Disneys latest attempt to sink a lawsuit over the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise has been scuttled by a California federal judge.
In November 2017, A. Lee Alfred II and Ezequiel Martinez Jr. sued Disney over the franchise. The duo claims their spec script defied pirate topes by having Davy Jones be funny instead of fearsome, and their work was plundered to create Jack Sparrow after their producer sent it to Disney.
Disney seemed to have defeated the suit in May 2019 when District Court Judge Consuelo B. Marshall granted its motion to dismiss, finding the similar elements between the 2000 spec and 2003 film Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl were largely unprotectable generic pirate fare but in July 2020 the matter was revived by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of appeals, which found the screenplay shares sufficient similarities with the film to survive a motion to dismiss.
The appeals court found it premature to definitively determine the similar elements are unprotectable and additional evidence and expert testimony would help. States the opinion, This would be particularly useful in this circumstance, where the works in question are almost twenty years old and the blockbuster Pirates of the Caribbean film franchise may itself have shaped what are now considered pirate-movie tropes.
Alfred and Martinez filed an amended complaint, and now Marshall has denied Disneys motion for summary judgment because of conflicting expert testimony.
While Disney had argued the writers expert is unfamiliar with the pirate genre and the legal analysis used to evaluate substantial similarity, notes Marshall, These arguments go to the weight of Plaintiffs expert report, and the Court cannot weigh evidence on summary judgment.
Plaintiffs expert opines that the parties works are substantially similar and have original elements in common, whereas Defendants expert opines that the parties works are not substantially similar and common elements in the parties works are common in the pirate genre generally, writes Marshall in the order, which is embedded below. The opinions from the parties experts thus creates a genuine issue of material fact in dispute regarding whether the works are substantially similar.
Original post:
Disney Cant Sink Pirates of the Caribbean Suit Over Jack Sparrow Character - Hollywood Reporter
- Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise ships leave from Baltimore for the first time since the collapse of the Key Bridge - Yahoo! Voices - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Man with seizure on Royal Caribbean cruise had to pay $2500 bill during evacuation - The Independent - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Tropical threat may arise in Caribbean days after hurricane season begins - AOL - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- What you need to know about record-breaking heat in the Atlantic Yale Climate Connections - Yale Climate Connections - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- 13 Best Jack Sparrow Quotes in 'Pirates of the Caribbean,' Ranked - Collider - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- 8 Reasons Why Margot Robbie's Pirates Of The Caribbean Spinoff Is More Exciting Than POTC 6 - Screen Rant - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- PAHO urges countries to strengthen dengue prevention in Central America, Mexico and the Caribbean - Pan American Health Organization - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean Ride SURPRISED Us in Magic Kingdom See WHY! - AllEars.Net - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- US issues severe 'Do not travel' warning for this Caribbean country - New York Post - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- EU Commissioner Urpilainen Meets With Caribbean Counterparts At SIDS Conference in Antigua & Barbuda - EEAS - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean Sailing the Seas of Success - FX Empire - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Sharp Dragon Expands Towards Africa and The Caribbean - Check Point Research - Check Point Research - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Heres What It's Like to Travel on Royal Caribbean's Icon of the Seas - Remezcla - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - Gwinnettdailypost.com - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- American company tells Mexico president that his $385m offer to buy its Caribbean property for ecotourism ... - Fortune - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Caribbean foods and culture highlighted at International Food Festival in Mount Vernon - News 12 Westchester - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- 7 Hidden Gem Islands In The Caribbean Perfect For Retirement - TheTravel - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - mycouriertribune.com - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Caribbean Heritage Month events hosted by PGParks & Recs - WUSA9.com - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Secrets of sargassum: Scientists advance knowledge of seaweed causing chaos in the Caribbean and West Africa - Phys.org - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - Rockdale Newton Citizen - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Icon of the Seas: Exploring private islands, swim up bars and Broadway shows on Royal Caribbean's newest cruise ship - HELLO! - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - Napoleon Northwest Signal - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Ben Bouldin to head of Royal Caribbean in China - - Cruise Adviser - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - Lenoir News-Topic - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed clogging up Caribbean 'could be used to produce sustainable goods' - Islander News.com - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - The Elkhart Truth - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - Herald Palladium - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Seaweed plaguing the Caribbean could become eco-friendly products - The Bryan Times - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Pirates Of The Caribbean Changed Completely Because Of Johnny Depp - Giant Freakin Robot - May 29th, 2024 [May 29th, 2024]
- Johnny Depp's Potential Return In Pirates Of The Caribbean Reboot Addressed By Producer - Screen Rant - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Johnny Depp Will Return as Jack Sparrow if Pirates of the Caribbean Producer Gets His Way - MovieWeb - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Virgin Voyages Expands Caribbean Summer Season Pass - Cruise Industry News - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Pirates of the Caribbean Producer Interested in Bringing Johnny Depp Back, "We'll See What Happens" - ComicBook.com - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Johnny Depp Spotted on Disney Set, 'Pirates of the Caribbean 6' Confirmed - Inside the Magic - Inside the Magic - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Can the circular economy help the Caribbean win its war against waste? - Mongabay.com - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Heat Stress Is Hitting Caribbean Reefs Earlier Than Ever This Year - The New York Times - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- CTO says Caribbean Week in NYC 'set to sparkle' Caribbean Life - Caribbean Life - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Researchers propose building US-Caribbean 'super grid' to offset solar energy losses during tropical storms: 'Need to ... - The Cool Down - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Banyan Tree is making its first foray into the Caribbean market. - Breaking Travel News - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Caribbean Hot in 2024 Tourism Surge - Travel And Tour World - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Afro Caribbean Cultural Center on the move - Waterbury Republican American - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Pirates of the Caribbean franchise without Jack Sparrow? Read on - Deccan Chronicle - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Investing in gender equality in Latin America and the Caribbean for a better world - Comisin Econmica para Amrica Latina y el Caribe - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Pirates of the Caribbean Producer Confirms Two New Movies Are Now in Development - MovieWeb - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Patricia Affonso-Dass: Leading The Way In Caribbean Hospitality - Travel And Tour World - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- I hope you like Pirates of the Caribbean, because both a reboot and that thought-to-be-dead Margot Robbie movie are ... - VG247 - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Caribbean communicators and health promoters participate in PAHO-led workshop on Risk Communications and ... - Pan American Health Organization - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- American Airlines Boosts Service to Caribbean Destinations for Winter Travel - Business Traveler USA - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Disney Still Really Wants to Make That Margot Robbie Pirates of the Caribbean Movie, Jerry Bruckheimer Says - IGN - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Bubba-Doo's takes on the Caribbean Part 2 Baptist News Global - Baptist News Global - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Cruise ops returning to Baltimore after temporary move to Norfolk - 13newsnow.com WVEC - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- New Pirates of the Caribbean movies unlikely to feature Johnny Depp as lead - Business Insider India - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Tourism's contribution to Caribbean GDP expected to rise | News - Breaking Travel News - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- 'Pirates of the Caribbean: Tides of War' Adds New Tacticians with Its 7th Anniversary Update TouchArcade - Touch Arcade - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Caribbean Renewable Energy Forum Awards ELM-Solar Island Energy Project as Microgrid of the Year - Microgrid Knowledge - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Caribbean Hotel & Tourism Association Unveils Bold Rebranding, Ushering In New Era For Caribbean Hospitality - Travel And Tour World - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Icon of the Seas by Wilson Butler Architects and Royal Caribbean is the world's largest cruise ship - The Architect's Newspaper - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Lrssen superyacht Lady Lara in the Caribbean - SuperYacht Times - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- Climate Crisis Costs: Caribbean Nations Demand Global Financial System Reforms - Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting - May 21st, 2024 [May 21st, 2024]
- New satellite imagery reveals expanse of oil spill in Caribbean - Fox Weather - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Oil spill off Trinidad and Tobago blackens Caribbean beaches - The Washington Post - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Passenger dies aboard 9-month Royal Caribbean cruise around the world - NBC News - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean Group Signs with Chantiers For Next Oasis Class Ship - Cruise Industry News - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean Perfect Day at CocoCay new adult-only area: review - Business Insider - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Tourists Warned To Protect Their Passports As Thefts In The Mexican Caribbean On The Rise - The Cancun Sun - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Antigua: Elderly man charged with second homicide of 2024 | Loop Caribbean News - Loop News Caribbean - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- With Jamaica and Bahamas under travel advisories, which Caribbean islands are safe to book your next vacation? - SILive.com - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean Gives Unprecedented Choice on Ultimate World Cruise - Cruise Hive - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Disney's Extensive Pirates of the Caribbean Change Officially Closes Attraction - Inside the Magic - Inside the Magic - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean's new Icon of the Seas: What it's like to stay on the largest cruise ship in the world - CNA: Breaking News, Singapore News, World and... - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- At Grenada's Spice Island Beach Resort, the Art of the Luxury All-Inclusive - Caribbean Journal - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Director Malaury Eloi-Paisley on Her Debut Documentary 'L'Homme Vertige,' and the Unvarnished Reality of ... - Yahoo Entertainment - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- See Royal Caribbean's newest giant cruise ship, Utopia of the Seas - Business Insider - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Preparing for Development of the Blue Economy in the U.S. Caribbean - NOAA Fisheries - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Latin America & The Caribbean Weekly Situation Update as of 16 February 2024 - Haiti - ReliefWeb - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Europe and Latin America & the Caribbean step up cooperation on cybersecurity - EEAS - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Royal Caribbean Confirms 9-Month Cruise Will Not Go Through Red Sea and Suez Canal Due to Middle East Unrest - PEOPLE - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Where is Death in Paradise set? The Caribbean island behind the BBC show - The Independent - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]
- Trinidad and Tobago: overturned barge leaks oil into Caribbean Sea video report - The Guardian - February 18th, 2024 [February 18th, 2024]