Monthly Archives: February 2012

7th grader helps Freedom Center

Posted: February 15, 2012 at 5:04 am

CINCINNATI - The financially troubled National Underground Railroad Freedom Center is getting a new lease on life.
            
A new plan would save more than $1 million by combining some management operations with the Cincinnati Museum Center.
     
This is welcome news for the center, and community leaders as well as freedom center visitors.
       
With an estimated $1.5 million deficit wiped away, they hope to see this center continue to teach its important lessons for both young and old.

One of the Freedom Center's biggest fans, who is very excited to hear about the new plans for keeping the center open, is only 12 years old.

Maia Thompson, a seventh grader at Mason Middle School, was shocked to hear about the Freedom Center's financial woes.

"I was sitting with my mom and I heard that the freedom center might be closing and I started going crazy. I was like, 'What? I know this can't be happening," said Thompson.

Last year Maia decided to do whatever she could to help out the Freedom Center. It started with creating a YouTube video asking for help. In it she says, "Up here we have something called the Freedom Center. It's an amazing experience and it taught me a lot. I recently learned that the center might be closing down..."

Maia didn't stop there. She also decided to create a special Freedom Center T-shirt with the words "Fan the Flame" and "Be the Spark".

"I discovered a website and I found out you could make shirts on it, and you sell them for a profit," she said.

The T-shirts will be sold at the Freedom Center gift shop and at the "Taste of Mason" celebration on Wednesday night.

Maia's mom, Deborah Thompson, is especially proud.

"Maia is the kind of person who is always giving and always sharing and... that's one of the things she'll do," she said.

When asked if she'd like to work at the Freedom Center, Maia replied, "Yes. I think I'd like to be a tour guide because it would be really cool to show people around and talk to them about the exhibits."

Details of both museums' new management system will unfold during a news conference Wednesday morning.

Stay with 9 News and WCPO.com for updates.

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Continued here:
7th grader helps Freedom Center

Posted in Freedom | Comments Off on 7th grader helps Freedom Center

Freedom High School boys basketball team advances to LVC title game with 45-40 victory over Parkland High School

Posted: at 5:04 am

Nyreef Jackson and his Freedom High School boys basketball teammates distinctly remember what happened on Jan. 20.

Parkland rallied for a two-point victory that night to ruin the Patriots' bid for an unbeaten season.

Freedom wasn't about to be denied again.

Jackson scored 16 points to snap out of a scoring slump and the Patriots hung on for a 45-40 victory over the Trojans in a Lehigh Valley Conference tournament semifinal at Allen High School's J. Milo Sewards Gymnasium.

"We really wanted this game," said Jackson, a junior forward. "They beat us the last time and we didn't forget that. That was a tough loss and we wanted to see them again. We were really confident today."

Freedom (20-3), which has never won a conference championship, advances to the title game against top-seeded Emmaus at 8 p.m., Friday at Allen. The Green Hornets defeated Easton 52-39 in the other semifinal.

Emmaus dealt Freedom a 48-43 loss on Jan. 31 in Bethlehem Township.

"This is a special feeling," Freedom coach Joe Stellato said, "but I don't want to get too emotional. We still have another battle coming up on Friday."

Joe Lococo, Freedom's leading scorer at 14.7 points per game, was held to four points through three quarters. But the senior guard made six clutch foul shots in the final 2:51 to help seal the win.

"I've said it all year, this team finds ways to win," said Stellato, whose team was 8-14 last season. "Every game they amaze me. I'm shocked at how these kids dig themselves out of holes."

The Patriots' lead seemed safe when Derike Chiclana's two free throws gave them a 43-37 lead with 21 seconds left.

Sophomore Justin Zajko made Parkland's only 3-pointer of the night to pull the Trojans within 43-40. Chiclana was immediately fouled with 12 seconds left, and the junior center missed the front end of the 1-and-1 free throw attempt.

Parkland (18-5) got the ball into the hands of junior guard Austin Beidelman, who hit the winning 3-pointer in the first game against Freedom. This time Beidelman's high-arcing 3 bounced off the back iron. Lococo added two free throws with 1.8 ticks remaining.

"I'd let (Beidelman) take that shot again," Parkland coach Andy Stephens said. "He's pretty good in tough situations. I give him a lot of credit just for wanting to take the shot. For a junior, that's definitely a good thing."

Jackson, considered Freedom's top defender, was primarily responsible for harassing Beidelman (14.5 ppg) into a 4-for-17 shooting night for eight points.

"He's a tough player, an all-league player," Jackson said. "I just tried to keep him in front of me and not give him wide-open shots. He has a nice shot with a lot of arc. I thought that (3-point attempt) was going to sink right in."

The game evolved into somewhat of a chess match as Freedom extended its defense to deny Parkland the 3-point shot. The Trojans shot 1-for-12 from distance.

Stephens seemed content to work the ball inside to burly forwards Rob Dvoracek and Daulton Charles, who finished with 10 points.

"I thought we could pound it inside and utilize our strength," Stephens said, "and I thought that would open up our perimeter game. It was a hard-fought battle. Give Freedom credit. They have the record they do for a reason."

Read the original:
Freedom High School boys basketball team advances to LVC title game with 45-40 victory over Parkland High School

Posted in Freedom | Comments Off on Freedom High School boys basketball team advances to LVC title game with 45-40 victory over Parkland High School

Fate of Freedom Fest in Pendleton uncertain this year

Posted: at 5:04 am

PENDLETON — Freedom Fest, Pendleton’s patriotic summer celebration, will not happen this year unless a new organizer steps in.

The event has been held 1990 on the Saturday before July 4 at Veterans Park, with fireworks, vendors, games and live music.

Friends of the Park, an organization that raises money and takes care of Veterans Park, recently voted against organizing and being the lead sponsor of the event. So far no one has contacted Pendleton Town Hall about planning Freedom Fest, said Amber Barnes, interim town administrator.

On Feb. 6, the Pendleton Town Council approved Friends of the Park’s request to dedicate the $2,500 budget for Freedom Fest to the Step Up to the Plate fundraising campaign to renovate the park’s ball fields.

The group reluctantly gave up planning Freedom Fest, said Friends member Nancy Hellams.

“It was a hard decision because we always felt very good to be able to provide that for the community,” Hellams said. She was chairwoman of Friends of the Park and Freedom Fest for three years, but stepped down in January to take a break from such time-consuming projects.

About 100 volunteers and more than 25 sponsors make Freedom Fest happen every year. Finding enough volunteers for the event is not a problem for Friends of the Park, Hellams said, nor is money. But the June heat is brutal to older Friends members who man stations all day.

“People usually are willing to be help out, but we’ve gotten older,” Hellams said. “It wasn’t that we don’t want to do it. We just aren’t able to anymore.”

No other members expressed desire to pick up organization, she said.

Organizers plan entertainment and secure vendors, sponsorships and a pyrotechnics company to shoot fireworks. About 3,000 people come to the event each summer.

“I think a lot of folks are going to miss it, but it was a tremendous amount of work,” said Pendleton Mayor Pro Tem Bruce Kalley.

The town started Freedom Fest 22 years ago in honor of its bicentennial. In 2004, budget strains led the town to pass the main sponsorship and organization to Pendleton Home Builders for three years. Pendleton Home Builders approached Friends of the Park in 2008 to take over and over four years the group has raised more than $10,000 through Freedom Fest to renovate Veterans Park.

The American Legion Post 113 donates some money toward Freedom Fest each year, said member Jimmy Manley, but renovations to the post will overshadow taking over Freedom Fest responsibilities.

“We’ve been raising money ourselves to refurbish the building up there,” Manley said. “I hope somebody does pick it up.”

Past organizer Rick Moore of Pendleton Home Builders said the same thing.

“I’d hate to see it die because we put so much effort into it,” he said. He and business partner Fred Hamilton used some of their own money to fund Freedom Fest, but he declined to say how much. Moore said that at this point he and Hamilton would not consider being main organizers, but that they would help out in a smaller way.

The event has grown from a simple festival to one with a fireworks show rivaling ones held in Anderson and Seneca, Moore said. The town council allocated $5,000 to Freedom Fest in 2009, but by this year the amount was cut in half. Kalley said it’s possible that new organizers could receive town funding.

“They have to come to the council and ask and we would just have to look at it,” he said.

Go here to read the rest:
Fate of Freedom Fest in Pendleton uncertain this year

Posted in Freedom | Comments Off on Fate of Freedom Fest in Pendleton uncertain this year

Liberty All-Star(R) Growth Fund, Inc. January 2012 Monthly Update

Posted: at 5:03 am

BOSTON, MA--(Marketwire -02/14/12)- Below is the January 2012 Monthly Update for the Liberty All-Star® Growth Fund, Inc. (NYSE: ASG - News)

Liberty All-Star Growth Fund Monthly Update
Ticker: ASG January 2012
Monthly Performance
Performance NAV Market Price Discount
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Beginning of month value $4.24 $3.81 10.1%
Distributions - -
End of month value $4.50 $4.04 10.2%
Performance for month 6.13% 6.04%
Performance year-to-date 6.13% 6.04%
Past performance cannot predict future
results
Net Assets at Month-End ($millions)
Total $135.4
Equities $131.3
Percent Invested 97.0%
Top 20 Holdings at Month-End
(34.2% of equity portfolio)
(Rank from previous month)
1 Apple, Inc. (1) 2.6%
2 QUALCOMM, Inc. (6) 2.0%
3 FMC Technologies, Inc. (3) 1.9%
4 IHS, Inc., Class A (5) 1.9%
5 Salesforce.com, Inc. (11) 1.9%
6 ACE Ltd. (4) 1.9%
7 Oceaneering International, Inc. (8) 1.9%
8 C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc. (2) 1.9%
9 American Tower Corp., Class A (10) 1.8%
10 Intuitive Surgical, Inc. (7) 1.8%
11 ARM Holdings PLC (12) 1.7%
12 Core Laboratories N.V. (9) 1.6%
13 VMware, Inc., Class A (18) 1.5%
14 Expeditors International of Washington, Inc. (17) 1.5%
15 LKQ Corp. (15) 1.4%
16 BioMarin Pharmaceutical, Inc. (16) 1.4%
17 Baidu, Inc. (21) 1.4%
18 Occidental Petroleum Corp. (20) 1.4%
19 Google, Inc., Class A (13) 1.4%
20 Rockwell Automation, Inc. (14) 1.3%
Holdings are subject to change.
Sector Breakdown(% of equity portfolio)*
Information Technology 30.3%
Industrials 15.0%
Health Care 13.6%
Consumer Discretionary 13.6%
Financials 9.6%
Energy 9.5%
Materials 3.1%
Consumer Staples 2.8%
Telecommunication Services 1.8%
Utilities 0.7%
100.0%
*Based on Standard & Poor's and MSCI Barra Global Industry Classification
Standard (GICS).
New Holdings Holdings Liquidated
Avago Technologies Ltd. CARBO Ceramics, Inc.
Fastenal Co. ICF International, Inc.
PriceSmart, Inc. SuccessFactors, Inc.
Xueda Education Group

Follow this link:
Liberty All-Star(R) Growth Fund, Inc. January 2012 Monthly Update

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Liberty All-Star(R) Growth Fund, Inc. January 2012 Monthly Update

Liberty girls drop KingCo title game

Posted: at 5:03 am

February 14, 2012

By Christina Lords

Delane Agnew, Liberty High School junior forward, lies sprawled on the floor but still tries to deny a rebound to Bellevue sophomore forward Holly Warendorf during the third quarter for the 3A KingCo Championship Feb. 9 at Bellevue College. By Greg Farrar

Liberty High School girls basketball coach Randy Leifer admits his team had an abysmal first half as they battled in the KingCo Conference 3A championship game Feb. 9 at Bellevue College.

It certainly didn’t help that the Bellevue Wolverines came out strong at both ends of the court, solidifying a 54-36 win over the Patriots.

“They were putting a lot of pressure on us, on our defense,” he said. “We didn’t take very good care of the basketball, and we settled for quick offensive shots.”

The Wolverines came into the tournament in the No. 4 slot and managed to overtake the Patriots with an 11-5 first-quarter lead. Bellevue boasted a 22-7 lead at halftime.

“They were able to get to the hoop a lot more than we did, and when they did, they shot the ball really well,” Leifer said.

The Wolverines’ defense held Liberty’s top scorers, Aspen Winegar and Sierra Carlson, to a combined 11 points. No Patriot scored in double figures — a situation the Patriots haven’t faced since the last time they took on Bellevue. Liberty dropped that game, 47-27, on Jan. 28.

Liberty only had four offensive rebounds for the night.

Leifer said he is proud of the success of the Patriots’ season and knew early in the year that the team had a shot at playing for the KingCo title.

“I thought we definitely had a chance, where we had several returning pieces from last year,” he said. “We lost some of our players, obviously, but we had three starters coming back, and I knew we had a shot at being there.”

Megan Tsutakawa led Liberty against the Wildcats with eight points. Winegar had six points, while Carlson added five points.

Bellevue’s Katie Savard contributed a game-high 13 points for the Wolverines.

 

Patriots stun Lake Washington

Two of the Patriots’ most-important games of the season came earlier in the week.

On Feb. 7, Winegar and Carlson hit clutch fourth-quarter shots as the Patriots upset second-seeded Lake Washington, 42-41. Lake Washington led 32-26 going into the final quarter. However, Liberty outscored the Kangaroos down the stretch to pull out the victory. Winegar hit a key 3-point field goal and Carlson followed with a game-winning basket to cap the Patriots’ rally.

Winegar finished with a game-high 13 points and Carlson had 11 points.

On Feb. 6, Liberty earned a berth to the Class 3A Sea-King District when it defeated visiting Mercer Island, 60-40, in a first-round, loser-out KingCo game.

Liberty bolted to a 20-7 first-quarter lead and held a commanding 42-18 advantage at halftime.

Winegar led the Patriots with 16 points and Carlson had 13 points.

Christina Lords: 392-6434, ext. 239, or newcastle@isspress.com. Comment at http://www.issaquahpress.com.

Written by Christina Lords · Filed Under Sports, Sports News 

Copyright 2011 by Issaquah Press Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, rewritten or redistributed without permission. E-mail editor@isspress.com

Comments

Read more:
Liberty girls drop KingCo title game

Posted in Liberty | Comments Off on Liberty girls drop KingCo title game

House committee adopts 2nd Amendment language

Posted: at 5:02 am

 

DES MOINES — A constitutional amendment protecting Iowans’ right to bear arms was approved by a House committee, but it wasn’t the one supporters hoped for.

Sponsor Rep. Matt Windschitl, R-Missouri Valley, offered House Joint Resolution 2005 — a constitutional amendment that must be approved by two session of the Legislature and Iowa voters — that would provide Iowans a fundamental right to “acquire, keep, possess, transport, carry, transfer and use arms to defend life and liberty and for all other legitimate purposes.” It would prohibit mandatory licensing, registration and special taxation of firearms.

He told the House Public Safety Committee his amendment would be “precise in protecting” Iowans’ Second Amendment rights.

However, Rep. Rick Olson, D-Des Moines, offered an amendment that substituted the last 14 words of the Second Amendment: “the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.”

Windschitl called it a dodge that wouldn’t fool backers of Second Amendment rights.

“What we’re trying to do is not uphold the U.S. Constitution (but) trying to get away from taking a politically tough vote,” he said about Olson’s amendment.

However, Public Safety Chairman Clel Baudler, R-Adair, argued that gun- rights supporters have used those words to win U.S. Supreme Court victories when they have challenged restrictive gun ordinances in Washington and Chicago.

“I cannot and will not vote against the U.S. Constitution,” Baudler said.

He was joined by two other Republican committee members, Reps. Dave Tjepkes of Gowrie and Gary Worthan of Storm Lake, in voting with Democrats to approve the amendment 11-10.

Windschitl promised to offer his wording when the bill, HJR 2005, comes to the House floor.

The Senate so far has shown little interest in taking up gun rights bills.

Read more from the original source:
House committee adopts 2nd Amendment language

Posted in Second Amendment | Comments Off on House committee adopts 2nd Amendment language

Breyer's Robbery Illustrates Why RKBA So Important Everywhere

Posted: at 5:02 am

To: LEGAL AFFAIRS AND NATIONAL EDITORS

BELLEVUE, Wash., Feb. 14, 2012 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The recent robbery of Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer at a vacation home in the West Indies should hopefully cause the learned jurist to re-examine his core beliefs about the individual right to keep and bear arms at places other than their primary residence, the Second Amendment Foundation said today.

Breyer has voted with the minority twice in recent years against recognizing that the Second Amendment protects an individual civil right to keep and bear arms, in both the Heller and McDonald cases. He was robbed last week, along with his wife and some guests, by an intruder wielding a machete, according to published reports. Justice Breyer was not harmed, but the robber got away with about $1,000 in cash.

"We're delighted that Justice Breyer was not hurt during this incident," said SAF founder and Executive Vice President Alan M. Gottlieb, "and hopefully this case will give him a new perspective on the right to bear arms for personal safety. Police cannot always be around when you need them, even if you're a Supreme Court justice. One does not leave his right of self-defense at the doorstep of his home when he travels.

"If this demonstrates anything to Justice Breyer," he continued, "it is that crime does not happen just at someone's primary residence, and criminals do not make appointments, giving someone time to unlock and assemble and load a firearm. You must be able to protect yourself, even on vacation outside of your home state, at a moment's notice. That's not just a civil right, but a basic human right.

"When Justice Breyer dissented in the Heller case," Gottlieb recalled, "he expressed concerns about keeping loaded firearms in the home for personal protection. Faced with a machete in the hands of a criminal, one wonders whether Breyer might have quietly wished he had a gun with which he could have defended himself, his wife and their guests. We hope this incident gives him new insight with which to temper his views."

The Second Amendment Foundation (www.saf.org) is the nation's oldest and largest tax-exempt education, research, publishing and legal action group focusing on the Constitutional right and heritage to privately own and possess firearms. Founded in 1974, The Foundation has grown to more than 650,000 members and supporters and conducts many programs designed to better inform the public about the consequences of gun control.

SOURCE Second Amendment Foundation

-0-

Read more from the original source:
Breyer's Robbery Illustrates Why RKBA So Important Everywhere

Posted in Second Amendment | Comments Off on Breyer's Robbery Illustrates Why RKBA So Important Everywhere

Gun advocates want ability to bring guns to work parking lots

Posted: at 5:02 am

NASHVILLE, TN (WSMV) -

It's an issue that has the business community and Second Amendment advocates at odds. Should permit holders be allowed to bring their guns on their commute to work?

Gun advocates want to be able to keep their guns locked in their cars at their workplace parking lot, and they say this plan needs to happen now, or else lawmakers are breaking promises.

Chris Smith knows a thing or two about gun permit holders. After all, he provides the training in order for them to get the permit.

"We're talking about law-abiding citizens. They want to defend their life, and they go through the proper training," said Smith, of Guns and Leather Inc.

Three years ago, state lawmakers made several changes to where permit holders would be allowed to bring their guns. But Second Amendment advocates say they haven't seen any movement on a plan to allow permit holders to keep their guns locked in their cars in their workplace parking lots.

"They want to feel safe while they are commuting, that they can have their firearms with them," said John Harris, with the Tennessee Firearms Association.

Second Amendment advocates are furious and feel like House leaders have betrayed them.

"Frankly, it's a litmus test in do you really believe in the Constitution or are you more beholden to corporate money," Harris said.

House leaders say they feel like they have done a lot to advance Second Amendment issues in the past few years, but they say there are other issues they must tackle.

"We have been focused on what we know what people of Tennessee want us to work on. Our economy needs to be looked at, and we want to make sure it's a job-friendly state," said Rep. Debra Maggart, R-Hendersonville.

Gun owners like Smith can see both sides of the argument, but for them, in the end it is about a fundamental right.

"They went through the proper training. They are going to keep that firearm locked up in their vehicle. That's their property, and I think the property owners should respect that," Smith said.

Senate leaders, including Lt. Gov. Ron Ramsey, have expressed a willingness to pass this bill this year.

However, it was delayed in a Senate committee late Tuesday afternoon.

Copyright WSMV 2012 (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.

Visit link:
Gun advocates want ability to bring guns to work parking lots

Posted in Second Amendment | Comments Off on Gun advocates want ability to bring guns to work parking lots

Montana's challenge to 'super PACs'

Posted: at 5:01 am

Montana's high court challenges the moral basis for the US Supreme Court's Citizens United ruling that spawned super PACs. The high court needs to rebalance free speech vs. democracy.

More than a century ago, a Montana industrialist named W.A. Clark used his wealth to buy a seat in the US Senate. Mark Twain wrote that Clark’s well-monied politicking had so sweetened corruption in Montana that “it no longer has an offensive smell.”

Skip to next paragraph

The state’s voters did rise up, however, at the power of money. They passed the 1912 Corrupt Practices Act. Ever since, the law has prohibited corporate spending on state political campaigns.

Now the law is under challenge in the US Supreme Court – the same court that decided in its 2010 Citizens United ruling that corporations have free-speech rights in unlimited spending on campaigns because there is no compelling case that they will demand something in return from politicians. The ruling has spawned a new kind of political-action committee, the “super PACs” now dominating the 2012 election campaigns.

The high court is reviewing a decision in December by the Montana Supreme Court that found the state still has a continuing and compelling interest to justify speech restrictions on corporations under the 1912 law.

Montana, being a state with a sparse population that is highly dependent on big farms and expensive mining, is “especially vulnerable to continued efforts of corporate control to the detriment of democracy and the republican form of government,” the state court wrote.

It cited many historical and recent examples of well-financed corruption as well as the fact that corporations have “a substantial presence and are active participants in Montana politics. The many lobbyists and political committees who participate in each session of the Montana Legislature bear witness.”

In addition, the court found a negative influence on voter enthusiasm from the outsized effects of corporate money. Even Clark himself admitted in 1900 that “[m]any people have become so indifferent to voting” in Montana as a result of the “large sums of money that have been expended in the state....”

The Montana court isn’t challenging the US Supreme Court directly on its reasoning in the Citizens ruling. Instead, it points to the ruling’s demand for a compelling interest – evidence – to curb corporate speech. In Montana, if not elsewhere, the evidence is clear.

If the US justices take the Montana case, they have a chance to refine their 2010 ruling and acknowledge that many states have a compelling case to curb big-money influence. Too many elected leaders allow big donors to influence official decisions.

The corrosive effects of big money on democracy are the legal equivalent of yelling fire in a crowded theater – a reason to impinge on free-speech rights under certain circumstances. The high court must find a better balance between its protection of free speech for corporations and the rights of a democracy to protect itself from large campaign donors who expect favors.

Read more:
Montana's challenge to 'super PACs'

Posted in Free Speech | Comments Off on Montana's challenge to 'super PACs'

In India, free speech a wavering ideal

Posted: February 14, 2012 at 4:25 pm

Booksellers offering their wares in Old Delhi, India. (Photo: Natalia Antelava)

Dozens of books have been banned in India because of their themes and topics. The country is trying to get Google and Facebook to devise a means of pre-filtering religiously objectionable content. All this, taken together, has many saying the country's freedom of speech is disappearing.

Book sellers in Old Delhi spread their goods on the pavement along one the city’s busiest streets every Sunday.

People push and shove as they scan rows of books laid out on the road. From Tolstoy in Russian to Hitler’s Mein Kampf, it looks as if you could find anything here. But you can’t.

A bookseller offers an obscure tome on Siberian railroad systems by Salman Rushdie. But ask instead for a copy of India’s most famous author's best known book, “The Satanic Verses” and the conversation is over.

The man just grins and looks away.

Rushdie’s 1988 novel infuriated some Muslims for its portrayal of the Prophet Muhammad. More than 20 years after its publication, the book is still banned in India.

Last month, Rushdie canceled a visit to India after he was told it was too dangerous for him to take part in a literary festival in Jaipur. He accused the Indian government of fabricating threats and preventing him from coming, just to please Muslim voters ahead of a key regional election.

Nilanjana Roy, an Indian literary critic, said whether Rushdie’s right, people who are running the world’s biggest democracy are failing to protect free speech.

“This entire business about having to cave in because the other side is being violent means you are allowing yourself to be bullied,” she said. “It is the state’s job to stand up and say we will not allow that to happen.”

It’s not just the Satanic Verses. Dozens of books and films are banned in India, often because of what’s deemed offensive religious content, though one of the Indiana Jones movies is banned for its so-called imperialistic tendencies and racist portrayal of Indians. Roy said she worries where things are heading.

“If everyone is free to claim offense, it will become less and less possible to accuse a politician of corruption, for example,” Roy said. “We love comparing ourselves to China in terms of how free we are, but if you look closely on it we’ve slid down to 122nd place in the list of countries when it comes to media freedom, to Internet freedom. That isn’t a happy ranking.”

Comparisons with China are growing increasingly common in India. Last year the country’s communications minister asked social networking sites to devise a system to filter and block “objectionable” comments. And the Delhi High Court is currently reviewing a case filed against 20 companies, including Google and Facebook, demanding that they pre-screen religiously “offensive” comments.

Vinay Rai, editor of Akbari magazine, who filed the criminal lawsuit, said India is a country that needs some censorship.

“Posting offensive content in a socially conservative country, which has a history of religious violence, presents a real danger to public,” Roy said.

But even when there’s no obvious danger to the public, the Indian government may still take offense.

Recently, a joke on the Tonight Show with Jay Leno turned into a diplomatic incident. The Indian government complained to the U.S. State Department after Leno showed a photo of India’s Golden Temple, which is sacred to Sikhs, and described it as Mitt Romney’s summer home.

The issue of free expression has prompted heated discussion in India. In a debate that was later televised, Shoma Chaudhury, managing editor of the liberal Tehelka magazine, recently took on Justice Markandey Katju, the government-appointed head of India's press council.

“India is different,” Katju said. “For many in India, freedom is food and security.”

“But how do you change a society unless you push the boundaries?” Chaudhury asked. “How will the boundaries of the society be pushed unless we question them?”

But pushing boundaries can be dangerous here. There is a growing list of artists, writers, academics and journalists who have been beaten, harassed and pushed into exile.

In central Delhi, an artist named Balbir Krishan, a double amputee who is also openly gay, was attacked during a recent exhibition by masked men who pushed him to the ground and kicked him. His most recent work deals with gay themes.

The men shouted “Get out of the country, you don’t belong here.” It was only after 24 hours of media pressure that the police launched an investigation.

“It’s going to become more dangerous,” Krishan said. “I am scared.”

Krishan said his role as an artist is to show people things they don’t want to see, to make people uncomfortable and make them think.

But he added that unless politicians step in and protect his right to do that, then the voices of those who are against him will become louder and clearer than his.

----------------------------------------------------------

"PRI's "The World" is a one-hour, weekday radio news magazine offering a mix of news, features, interviews, and music from around the globe. "The World" is a co-production of the BBC World Service, PRI and WGBH Boston. More about The World.

Go here to see the original:
In India, free speech a wavering ideal

Posted in Free Speech | Comments Off on In India, free speech a wavering ideal