Monthly Archives: April 2012

Jersey City Developer Liberty Harbor North Files for Bankruptcy

Posted: April 21, 2012 at 7:14 am

By Steven Church and David Voreacos - Thu Apr 19 20:37:54 GMT 2012

Liberty Harbor North Inc., a developer of waterfront property opposite Manhattan in Jersey City, New Jersey, filed for bankruptcy to resolve a $21 million court judgment related to the urban-renewal project.

Company President Peter Mocco, a former mayor of neighboring North Bergen, put three companies affiliated with the Liberty Harbor community into bankruptcy to settle a legal dispute with a former landowner.

We need the quick definitive action of the bankruptcy court to permit me to enter into a settlement, Mocco said today in an interview.

Liberty Harbor North controls land worth $350 million, the company said in court papers filed April 17 in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Newark. The project itself is not in bankruptcy and has adequate cash flow, Mocco said.

The development is an example of new urbanism, which relies less on cars and more on public transportation in creating a sense of community, Bob Antonicello, executive director of the Jersey City Redevelopment Agency, said in a telephone interview.

It is monitored by more than 500 security cameras, served by two light-rail stations, and sits within walking distance of PATH trains run by the Port Authority of New York & New Jersey, Mocco said.

People have really looked at this and said this could be a striking example of how to redevelop cities, Antonicello said.

The bankruptcy filing is very disappointing, he said.

When the developer files a bankruptcy and thinks it wont impact the future development, thats ludicrous, he said. At the end of the day, bankruptcies have a stigma. This will be a stigma on what has the potential for being a jewel on the Hudson. This cold, calculating business move could have a very damaging effect on the city.

Read the original here:
Jersey City Developer Liberty Harbor North Files for Bankruptcy

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Jersey City Developer Liberty Harbor North Files for Bankruptcy

Liberty Energy Announces Execution of Letter of Intent for Texas Leases

Posted: at 7:14 am

HOUSTON, April 19, 2012 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Liberty Energy Corp. (OTCBB:LBYE.OB - News) ("Liberty" or "the Company") announces executing a Letter of Intent to acquire new acreage in Texas.

The Company is pleased to announce that it has signed a memorandum of understanding to acquire an estimated 1,040 acres in Bastrop, Caldwell and Eastland Counties. The Company intends to conduct further geological and geophysical surveys to complete the plan of development for this project.

"We are extremely excited to announce this letter of intent and intend on providing further information on geological and geophysical work to be carried out once we have completed our due diligence process. These new prospects strengthen our commitment to secure Texan assets and ties in with our growth program of continued investment in onshore projects that grow shareholder value," Commented Ian Spowart, CEO of Liberty Energy Corp.

Bastrop County

Bastrop County is located in South Texas. The majority of production in Bastrop is attributed to the Austin Chalk and Navarro formations.1 The county presently houses over 1,700 wells and over 170 operators including; Texas Vanguard Oil Company, Chalker Operating Inc. and Petro-Gas Inc.2 The Eagle Ford Shale formation is in the oil maturity window and is present in Bastrop County. The play is 50 miles wide and an average of 250 feet thick at a depth between 4,000 and 12,000 feet. The oil reserves are estimated at 3 billion barrels with potential output of 420,000 barrels a day.1 Major producers in the county include Anadarko, Exxon-XTO and PetroHawk. Liberty will, under the terms of the LOI, acquire five leases comprising approximately 630 highly prospective acres within the county.

Caldwell County

There are four main pay zones within Caldwell County, the Sepertine, Dale Lime, Austin Chalk and Edwards. There are currently 385 operators (including Eagle Ford Oil Co., Inc., Luling O&G LLC and Texas Petroleum Investment Co.) and nearly 9,000 wells in Caldwell County.2From March 2010 to March 2011 the county produced over 1 million barrels.4 Liberty will, under the terms of the LOI, acquire two leases comprising approximately 300 greatly prospective acres within the county.

Eastland County

In addition to having the Marble Falls, Duffer and Mississippian formations Eastland County is the westernmost extension of the Barnett Shale play and can be considered as part of the active Barnett Shale play area.5 The Bend Arch has had a significant effect on the Barnett Shale with regard to its burial history and geo-thermal makeup. The Barnett is the source rock for the hydrocarbons produced from many of the shallower zones over the Bend Arch such as the Marble Falls and Duffer. There are currently 893 operators (including North Ridge Corporation, Sun Expl. & Prod. Co.-Abilene and B & B Oil, Inc.) and over 10,900 wells in Eastland County.2 Using a geology-based assessment methodology, the U.S. Geological Survey estimated a mean of 26.7 trillion cubic feet (TCF) of undiscovered natural gas, a mean of 98.5 million barrels of undiscovered oil, and a mean of 1.1 billion barrels of undiscovered natural gas liquids in the Bend Arch-Fort Worth Basin Province.6 Liberty will, under the terms of the LOI, acquire one lease comprising approximately 110 considerably prospective acres within the county.

ABOUT LIBERTY: Liberty Energy Corp (OTCBB:LBYE.OB - News) is an Independent Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Company dedicated to the sourcing and production of fuel supplies in the United States and Europe. Headquartered in Houston, Texas, the company has leases and royalties in both Texas and Bulgaria, covering several wells with extensive potential for future development. In Texas, Liberty owns twelve leases based around numerous geological pay zones. In North-West Bulgaria, Liberty has royalty rights to a 1,000,000+ acre natural gas property (the A-Lovech exploration block), an area of high quality, low-sulphur natural gas condensate. Through this combined international reach and domestic focus, Liberty Energy is committed to the development of U.S. fuel reserves while seeking out further opportunities for the global energy markets.

Read the original here:
Liberty Energy Announces Execution of Letter of Intent for Texas Leases

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Liberty Energy Announces Execution of Letter of Intent for Texas Leases

Earnings Preview: Liberty Property – Analyst Blog

Posted: at 7:14 am

Liberty Property Trust ( LRY ), a real estate investment trust (REIT), is scheduled to report its fiscal 2012 first quarter earnings on April 24, 2012. The current Zacks Consensus Estimate for the first quarter is pegged at 63 cents per share, representing a year-over-year decline of about 1.69%.

Fourth Quarter Recap

Liberty Property reported fourth quarter 2011 FFO (funds from operations) of 63 cents per share compared with 65 cents in the year-earlier quarter. Funds from operations, a widely used metric to gauge the performance of REITs, is obtained after adding depreciation and amortization and other non-cash expenses to net income. Reported FFO were in line with the Zacks Consensus Estimate.

For full-year 2011, Liberty Property reported FFO of $2.61 per share compared with $2.66 in the previous year

Total revenues for fourth quarter 2011 were $169.8 million compared with $164.5 million in the year-ago quarter. Total revenue in the reported quarter fell short of the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $175 million. Total revenues for fiscal 2011 were $667.6 million compared with $657.0 million in 2010.

Agreement of Analysts

Over the last 7 days, one analyst out of 12 increased the earnings estimate for the first quarter while none revised downward for the first quarter or fiscal 2012. In the last 30 days, one out of 12 analysts increased the earnings estimates for the first quarter and one out of 13 analysts increased the earnings estimates for fiscal 2012 while none revised it downward for first quarter as well as for fiscal 2012.

Magnitude of Estimate Revisions

Taking into effect the analysts' earnings revision, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for the first quarter and fiscal 2012 remained constant over the last 7 days and 30 days at 63 cents and $2.54, respectively. However, Liberty Property expects FFO in the range of $2.45 - $2.60 per share in fiscal 2012.

Our Recommendation

Follow this link:
Earnings Preview: Liberty Property - Analyst Blog

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Earnings Preview: Liberty Property – Analyst Blog

Liberty Mutual First Group Benefits Carrier to Introduce Mobile Applications to Manage Employee Absence

Posted: at 7:14 am

BOSTON--(BUSINESS WIRE)--

Liberty Mutual Insurances Group Benefits operation has become the first group disability and life carrier to introduce mobile applications that make it easier for employees to manage their benefits using any mobile device.

The Boston-based group benefits carrier introduced MyLibertyMobilesm to improve the benefits management experience for customers. Intermittent leave time reporting is the first MyLibertyMobile application, allowing employees to enter time away from work during approved leaves with a web-enabled mobile device. Additional applications will be released in coming months. All MyLibertyMobile applications will be available for qualified Group Benefits customers to provide to their employees.

In announcing MyLibertyMobile, Jean Scarrow, Chief Operating Officer, Liberty Mutual Group Benefits noted, We have made a strategic commitment and a substantial investment to deliver technology tools that address employers needs in todays mobile environment. The mobile applications were building make it easier for employees to manage their benefits, while expanding ways for employers to manage absence and return to work. The ultimate goal is to deliver convenience and flexibility to employers and employees.

All information transmitted through mobile devices is seamlessly integrated into Liberty Mutual Group Benefits tracking and reporting tools for employers.

More information on MyLibertyMobile and Group Benefits other mobile applications can be accessed at LibertyMutualGroup.com/Mobile.

About Liberty Mutual Insurance

"Helping people live safer, more secure lives" since 1912, Boston-based Liberty Mutual Insurance is a diversified global insurer and the third largest property and casualty insurer in the U.S. based on A.M. Best Company's report of 2010 net written premium.

Liberty Mutual Insurance also ranks 82nd on the Fortune 100 list of largest corporations in the U.S. based on 2010 revenue. As of December 31, 2011, Liberty Mutual Insurance had $117.1 billion in consolidated assets, $99.3 billion in consolidated liabilities, and $34.7 billion in annual consolidated revenue.

Liberty Mutual Insurance offers a wide range of insurance products and services, including personal automobile, homeowners, workers compensation, property, commercial automobile, general liability, global specialty, group disability, reinsurance and surety. Liberty Mutual Insurance (www.libertymutualinsurance.com) employs over 45,000 people in more than 900 offices throughout the world.

Continue reading here:
Liberty Mutual First Group Benefits Carrier to Introduce Mobile Applications to Manage Employee Absence

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Liberty Mutual First Group Benefits Carrier to Introduce Mobile Applications to Manage Employee Absence

SiriusXM snubs Liberty Media's takeover attempt — again

Posted: at 7:14 am

Sirius XM Radio Inc. delivered a counterpunch Friday to Liberty Media's hostile takeover attempt in a brief it filed with federal regulators.

Liberty Media in March threw the first punch byasking the U.S.Federal Communications Commission togive it control overSiriusXM's operating licenses. Liberty argued that its 40% stake in SiriusXM gave it "de facto" control over the satellite radio company. It refined its argument further last Thursday, arguing that its stake, and control over five of the 13 seats on the Siriusboard is "more than sufficient to determine the outcome of matters submitted to a vote of shareholders."

SiriusXM took umbrage over the characterization. In a brief filed with the FCC, SiriusXM scoffed at Liberty's argument that "40 is the new 50."

"There is no support for the remarkable proposition that a... 40% minority interest, standing alone, is sufficient to bestow control of a public company," wrote SiriusXM's attorneys, who urged the agency's commissioners to dismiss Liberty's request.

Calls to the FCC were not returned, and Liberty Media's spokeswoman did not respond to requests for comment.

Eddy Hartenstein, publisher of the Los Angeles Times, is a non-executive chairman of the SiriusXM board.

The tussle for control over SiriusXM, whichtopped $3 billion in revenue in 2011, stems from a Faustian bargain its chief executive, Mel Karmazin, made in 2009to accept a $530-million loan fromLiberty Media's chairman, John Malone. The money, which has since been repaid, saved SiriusXM from having to file for bankruptcy protection.

The deal also gave Liberty Media a 40% stake in Sirius and five seats on the company's board. But it handcuffed Malone from making further moves to take over SiriusXM at least until thisMarch. When those restrictions expired,Liberty Media made its first moveby petitioningthe FCC for a transfer of SiriusXM's operating licenses.

For now, that's the least expensive path to gaining control of SiriusXM. But Liberty has other options, which it outlined in its petition last week to the FCC. Those include accumulating enough shares of SiriusXM to boost its stake above 50%and staging a boardroom coup bycalling "a meeting of Sirius stockholders" and putting the matter to a vote. But doing so could trigger a big tax bill for Liberty Media if the transaction is deemed to be an acquisition.

See the original post:
SiriusXM snubs Liberty Media's takeover attempt -- again

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on SiriusXM snubs Liberty Media's takeover attempt — again

Liberty Tax’s Preliminary Tax Season Results Show a Competitive Industry Edge

Posted: at 7:14 am

VIRGINIA BEACH, Va.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--

Liberty Tax Service continued its growth in key areas during the just-completed tax season, and successfully addressed major industry changes in its operations. Throughout this decade, Liberty Tax Service has demonstrated significant gains in an industry formerly dominated by tax giant H&R Block (NYSE:HRB - News) and, during the 21st century, Liberty has grown by more tax returns than both Jackson Hewitt (JHTXQ.PK) and H&R Block combined.

Liberty Tax Service prepared 7.9% more returns through April 18, 2012, compared to the same time period in 2011. Systemwide revenues increased 4.7% over the same periods. In 2012, significant IRS delays in return processing posed customer service challenges for the tax preparation industry. The reduced importance of refund anticipation loans and ability to offer financial products also were issues for the major tax players. However, the Company continued to offer competitive choices, allowing its growing customer base to choose between professional services in brick-and-mortar locations, and do-it-yourself online tax preparation with its eSmart Tax product at http://www.esmarttax.com.

In addition, this year the IRS officially started its tax preparer oversight programs, and a further requirement that preparers pass a competency test is on the horizon. As noted by Liberty Tax Service Founder and CEO, John Hewitt, Liberty has been well-prepared for these changes:

Each tax season is unique for its challenges. Our companys success in triumphing over adversity in some tough years demonstrates our ability to continue to climb to the pinnacle of this industry. With an internal tax preparer certification process in place for 5 years, we are embracing the IRS requirements and applaud the positive effect these changes are having. Our ability to strategize, prepare and respond quickly is a true to the ability of our entire Liberty team, Hewitt reflected.

Aggressive marketing coupled with a strong commitment to customer service have been key factors in building a successful brand in fourteen years. Since 1997, the Company has grown from 119 offices located in Canada, to over 4,200 offices throughout the U.S. and Canada today.

About Liberty Tax Service

Liberty Tax Service is the fastest-growing retail tax preparation company in the industrys history. Founded in 1997 by CEO John T. Hewitt, a pioneer in the tax industry, Liberty Tax Service has prepared over 10,000,000 individual income tax returns. With 43 years of tax industry experience, Hewitt stands as the most experienced CEO in the tax preparation business, having also founded Jackson Hewitt Tax Service. Liberty Tax Service is the only tax franchise on the recently released Forbes Top 20 Franchises for the Buck.

Read this article:
Liberty Tax’s Preliminary Tax Season Results Show a Competitive Industry Edge

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Liberty Tax’s Preliminary Tax Season Results Show a Competitive Industry Edge

Pop artists turning to Satanic imagery to drum up controversy, sales, experts say

Posted: at 7:14 am

NEW YORK Its an age-old saying in Hollywood that sex sells, but with consumers finding themselves oversaturated with sexual imagery, todays top acts are turning to something even more sinful to get our attention: Satan.

Performer Nicki Minajs Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded is getting a lot of buzz this month, due in large part to her infamous Grammy performance earlier this year, where she acted out scenes from an exorcism onstage. While critics, particularly religious groups, blasted the imagery in that performance as ill-timed and awkward, there is no denying that Minaj garnered the attention she was looking for with her antics.

"Like sex, provocative subject matters and whatever is perceived to be forbidden intrigues the human psyche, explains Kelly Brady, a partner in Brandsway Creative, a marketing and public relations company.Nicki Minaj's performance, although criticized, created an intrigue and it kept her fans wanting to know what's next.

The pop star continues to feed into the buzz machine and has even gone so far as to explain that she believes a demon named Roman lives inside her.

His name is Roman. Basically, the religious figure is there because he was called by Roman's mom to rehabilitate him. Thats pretty much it, she said post-Grammys. I had this vision for Roman. I had this vision for him to be sort of exorcised. People around him tell him hes not good enough cause hes not normal, and hes not blendingin with the average Joe. People around him are afraid because theyve never seen anything like him. Not only is he amazing, sure of himself and confident, but hes never going to be exorcised. Even when they throw the holy water on him, he rises above.

And while her statements may be dark, bizarre and have religious groups up in arms, they have translated to massive sales for Minaj. Her album Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded debuted at Number one last week with an impressive 250,000 album sales.

More importantly, it got everyone talking about her in an environment where celebrity news often lasts for a mere few minutes before eyeballs are moving onto the next story.

But invoking Satanic imagery is nothing new in music, and Minaj is following in some successful footsteps.

Heavy metal bands in the seventies and eighties pioneered the trend of Satanic marketing, most noticeably acts like Black Sabbath, Motley Crue and KISS.

What goes around comes around. The metal bands of the 70s and 80s who presented themselves as satanic sold records, and apparently its time to try the idea again. Theres a reason its called shock value, says Shawn McEvoy, the Managing Editor of the Christian website Crosswalk.com. It sells, though logically it shouldnt, because if Satan is real, then hes our enemy who has nothing but our destruction in mind, and if youre an atheist, why buy that which glorifies the losing side of a theology you dont believe in anyway?

View original post here:
Pop artists turning to Satanic imagery to drum up controversy, sales, experts say

Posted in Illuminati | Comments Off on Pop artists turning to Satanic imagery to drum up controversy, sales, experts say

The Piterberg Doctrine: Free speech for me but not for thee

Posted: at 7:12 am

Opinion

April 20, 2012

by Roberta Seid and Roz Rothstein

Youd imagine every campus faction would have welcomed University of California President Yudofs statement on March 8. He called on the UC community to follow the basic rules necessary to protect free speech on college campuses. President Yudof denounced recent incidents during which demonstrators tried to shout down speakers, declaring that such actions are not protected speech but rather an effort to deny others their right to free speech. But the seemingly noncontroversial statement incensed UCLA professor Gabriel Piterberg, a prominent anti-Israel ideologue, and his allies. To condemn both the statement and President Yudof, Piterberg led a teach-in on April 12 that was sponsored, surprisingly, by the UCLA Center for Near East Studies.

Piterberg did not object to the principles that President Yudof outlined. Rather, in his convoluted presentation, he denounced the statement because it used the principles of free speech to condemn tactics that anti-Israel activists have been using with increasing frequency. Piterberg charged that the statement criminalized political dissent.

In fact, the statement was prompted by anti-Israel tactics. It specifically referred to an incident at UC Davis on February 27, when the student Chabad club and StandWithUs sponsored an Israeli Soldiers Stories (ISS) speaker program. The event deteriorated into near chaos because a heckler continually screamed invectives, and members of Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace hurled continuous insults at the speakers. Such disruptions have become a favored tactic of anti-Israel activists, most notoriously when Muslim Student Union members almost succeeded in preventing Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren from speaking at UC Irvine in February 2010. Their goal is to let mainstream pro-Israel speakers know they are not welcome on campuses, as the UC Davis protesters themselves said just before the ISS incident at a meeting that was caught on video. The unspoken objective is to create an atmosphere in which Israel and its supporters are regarded as pariahs on campuses with no right to present their case.

President Yudof also condemned another practice commonly used by the anti-Israel movement. He specifically denounced the recent defacement of an Israeli flag on display at UC Riversides Hillel, underscoring that Jewish students who identify with Israel have rights and sensitivities like other minorities, and symbols important to their identity should be respected. This rebuke was unacceptable to the anti-Israel activists who regularly mock or deface Israeli and Jewish icons and symbols, from exploiting a picture of Anne Frank to juxtaposing swastikas with the Jewish Star of David.

President Yudofs statement did not take a side in the debate about Israel, but it let anti-Israel activists know that their tactics, which violate free speech and Jewish sensitivities, are unacceptable.

Rather than recommend that anti-Israel activists moderate their behavior, Piterberg went on the attack. He charged that the statement was biased and showed unwarranted, disproportionate concern for Jewish students and alleged that it ignored harassment and threats to Palestinian and Arab students and their allies, though he could not cite any comparable examples of anyone disrupting their events. He denied that defacing Israeli symbols was an affront to Jewish students, declaring that it is racist to associate all Jews with Israel. He ridiculed the idea that anti-Semitism is a problem on campus, mocking such concerns as a figment of overwrought imaginations. To prove his point, he showed a Seinfeld clip satirizing such concerns.

Piterberg then argued that anti-Israel activists actions do not deny the free speech of others. He accused pro-Israel groups of misrepresenting the extremism of these incidents. Then, in a breathtaking inversion of reality, Piterberg contended that when incidents did become menacing or violent, it was because pro-Israel groups fomented or initiated the threatening atmosphere, essentially blaming the victims. He excoriated StandWithUs because it brings mainstream, pro-coexistence speakers to campuseshe apparently considers programs featuring such speakers to be extremist. Indeed, the UCLA Center for Near East Studies no longer includes such mainstream speakers in their programs.

Link:
The Piterberg Doctrine: Free speech for me but not for thee

Posted in Free Speech | Comments Off on The Piterberg Doctrine: Free speech for me but not for thee

Tarek Mehanna: Punishing Muslims for free speech only helps Al Qaeda

Posted: April 20, 2012 at 2:14 am

Tarek Mehannas political speech was controversial and offensive. But the prosecution did not show that he was willing to actually engage in violence.Terrorists win hearts and minds when the US government prosecutes Muslims in America with little regard for the Constitution.

On April 12 the United States government successfully convicted another young Muslim male who believed he had the right to express his deep disdain for American foreign policy in the Middle East and Asia. Tarek Mehanna, an American-born Bostonian, took his First Amendment rights quite seriously when he vocally condemned his government for killing thousands of Muslims abroad. As a result, he was convicted of conspiring to help Al Qaeda.

While his prosecution may appear to be another success in the nebulous war on terror, it is in fact a victory for terrorists abroad who win hearts and minds when the American government bends over backward to prosecute Muslims in America with little regard for the Constitution.

Without a doubt, Mr. Mehannas political beliefs and speech were controversial if not outright offensive. Indeed the prosecutors highlighted a website run by Mehanna that often posted English language translations of Islamic teachings in favor of self-defense and circulated gruesome jihadi videos.

But what the prosecution was unable to show was Mehannas willingness to actually engage in violence in furtherance of his political beliefs. At numerous junctures during which Mehanna was under surveillance, Mehanna rebuked overtures by government informants and others to join them in a terrorist attack. To the contrary, Mehanna limited his actions to speaking out and writing against US foreign policy as well as translating controversial extremist materials into English.

In addition, Mehanna traveled to Yemen in 2004. He claimed his visit was to study Arabic and Islam. The government alleged he went to join Al Qaeda and later returned home to assist the terrorist organization expand its influence in the US. But both admit that Mehanna never actually planned or attempted to execute a violent terrorist act.

But for the 2010 Supreme Courts flawed decision in Humanitarian Law Project v. Holder (HLP), it is doubtful the prosecution would have stood a chance at a conviction. The ruling in HLP criminalized coordinated advocacy with a designated terrorist group as unlawful material support to terrorism, while independent advocacy remained protected by the First Amendment.

Thus the case came down to whether Mehannas vocal criticism of US military practices in Afghanistan, Iraq, and other Muslim majority countries was coordinated with Al Qaeda operatives. Similarly, when he translated Islamic literature and Al Qaeda propaganda, the government labeled it coordinated advocacy such that he was providing unlawful material support to terrorism.

Ultimately, the case depended on whether the jury believed the governments explanation for Mehannas 2004 trip to Yemen. Had he not taken the trip, perhaps he would never have been convicted of conspiring to aid Al Qaeda, though he likely would still have been prosecuted.

View original post here:
Tarek Mehanna: Punishing Muslims for free speech only helps Al Qaeda

Posted in Free Speech | Comments Off on Tarek Mehanna: Punishing Muslims for free speech only helps Al Qaeda

The firing of Brooke Harris: a teachable moment about free speech

Posted: at 2:14 am

Last month, Michigan teacher Brooke Harris was fired for allegedly helping students organize a 'hoodie' fundraiser for the family of Trayvon Martin. By all means, give Harris her job back. But lets also support the free-speech rights of all of our teachers, not just the ones we agree with.

The Trayvon Martin case has claimed a new martyr. The first one was Martin, the Florida teenager gunned down on Feb. 26 by neighborhood watchman George Zimmerman. Now theres Michigan teacher Brooke Harris, who was fired last month, allegedly for helping her 8th-grade students organize a fundraiser for Martins family.

Ms. Harris quickly became a cause clbre on the Internet, where more than 200,000 people have signed a petition calling for her reinstatement. As the petition correctly noted, dismissals of this type create an atmosphere of fear in American schools. We will not tolerate the silencing of our nations best teachers, the petition declared.

But we do tolerate it, and increasingly so. Harriss firing comes at a historic low point for teacher freedom in the United States. And most of us have stood idly by, because we dont really believe that teachers should have freedom. Instead, we want them to echo our own views.

Consider the case of Jillian Caruso, who was fired from her Massapequa Park, N.Y., elementary school after her principal objected to a picture of George W. Bush that she displayed in her classroom during Bushs 2004 re-election campaign. A member of the Republican National Committee, Ms. Caruso alleged that the principal who was married to a Democratic state assemblyman violated her First Amendment rights to free speech and association.

Carusos dismissal generated a few columns and blog posts from outraged Republicans. But from Democrats? Not a peep. Nor did I hear much protest from any side of the aisle when a federal jury ruled against Caruso in 2007.

In instructing the jury, the presiding judge emphasized that Caruso had freedom of speech in her capacity as a citizen, but not as a teacher. So she was free to support President Bush on her own time and on her own dime but not while she was in school.

Here the judge invoked the Supreme Courts 2006 decision in Garcetti v. Ceballos, which said that public employees have no First Amendment rights when they are speaking as part of their official duties. The state hires employees to deliver a certain message, the court said, so it can also penalize those who deviate from it.

Since then, federal courts have used Garcetti to uphold the removal of an Indiana teacher who told her students she opposed the war in Iraq, and of an Ohio teacher who asked her class to report on examples from the American Library Associations 100 most frequently challenged books. The right to free speech...does not extend to the in-class curricular speech of teachers in primary and secondary schools, the Ohio ruling flatly declared.

Thats a huge problem for anyone who cares about American democracy. Teachers do not simply work for the government; theyre supposed to help students learn how to function within it. So they also need to model the skills and habits that democracy demands, especially the ability to analyze and evaluate different points of view.

Here is the original post:
The firing of Brooke Harris: a teachable moment about free speech

Posted in Free Speech | Comments Off on The firing of Brooke Harris: a teachable moment about free speech