 2022
- Seadrill Expects to Emerge from Bankruptcy This Week - The Maritime Executive - February 24th, 2022
- Solomon: Is it too late to save more restaurants from bankruptcy? - Boston Herald - February 24th, 2022
- Is It Too Late to Save More Restaurants From Bankruptcy? InsideSources - InsideSources - February 21st, 2022
- Bankruptcy resolution shifting to fast track - Mint - February 21st, 2022
- Philippine Airlines soars from brink of bankruptcy to profitability: how it happened - Gulf News - February 21st, 2022
- Pensions: what's new this week February 2022 # 3 | Allen & Overy LLP - JDSupra - JD Supra - February 21st, 2022
- Senior Living Drives Health Care Industry Distress in Final Quarter of 2021 - GlobeNewswire - February 21st, 2022
- Months of debts, promises and guilt trips: Woman declares bankruptcy after $240k 'pig-butchering' scam - AsiaOne - February 21st, 2022
- Five years of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code: A promising journey - BusinessLine - February 21st, 2022
- Chapter 11 Bankruptcy: What You Need To Know - Forbes - February 19th, 2022
- These Restaurants Are Nearing Bankruptcy, Recent Data Shows Eat This Not That - Eat This, Not That - February 19th, 2022
- Podcast: The awful sound of Shelley Luthers moral bankruptcy - San Antonio Express-News - February 19th, 2022
- What You Need to Know About Filing for Bankruptcy with a Reverse Mortgage - Lawyers.com Blog - February 19th, 2022
- Florida Orange Forecast Drops and Chapter 12 Farm Bankruptcy Filings Down - AG INFORMATION NETWORK OF THE WEST - AGInfo Ag Information Network Of The... - February 19th, 2022
- Evander Kane bankruptcy trustee wants to sue firm that arranged his loans - The Athletic - February 19th, 2022
- 2021 was one of the worst years in decades for BigLaw bankruptcy practices - ABA Journal - February 15th, 2022
- Lawyers in 2 states sanctioned over association with national bankruptcy law firm - ABA Journal - February 15th, 2022
- Bankruptcy Discharge: What Is It? Forbes Advisor - Forbes - February 15th, 2022
- A Wave of Bankruptcies and Foreclosures Appears to be Building - Kiplinger's Personal Finance - February 15th, 2022
- Latham & Watkins Advises Huachen Energy on Innovative Bond Restructuring and the First-Ever US Chapter 15 Recognition of a PRC Bankruptcy... - February 15th, 2022
- How PMPML drove on the long route to bankruptcy - Hindustan Times - February 15th, 2022
- The Moral Bankruptcy of a Violent StateProtesting Prison Expansion & Documenting Police Beatings at the Arkansas State Capitol (INCLUDING VIDEO).... - February 15th, 2022
- Cross-Border Bankruptcy Cases: Chapter 15 of the Bankruptcy Code and Parameters of a Discovery Tool - JD Supra - February 15th, 2022
- Bankruptcy Court Protects Creditors And Banks Holding Garnished Funds - Lexology - February 15th, 2022
- They ask to decree the bankruptcy of Correo Argentino: the decision will fall on the Economic Criminal Chamber - Then24.com - February 15th, 2022
- Richard Osman's House of Games: David James' life from bankruptcy to unusual second career - Birmingham Live - February 15th, 2022
- Lawyers to discuss whether letters to archbishop will be included in bankruptcy trial - Guam Pacific Daily News - February 11th, 2022
- Guatemala - changes in the regulations regarding insolvencies and bankruptcy: approval of the law on insolvencies, by virtue of which the existing... - February 11th, 2022
- End the free passes at bankruptcy court - bedfordgazette.com - February 9th, 2022
- Moving Up: Bankruptcy Code Dollar Amounts Will Increase On April 1, 2022 - Insolvency/Bankruptcy/Re-structuring - United States - Mondaq News Alerts - February 9th, 2022
- Bifurcated Fee Agreements Approved in Southern District of Florida, But Barred in Western District of Kentucky - JD Supra - February 9th, 2022
- Bankruptcy court temporarily stays auction of Gujarat-based Sterling Biotech - Economic Times - February 9th, 2022
- Puerto Rico may be nearing the end of bankruptcy. What does this mean? - ABC News - February 7th, 2022
- One-year bankruptcy is back on the table - Insolvency/Bankruptcy/Re-structuring - Australia - Mondaq News Alerts - February 7th, 2022
- Novosibirsk court began bankruptcy proceedings for an operator for the treatment of MSW - Then24 - February 7th, 2022
- Andrew Garfield Once Explained Why Bankruptcy Was the 'Best Thing' to Happen to His Family - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - February 7th, 2022
- Bankruptcy confusion leads to loss of home - New Zealand Herald - February 7th, 2022
- U.S. Court Of Appeals and Bankruptcy Appellate Panel ... - February 5th, 2022
- Brian Serpone takes the Fifth at Levee Breaks bankruptcy hearing - Cape Cod Times - February 5th, 2022
- Amid bankruptcy, breakfast remains off the table at Wilmington K&W - Greater Wilmington Business Journal - February 5th, 2022