A dispute between InterDigital and Xiaomi highlighted the delicate balance between confidentiality and fair opportunity in SEP disputes, say Ranjan Narula and Suvarna Pandey of RNA Technology and IP Attorneys.
The objective of forming a Confidentiality Club during patent or trade secret litigation matters has become a standard protocol to keep the business-sensitive documents/information confidential to the parties involved in the litigation. The idea is to limit access to documents to a specific set of people bound by the obligation to maintain confidentiality.
The provision of the Confidentiality Club, introduced by the Delhi High Court Act 1966 through amendments in 2018 in its practice rules for the lawsuits where the Delhi High Court is the court of the first instance, is defined as follows: 17. Confidentiality Clubwhen parties to a commercial suit wish to rely on documents/information that is commercially or otherwise confidential in nature, the court may constitute a Confidentiality Club so as to allow limited access to such documents/information.
In doing so, the court may set up a structure/protocol for the establishment and functioning of such club, as it may deem appropriate. An illustrative structure/protocol of the Confidentiality Club is provided in Annexure F. The court may appropriately mould the structure/protocol of the club, based upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
The rules state that each party shall nominate not more than three advocates, who are not, and have not been, in-house lawyers of either party, and not more than two external experts, who shall constitute the Confidentiality Club.
The post discusses the decision of a single judge of the Delhi High Court in an standard-essential patent (SEP) infringement suit between InterDigital Technology (plaintiff) and Xiaomi (defendant) (CS [COMM]-295/2020 and IA No. 6441, 2020).
In summary, the parties did not disagree on forming the Confidentiality Club but its structure. InterDigital has proposed a two-tier club classifying documents and their access as follows:
Outer tier: documents are accessible to the advocates for both sides, experts appointed by them, as well as representatives of both parties and denoted as confidential information.
Inner tier: documents accessible only to the advocates for both sides and experts appointed by them who would not be in-house counsel and denoted as legal eyes only (LEO) confidential information.
Xiaomi objected to the classification of inner tier documents. Xiaomi contended that it would result in its officials, personnel, and employees being denied access to documents comprising third-party comparable patent licence agreements. Further, these documents are necessary for them to examine the basis on which royalty rates have been worked out and whether they are comparable.
The court dealt with the issue of whether comparable patent licence agreements could be justifiably included in an inner tier of confidential documents, ie, kept away from the eyes of the defendant, as well as all its officers and employees.
Court ruling
The court noted the following: the defendants would have to be made privy to the licence agreements with other licensees. Without knowing the identity of the licensee, the particulars of the licence agreement, or its covenants, it defeats comprehension as to how the defendants can be expected to make any submission regarding whether the rate at which such licence has been granted is, or is not, fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND).
The determination of whether licensing rates set by the SEP owner are FRAND requires assessment of licence agreements with other licensees, considering the licensees identity and the scope of the licence. This assessment cannot be carried out solely by advocates and external experts to the exclusion of party representatives.
Civil litigation generally requires each party to be aware of the other partys case that it is supposed to counter, and no surprises should be permitted in this regard, especially in litigation as complex as this, involving fixation of FRAND rates and determination of the issue of whether Xiaomi is, or is not, infringing the SEPs of InterDigital.
The court opined that it is a prime necessity that the officials of Xiaomi, which is conversant with its activities, and who can decide on the rate at which Xiaomi can take a licence for the exploitation of the SEPs from InterDigital, are kept abreast of all aspects of the case set up by InterDigital. A prime element for the determination of FRAND rates would be the allegedly comparable licence agreements proposed by InterDigital.
InterDigital argued that access to documents marked and designated as LEO confidential information, third-party licence agreements in particular, contain sensitive commercial information. They are strictly restricted not to disclose such information.
If such information is placed in the hands of other parties such as the defendants and if it is misused or further disclosed there-after, it could cause such grave prejudice to the commercial interests of the plaintiffs, as well as the third-party entities, who in many instances are competitors to the defendants, said the court.
In the case that such confidential and sensitive information is disclosed to the defendants, or is disclosed to other third parties thereafter, it will cause grave prejudice not just to the plaintiffs, but their third-party licensees as well, since it will be very difficult for the plaintiffs to be able to negotiate future licence agreements with licensees who cannot be assured that the confidentiality obligations with respect to such negotiations can be complied with.
In such a situation, any order from this Honble Court passed later cannot reverse the damage.
Single tier
While rejecting this argument, the court held: First, that litigation is not a one-way street and, second, that InterDigital has invited Xiaomi into the arena, and not vice versa. The court concluded Xiaomi is not unwilling to take licences from InterDigital, and determination of licence fees would require Xiaomi, its officers and employees to determine whether rates being offered are FRAND.
The court thus rejected InterDigitals wishes for the creation of a two-tier Confidentiality Club, with inner tier documents being shown only to advocates (who are not in-house counsel) and external experts nominated by Xiaomi.
The court directed to constitute the single-tier Confidentiality Club in the following terms:
The case emphatically lays down that the business interest of a party cannot prevail over fair opportunity and natural justice. Further, the court is required to balance the interest of the parties and cannot place one on a higher pedestal than the other.
See the original post here:
- Steer clear of seals, warns Hout Bay Seal and Rescue Centre - IOL - December 25th, 2023 [December 25th, 2023]
- People really live in the world's tiniest 'state', Sealand - Supercar Blondie - December 16th, 2023 [December 16th, 2023]
- This is the Smallest Country in the World Its Entire Population Could Fit in a Chair - AZ Animals - December 16th, 2023 [December 16th, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 18 to 24 November - GOV.UK - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Franklin Templeton mulls options on China JV - Fund Selector Asia - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- State Flag And Seal Designs Available for Public Viewing - redlakenationnews.com - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- News Release Department of Health issues voluntary recall ... - David Y. Ige | Newsroom - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Glover Road and US 93 project complete | News | charkoosta.com - Char-Koosta News - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- easyJet Will Collect & Deliver Bags Straight To Hotels For Its ... - Simple Flying - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Recalling a moment of valor - Yahoo News - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Discover 7 DIY Solutions to Preserve Leaves This Fall - AZ Animals - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Why advocates for transgender rights are so thrilled with election ... - Route Fifty - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Drop in temps led to Mill Creek chip-seal failure - The Times ... - The Times-Independent - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 11 to 17 November - GOV.UK - November 4th, 2023 [November 4th, 2023]
- Flintshire Council greenlights new gym and community hub in ... - Deeside.com - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 12 to 18 August - GOV.UK - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Design and Delivery of Elegant, Compact, and Eco-Friendly (ECEF ... - Digital Journal - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- From Sea to Stars: The remarkable journey of a Navy Seal and ... - Chicago Star Media - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Fresh and Naturally Fermented Birch Juice: A beverage made from ... - University City Review - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Photos of the Week: Trump, the Bidens vacation and fans remember Paul Reubens - The Hill - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Global Airport Baggage Protection Market Size and Forecast | Safe ... - University City Review - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Texas man sentenced to 10 years for operating human smuggling ... - U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Newsroom - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Road Slurry Seal and Micro Surfacing Equipment Market 2023-2029 ... - University City Review - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Reward offered in Kellogg vandalism - Shoshone News Press - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Nearby waters a white shark hot spot | Inquirer and Mirror - The Inquirer and Mirror - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- All Aboard: Haunted Ship USS Nightmare Hiring Actors and Makeup ... - Cincinnati CityBeat - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- CJ Logistics teams up with ONE as strategic partner - India Shipping News - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- The fashionable riviera the Danes want to keep to themselves - The Times - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Wands and Wizards Weekend Brings Magic to Fairfield County - Cincinnati CityBeat - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- 10 DC Comics The Superman & Lois TV Show Never Adapted - CBR - Comic Book Resources - August 5th, 2023 [August 5th, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 29 July to 4 August - GOV.UK - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 22 to 28 July - GOV.UK - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Single mum to open florist near Chester after retraining in lockdown ... - Chester and District Standard - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- 10 Most Popular Hotspots In The Mexican Caribbean For a Unique ... - TheTravel - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Chester homeless shelter evacuated after torrential rain | Chester ... - Chester and District Standard - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Campbellton Neighbourhood Association dedicates Beaver floatplane - Campbell River Mirror - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Searching for the best of all possible worlds in London - The Spectator - July 21st, 2023 [July 21st, 2023]
- Councillor Ian Roberts to continue to lead Flintshire Council - Herald Wales - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Sealand firing times 20 to 26 May - GOV.UK - May 14th, 2023 [May 14th, 2023]
- Is Sealand a Country? - WorldAtlas - February 2nd, 2023 [February 2nd, 2023]
- Sealand Power Distributors, LLC - February 2nd, 2023 [February 2nd, 2023]
- HF FOODS GROUP INC. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations. (form 10-Q) - Marketscreener.com - February 2nd, 2023 [February 2nd, 2023]
- Long Beachs Aquarium on Wheels is back, bringing the ocean to classrooms and communities - Long Beach Press Telegram - January 6th, 2023 [January 6th, 2023]
- Im an appliance expert and youre not cleaning your washing machine enough, there are four steps to take n... - The Scottish Sun - January 6th, 2023 [January 6th, 2023]
- Report raises question of hunting seals to save Washington salmon - The Center Square - December 21st, 2022 [December 21st, 2022]
- Nora Fatehi Get Trolled For Wearing White Fleece Coat On Airport, Aditya Seal And Anushka Ranjan Give Couple - India.com - December 21st, 2022 [December 21st, 2022]
- 'This gentleman had his weekend plans all figured': Anand Mahindra's Friday tweet involves a seal in the pool - Business Today - December 16th, 2022 [December 16th, 2022]
- Our story: The birth of Sealand | Principality Of Sealand - December 2nd, 2022 [December 2nd, 2022]
- Sealand Container Tracking | Shipup - November 7th, 2022 [November 7th, 2022]
- Brown: Come to Penn Museum for an Adventure of the Ages, Nov. 19-20 - Main Line - November 7th, 2022 [November 7th, 2022]
- A Comprehensive Introduction to Seal and Valve Maintenance - AZoMining - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Pingree and Thelander clash over support for the lobster industry in 1st Congressional District debate - Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Gray fitness trainer, former reality TV contestant, accused of welfare fraud - Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Alex Caruso, Bulls reserves have makings of another Chicago bench mob - The Athletic - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Vidillion Receives Trustworthy Accountability Group (TAG) Verification, and Anti-Fraud Certification across North America - Yahoo Finance - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Courier letter: Ed Thelander loves America and its people - Courier-Gazette & Camden Herald - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Ocean currents have sheltered the Galpagos from global warming. Now it's time to protect them - University of Colorado Boulder - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Police teams fan out to check veracity of 4500 affidavits found in court - The Indian Express - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- 8 million NZTC funding allocated to 20 low-carbon technology projects - Current News - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Is promotion written in the stars for Wrexham AFC? - The Leader - October 8th, 2022 [October 8th, 2022]
- Sealand Road - Wikipedia - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- Shell Island tourist and 'depraved' sex offender among those jailed last month - North Wales Live - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- Recycling centres in Cheshire West to move to winter opening hours this weekend - Chester and District Standard - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- Five Blacon properties that could be yours for less than 170,000 - Cheshire Live - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- 'Psychotic' killer whale scalped and dismembered trainer as horrified tourists looked on - The Mirror - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- Top 30 Ocean Carriers: Riding high on wave of profits - Logistics Management - October 2nd, 2022 [October 2nd, 2022]
- Airport Baggage Protection Market Size And Forecast To 2022 |Safe Bag Group, TrueStar Group SpA, Sealand Go, Flymate services, Tripod and Secure Wrap.... - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Shoebert the Seal's Week on the Lam in Mass. Pond Appears to Be Coming to an End - NBC10 Boston - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- BYD Reports Firm That Faked Being Bought by NEV Giant to Chinese Police - Yicai Global - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Seal breeding forces Blue Lagoon to close to the public - South Wales Argus - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Report highlights return of EU wildlife over past 50 years - Agriland - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- The North Wales criminals locked up for crimes of aggression and violence - North Wales Live - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- CIDCA to send medial, disaster assessment teams to flood-hit areas of Pakistan - Daily Times - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- The Smallest Country in the World That No One Knows About - History of Yesterday - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Commission on changing state seal and motto behind schedule - WWLP.com - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- A short history of luxury: Mumm, the "Champagne of the Sovereign of England" - Luxus Plus Mag - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Seal spotted in freshwater pond on North Shore of Massachusetts - WCVB Boston - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Genshin Impact 'Try to Lift the Seal' Guide: 7 Seal Locations and how to lift them - The Click - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- The example of the late Queen will shape the future, hopes the Bishop of St Asaph - Rhyl Journal - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Frozen Planet II: Viewers in tears as seal pup abandoned at 12 days old - Metro.co.uk - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]