By Carlos Gutierrez*
Most attendees will never forget that football match. It was Saturday, September 10, and Deportivo Independiente Medellin (DIM) and Santa Fe were facing each other. It was memorable, not because of what happened on the pitch, but for what was going on in the bleachers. Sebastian Pamplona, a young man with a terminal illness, went to the stadium to fulfill his last wish: watching the DIM (his favorite team) play before being euthanized. Thousands of fans and players chanted his name in deeply poignant moments.
Colombia is a pioneer in decriminalizing euthanasia in Latin America. The law authorized it, back in 2015, for patients with terminal illnesses. Physicians must undertake the procedure with prior authorization of the respective Interdisciplinary-Scientific Committee to Die with Dignity.
Aside from Sebastians story, the debate to decriminalize and regulate euthanasia is back in the news in Latin America. In early February, the Constitutional Court of Ecuador decriminalized euthanasia in its active form, after a woman, 42, Paola Roldan, made a plea on social media to request the legalization of assisted death, in August 2023.
Three years ago, Paola was diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and she has been immobilized for more than six months, without chances to improve. Those being her circumstances, she recruited a team of lawyers to demand her right to die with dignity to the Court. Along the process, she became a symbol of the fight to decriminalize euthanasia not only in Ecuador but in Latin America.
Although etymologically euthanasia meansgood death, it refers to ending the life of a person with an incurable or irreversible disease. It implies administering painless means to avoid the continuation of grave physical suffering. Oftentimes, it takes place in clinical contexts in which a third party, usually a doctor or group of doctors, is in charge of performing the procedure. The third party sets in motion a chain of events leading to the final outcome, controlling the result at all times, explains Carlos Molina-Ricaurte, of Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia, in a chapter of the book Las identidades analizadas a traves de las segregaciones historico-culturales.
Globally, a mere nine nations have decriminalized and legalized the intervention. The Netherlands walked that path first, in April 2002. A month later, Belgium followed, and so did Luxembourg in 2009. In 2016, Canada joined them, and New Zealand in 2020. Spain legislated on it in July 2021, and Portugal in 2023. And In Australia, euthanasia is allowed only in the state of New South Wales, which authorized it in 2022.
In the United States, from 1997 to 2017, ten states legislated on assisted suicide for people over 18 who had a life prognosis shorter than six months. Unlike euthanasia, assisted suicide requires no intervention by a third party. It is defined as the action of a person suffering an irreversible disease to terminate his or her life. To do so, he or she has to have the support of practitioners that provide knowledge and means. Since 2020, it is not prosecuted in Germany and in Italy, where it is admitted in very special cases. Austria and Switzerland consider it only if the motive is not against the law.
In 2022, Colombia decriminalized assisted suicide for people with grave or incurable diseases. That same year, Victor Escobar, a 60-year-old driver, was the first Colombian to be euthanized without having an illness in the terminal stage. He had had cerebrovascular accidents, as well as obstructive pulmonary disease and hypertension. His battle opened doors for patients behind me who wish to die with dignity, Victor said in a farewell video published by the newspaper El Tiempo.
In Cuba, last December, the National Assembly of Peoples Power passed a new law by which it admits the right of people to die with dignity by arranging the decisions for the end of their lives, which may include the limitation of therapy, continuous or palliative care and valid conducts that put an end to their lives. The law, however, will only become effective when the legislature passes the regulation for its application.
Eneyda Suer, Mexican professor at Instituto Tecnologico y de Estudios Superiores de Occidente (ITESO), thinks that euthanasia should be legal and not just decriminalized, because that would open the door to serious, strict and dutiful protocols. Otherwise, it will continue taking place surreptitiously, carelessly and without adequate protocol. In his text, Molina-Ricaurte admits that in the case of Colombia, neither euthanasia nor assisted suicide have been sufficiently regulated. It is a fair demand to legislate on the matter.
Mexicos General Health Law forbids euthanasia, assisted suicide and mercy killing. However, there is the option of anticipated will, a legal figure through which someone with a terminal disease, or a forecast of one, may plan treatment and care for the end of life. One of the purposes of this resource is to respect the patients will, as well as guaranteeing a natural death in dignified conditions, says the Mexican Health Secretariat.
One of the arguments in favor of legalization is the right to make choices pertaining to our own lives. Neither assisted suicide nor euthanasia harm the rights of third parties. And we all know, as the popular adage says: my rights end where yours begin, states Marina Arias, lawyer of the Ministry of Public Defense of Paraguay.
Discussions around euthanasia are full of complexities and myths. Topics that have to do with morality are usually taboo. Theres abortion, euthanasia, surrogacy, homosexuality Suer says. From her point of view, euthanasia should be legislated because it is about coexisting. And in coexisting, we must admit that there are some facts that, albeit unpleasant, occur. So, why not legalize and create protocols to effectively respect a person?
Some studies address the influence of religion. It is clear that religiousness is negatively associated with accepting euthanasia or assisted suicude. As explained by Norma Ordoez and a team of researchers at Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), in the article entitled Exploracion del discurso de los enfermos cronicos sobre la legalizacion de la muerte asistida.
But this brings upon controversy. Miguel Pastorino, PhD in philosophy and director of Centro Core at Universidad Catolica de Uruguay, considers it a myth to argue that the main stance against euthanasia is religiously driven. If you read documents by Catholic bishops, and I just read the one written by the bishops of Ecuador, their arguments appeal to human rights instead of to religion. The question is: Is it a human right to demand induced death? Or, as it is almost everywhere thus far, is it a human rights violation to end someones life even though he or she asked for it? In other words, what we have are two conflicting points of view on human rights, he underscores.
Lawyer Arias claims that at the moment of legalizing, the right that would prevail the most would be the right of autonomy. So, to what extent are we allowed to make decisions about ourselves? she wonders. She alleges that the existence of laws that criminalize euthanasia and assisted suicide means that the State is meddling on when a person can decide over his or her body. She also supports that mental illnesses should be taken into account when legalizing euthanasia.
Pastorino adds that it is a myth to confuse euthanasia with palliative or terminal sedation. It is not an undercover form of euthanasia, as many people think, he says. It is about inducing a coma for the personal to die naturally, but unconsciously. It simply makes death less atrocious, it makes it peaceful. That is ethically correct. It is legal, he explains.
For Pastorino, the law in favor of euthanasia allows physicians to kill patients. The problem is that it has been sweetened and romanticized. He believes the only argument for it is compassion towards the patients suffering, but that can be alleviated with proper palliative care. He highlights that, in that regard, there is a problem of social injustice that is frequently overlooked, since many people dont even have access to palliative care.
In an interview with the Uruguayan radio show En perspectiva, Spanish oncologist and palliative care physician Enric Benito talked about his experience with Fernando Sureda, former manager of the Uruguayan Football Association. In 2018, after being diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, he requested an euthanasia to the Uruguayan legal system, to no avail. Due to the pandemic, Benito virtually accompanied Sureda in his last days.
The documentary Hay una puerta ahi is a compilation of videos of those meetings, and it shows Sureda reconsidered the possibility of euthanasia. Based on this experience, the persons real intention is to put an end to suffering. And it is more elegant, more professional, and more humane, to put an end to suffering instead of ending a life.
Gerardo Perez-Mendoza, researcher of Laboratorio de Genetica at Universidad Autonoma de Yucatan, proposes considering the opinion of physicians. He thinks that many resist doing it because it is against their professional principles. Their oath dictates that they must seek to save or alleviate the patient.
In 2020, the Medical Association of Uruguay conducted a poll that revealed doctors in that country had a very favorable attitude towards the approval of legislation to enable euthanasia in its active form. In 62% of the cases, they responded in favor with total certainty.
In any case, the role of doctors would have to be closely monitored to avoid the likelihood of malpractice. In a text published in Prudencia Uruguay. En defensa de la dignidad humana, Carlos Maria Schroeder, honorary professor of Universidad de la Republica, refers to an official report of the Canadian Medical Association in which 120 Belgian nurses admitted to having performed euthanasia without the patients request. He states that in countries where it has been approved, the practice of palliative care has truly decreased: the medical community has been strongly deterred from pursuing that type of care, in the face of mounting unruly, and oftentimes, unjustified cases of euthanasia.
Most experts interviewed for this article agree that many of the controversies on the matter are among healthy people and at theoretical level. There arent many studies with people living with diseases in the terminal stage. People who really wish to be euthanized are not in conditions to manifest their intentions or to sign documents. Normally, they realize they wish for it when they are in a terminal stage and in a lot of pain, Suer says.
The stance of sick patients on this topic is relevant to have enough elements aimed at a prospective regulation, from the bioethics, medical and legal perspectives, UNAM researchers expound.
The topic requires serious analyses and dialogue between professionals from different disciplines. In the meantime, Pastorino recommends moving forward on better palliative care, on laws of anticipated will, on health care, on providing support to patients in pain and their families. For this expert, whose thesis in bioethics was on euthanasia, the discussions tend to be in black and white, in heated defenses for or against. And, well, this is not a football match.
Each week, CONNECTAS, the Latin American journalism platform, publishes an analysis of relevant events in the Americas. If you are interested in this information, click hereeste enlace.
*Member of the editorial board at CONNECTAS
Read more here:
To Suffer or To Live: The Dilemma of Euthanasia - CONNECTAS - Connectas
- Death of Catholic former Dutch prime minister highlights 'duo euthanasia' trend in Netherlands - Catholic Herald Online - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- The Deadly Trend of Double Euthanasia The European Conservative - The European Conservative - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Humane Society of Central Texas asks for help as overpopulation threatens animals with euthanasia - KWTX - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Ending euthanasia is 'an act of love,' says Canadian activist. Published Feb. 20 2024. World. - The Pilot - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- 'Duo euthanasia' of former prime minister unveils growing trend in the Netherlands - Evangelical Focus - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- All you need to know about euthanasia - Nation - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Home with Dignity Enters Cincinnati, Ohio, Revolutionizing In-Home Euthanasia for Pets - PR Newswire - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Despite postponement, Canadian government 'fully committed' to expanding assisted suicide, warn country's bishops - Catholic Herald Online - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Dame Esther Rantzen explained main reason why she's choosing to die by euthanasia - LADbible - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Dame Esther Rantzen's heartbreaking last wish after she prepares for euthanasia - The Mirror - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- Dame Esther Rantzen reveals her final wish as she prepares for euthanasia - LADbible - February 24th, 2024 [February 24th, 2024]
- "My Last Day Will Be Saturday": Dutch Woman, 28, Shares Final Post Before Being Euthanised - NDTV - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Opinion | The aid-in-dying question - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Enjoy A Last Morbid Meme: Dutch Woman Has Funny Final Meme Before Undergoing Euthanasia - Bored Panda - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Opponents of nitrogen executions bill cite Ohio's ban on gas for pet euthanasia - The Statehouse News Bureau - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Euthanasia for mentally ill off the table in Canada for now - GZERO Media - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Odin the dog rescued from euthanasia - Lincoln - KOLN - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- 'My last day will be on Saturday': 28-year-old with ME shares final post before being euthanised - Yahoo News UK - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Odin the dog rescued from euthanasia - Lawton - KSWO - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Organ-Harvesting Requested from Those to Be Killed by Euthanasia in Quebec - National Review - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Austin Animal Center to follow new euthanasia rules for dogs with severe bite histories - Community Impact - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Dogs at Mission shelter at risk of euthanasia due to overcrowding - KRGV - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Decision Made with Regard to a Proposed Referendum on Euthanasia - Hungary Today - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Execution method used on Alabama inmate has pro-euthanasia activists worried - Live Action - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- 28-year-old Dutch woman dies by euthanasia after documenting her battle with 'chronic fatigue syndrome' - The New Indian Express - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Canada delays plans to make euthanasia on the grounds of mental illness alone legal - Right To Life UK - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- 'My last day will be Saturday - Woman, 28, shares harrowing post before euthanasia - The Mirror - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Family with children suffering from rare disease seeks euthanasia | Kerala | Onmanorama - Onmanorama - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- MAiD for mental illness must be stopped, not paused, Catholic and legal experts say - The B.C. Catholic - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- South Australian figures show 110 people used euthanasia to end their lives - CathNews - February 3rd, 2024 [February 3rd, 2024]
- Euthanasia Rates on the Rise as Dog Adoptions Slow Down - Yahoo Life - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Is Disney Building a New Roller Coaster Designed To Kill You? - Snopes.com - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Euthanasias effect on culture and society - Valencia County News Bulletin - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Arson Detection Pit Bull Hansel Escaped Euthanasia - Daily Paws - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Imagining Death | Sarah O'Dell - First Things - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- UPDATE: Fort Bend County animal shelter over 250% of capacity ... - Community Impact - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Sister Dogs and Their Puppies Spared Euthanasia Face 'Cruel Twist ... - Newsweek - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- One way to escape malpractice lawsuits: euthanise the patient - BioEdge - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Arizona legislative committee meets on animal care standards - Fronteras: The Changing America Desk - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Colombia begins sterilizing its invasive hippos: what scientists think - Nature.com - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Conference brings medics together in support of good ethics - The Catholic Weekly - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- A Wheeling Murderer was sentenced to life in prison and citizens demand answers about the euthanasia of dogs at a local animal shelter: Heres a look... - November 16th, 2023 [November 16th, 2023]
- Darwin bishop ready to champion 'value of Christian life' as ... - Catholic Leader - July 26th, 2023 [July 26th, 2023]
- Suddenly hospital transfers are an issue? - BC Catholic - Multimedia ... - The B.C. Catholic - July 26th, 2023 [July 26th, 2023]
- Dutch government to expand euthanasia law to include children aged one to 12 an ethicist's view - The Conversation - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Thousands of signatures presented to Mexican Congress urging defeat of euthanasia bill - Catholic News Agency - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Is Government-Sanctioned Euthanasia Really That Far-Fetched? - The New York Sun - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Victoria's rising euthanasia rate shows governments won't bear the ... - The Catholic Weekly - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Experts looking into option of euthanasia for Noor Jehan - DAWN.com - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- More than 70 dogs in PA at risk of euthanasia by next week amid canine flu outbreak - SILive.com - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Death Upon Request: Euthanasia and Assisted-Suicide - The Speaker - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- BREAKING: Pontifical Academy of Life president calls medically assisted suicide feasible - Catholic News Agency - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- What happens to animals who die at the zoo? - WGN TV Chicago - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Opinion | Medical Assistance in Dying Should Not Exclude Mental ... - The New York Times - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Watch: 'Why Are We Safeguarding Cells?' - Philosophy Teacher ... - Lovin Malta - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- The Greatest Horror of 'Soylent Green' Isn't Soylent Green It's This - Collider - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Explained: Dying animals, lack of funds - distressing state of Pakistan zoos - WION - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Stray dog population control is dogged by bad science - The Hindu - April 23rd, 2023 [April 23rd, 2023]
- Euthanasia: Right to Die with Dignity - PMC - National Center for ... - April 14th, 2023 [April 14th, 2023]
- Pet assistance program - King County - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Euthanasia - MU School of Medicine - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Euthanasia | ama-coe - American Medical Association - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Euthanasia - Arguments in Favour and Against - ClearIAS - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Baton Rouge animal shelter overwhelmed, resorting to euthanasia: 'Please help us help them' - The Advocate - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Canadian religious leaders speak out as country set to allow euthanasia for mental illness - Fox News - November 25th, 2022 [November 25th, 2022]
- The History of the Euthanasia Movement | JSTORY Daily - November 5th, 2022 [November 5th, 2022]
- How Canada became a world leader in euthanasia - Spiked - October 25th, 2022 [October 25th, 2022]
- In places where it's legal, how many people are ending their lives ... - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- Human Rights and Euthanasia - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- 25 Bible Verses about Euthanasia - Human Life International - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Canadian moms harrowing tale shows the real dangers of legal euthanasia - Aleteia - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Is it time to rethink the laws on assisted dying? - podcast - The Guardian - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Alive offer free adoptions for dogs and puppies - mySA - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Animal shelters are overwhelmed - The West Volusia Beacon - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Poor Canadians are now willing to legally die instead of living in Trudeaus Canada - TFI Global News - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- 43rd Senate District: Ashby, Smyth offer contrasts on farm overtime, other issues during virtual debate - The Post Star - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- John Irving's latest novel is full of empathy and affection for his characters - NOW Toronto - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- What passive euthanasia is - PubMed - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Mehmet Oz is facing accusations of animal abuse tied to medical research. Here's what you need to know - The Morning Call - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- L.A. Animal Servicesa Ticking Time Bomb, and the Hypocrisy of No Kill - City Watch - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]