I love a good coincidence, and this story has two. One is pedestrian, the other cosmic.
It starts with me pondering Gaia data. Gaia is a European Space Agency observatory that is revolutionizing astronomy. Its mission is to accurately map the positions, colors, distances, and motions of over a billion stars yes, a billion, about 1% of all the stars in our galaxy and create a massive database of the results, essentially a 3D map of the Milky Way galaxy.
Such surveys are incredibly useful. New objects can be found this way, like stellar streams. Sometimes hidden objects reveal themselves in the data. The shape of the galaxy can be found, as well as the distances to star clusters, the remains of cannibalized galaxies, and, importantly, the distances to some stars that are used to calibrate our distance scales to other galaxies, and from there the Universe.
And, sometimes, they can solve age-old mysteries. For example, the star Albireo is a close double star, but are the two stars physically related? Astronomers argued for a long time, but Gaia data easily showed that nope, they're not related, at two very different distances but just coincidentally aligned in the sky.
Which brings us to M73.
This is purportedly a small, loose cluster of stars in the constellation of Aquarius. The M in its name means it was catalogued by the famous French astronomer Charles Messier, who was a comet hunter in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. As he scanned the sky looking for these objects, he kept stumbling on fuzzy things that were easily mistaken for comets, and he got irritated enough by them that he listed them in his now-famous Messier Catalog, so that others might not be fooled.
Thing is, those are some of the brightest and best-known objects in the sky now. The Orion Nebula, the Andromeda galaxy, the Pleiades... all of these and 100 more sport M numbers.
And then there's M73. This is the object in question:
I know, right? Not much there. The cluster is composed of the four bright stars in the center, and the three slightly dimmer ones below. To Messier, in his small telescope, they looked a bit fuzzy so he listed them, claiming he saw nebulosity around them, what we now think of as clouds of gas and dust. Many clusters are still embedded in the material they were born from (see the aforementioned Pleiades), so fair enough.
Decades later, John Herschel was making his own, much larger catalog, called the General Catalogue of Nebulae and Clusters of Stars, and noted that M73 was listed by Messier. To him they just looked like stars (he notes it looks "very poor" and lists it as "Cl??" meaning "cluster??"). Years later, when John Lewis Emil Dreyer compiled the extensive (and still used) New General Catalog,he listed M73 in his catalog as NGC 6994, and while he copied Herschel's comments he took the question marks away, so it's listed as just "Cl, eP, vlC, no neb.": cluster, extremely poor, very little compressed, no nebulosity"*.
And that's the thing. Ever since then over a century ago! astronomers have argued over this collection of 7 stars. Is it a cluster or not?
It's a fair question. Clusters usually have dozens or hundreds of stars, but as they age stars get ejected, and at some point you're going to have just a few stars hanging out together. Is M73 one of those?
Two papers came out by professional astronomers at almost the same time tackling this issue. Although using different telescopes, they both looked at the colors of the stars if plotted a certain way, that can be used to determine if stars belong in a cluster or not. And guess what? Go ahead, guess!
Yup. In one paper a researcher concluded the stars were not in a cluster, and in the other, they concluded they were. Hurray.
So which is it?
About a year later, another team of astronomers took spectra of the stars, breaking their light up into individual colors, in order to look for a Doppler shift which determines if the stars are moving toward or away from us, and how rapidly. If the stars are physically in a cluster, they should all have roughly the same velocities.
And... they don't. One, for example, is moving toward us at 53 kilometers per second, while another is moving away at 35 km/sec. The others are scattered all over the place in between those two values.
It's pretty clear, then, they're not in a cluster together.
But, maaaaaybe they recently underwent some big scattering event, sending them every which way. That's hugely unlikely, but it would be nice to know for sure.
... and that brings us back to Gaia. It measures the distances to stars via parallax, and is very accurate for stars like this. The conclusion?
Nope. The stars are at all different distances, ranging from about 1,000 to 3,000 light years (although one has a distance of 45,000 light years, which is far enough that Gaia has a harder time measuring parallax, so the distance is a bit uncertain). A cluster of stars is usually just a few dozen light years across at most, so these stars are clearly physically unassociated with each other.
Their apparent closeness in the sky is therefore a coincidence, an illusion. It's like seeing a bug on your window apparently next to a distant mountain. The Universe is tricksy that way.
In other words: M73 is not a cluster. Never was, never will be.
So that's the cosmic coincidence. What's the pedestrian one?
As I said, I've written about Gaia data debunking some astronomical objects like Albireo. As an amateur astronomer of many decades, I've done my share of scratching my head over M73 (though honestly I've always leaned toward it being an outcome of chance). So I've had a note to write about this for a couple of years, but just never got around to it.
Then out of the blue I got an email from reader Dean Lewis. He asked me if I had seen the Deep Sky Videos series, created by professional astronomers, that goes over (nearly) every object in Messier's catalog.
I hadn't, as it turns out, despite it being done by people like Dr. Becky Smethurst, a noted and wonderful science communicator. And amazingly the second coincidence the video he watched that made him want to contact me was on M73!
Well! That pushed me to finally write up this little tale. And Dr. Smethurst had some info in her video I was unaware of, and used as reference material in the article you're reading now, matter of fact. She did a great job, so give it a watch:
Lovely. I like how she talks about confirmation bias, and even how astronomers can be fooled, even when looking at almost essentially the same data. One reason we have so many rules in science when publishing is to avoid bias in our interpretation of data. It doesn't always work, but in the end here we are. We now know M73 is not a cluster, and we've learned hopefully to be a little more careful.
Gaia has been an amazing tool for this. And it's nowhere near finished, either. A new data release is scheduled for December 2020, and will have 1.5 billion stars in it. What new treasures are buried in the observations?
And what treasures do we hold now that it will show to be fool's gold? With open eyes and open minds, I guess we'll find out.
* Correction: I originally made some errors in this part of the article, saying William Herschel made the NGC; I conflated a couple of things there. William was John's father, and while he and his wife Caroline made a catalog, the NGC came later. My thanks to Larry Faltz, editor of Sky WAAtch,for pointing this out to me!
- The Milky Way may have grown up faster than astronomers suspected - Science News Magazine - May 18th, 2021
- Astronomy: Discovering the Universe with cutting-edge technology - Open Access Government - May 18th, 2021
- Pune: 16-year-old astronomy lover clicks stunning pic of moon with 55,000 images - Republic World - May 18th, 2021
- Astronomers Measure the Background Brightness of the Night sky Across the World. Canary Islands are the Darkest in the Survey - Universe Today - May 18th, 2021
- Astronomy events 2021: These happenings will make you starry-eyed this summer - Woman & Home - May 18th, 2021
- Maui Teens and UH Astronomer Featured in Xploration Awesome Planet TV Show - Maui Now - May 18th, 2021
- Dark matter might heat exoplanets enough to make them glow - SYFY WIRE - May 18th, 2021
- Tour UVic's telescope and chat with astronomers during Greater Victoria's 'Star Party' Victoria News - Victoria News - May 18th, 2021
- Nehru Planetarium director, who helped make astronomy accessible to the young, dies of Covid - The Indian Express - May 18th, 2021
- Calendar of Astronomy Events Summer 2021: 7 Stargazing Events to Watch - Real Simple - May 18th, 2021
- International Astronomy Day: Astronomy Quotes That Will Inspire You To Explore The Cosmos - International Business Times - May 18th, 2021
- Astronomers get rare and surprising before and after shots of a star going supernova - CBC.ca - May 18th, 2021
- Astronomers keep finding mysterious circular rings in the sky and don't know how to explain them - Livescience.com - May 11th, 2021
- National Radio Astronomy Observatory featured in the 2021 STEM for All Video Showcase - Newswise - May 11th, 2021
- Hapless star 'spaghettified' by black hole. And astronomers capture the gory show in a first. - Livescience.com - May 11th, 2021
- How the Starlink satellites spotted over western Washington can interfere with astronomers research - KING5.com - May 11th, 2021
- By Jove! Jupiter Shows Its Stripes and Colors - Newswise - May 11th, 2021
- Astronomers are Watching a gas Giant Grow, Right in Front of Their Eyes - Universe Today - May 9th, 2021
- How Islamic astronomers changed Chinas view of the stars - The National - May 9th, 2021
- Astronomy: Supermassive black hole at center of Milky Way has mass of 4.6 million suns - The Columbus Dispatch - April 25th, 2021
- Tiny newfound 'Unicorn' is closest known black hole to Earth - Space.com - April 25th, 2021
- Will Satellites Cripple Ground-Based Astronomy? - Optics & Photonics News - April 25th, 2021
- Did forgotten astronomy artist have Bradford connections? - Bradford Telegraph and Argus - April 25th, 2021
- Mapping cancer as if it were the universe - The Economist - April 25th, 2021
- In the light of the Super Pink Moon, look for the radiant Tycho crater - Space.com - April 25th, 2021
- Looking at the stars, or falling by the wayside? How astronomy is failing female scientists - The Conversation AU - April 23rd, 2021
- W. Vincent Liu Elected to Physics and Astronomy Organization Leadership - UPJ Athletics - April 23rd, 2021
- Black hole is closest to Earth, among the smallest ever discovered - The Ohio State University News - April 23rd, 2021
- Millions of lonely black holes are in our galaxy. Heres how well find some of them. - SYFY WIRE - April 23rd, 2021
- UH astronomers to help map the first galaxies in the universe | University of Hawaii System News - UH System Current News - April 23rd, 2021
- A supermoon and a meteor shower: astronomical events this April - The Hindu - April 23rd, 2021
- Astronomy magazine 1-year subs just dropped to $13 (Reg. $45+), more from $6 - 9to5Toys - April 13th, 2021
- Spitzer Discovers Three Most Rapidly-Rotating Brown Dwarfs | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - April 13th, 2021
- International Dark Sky Week is April 5 to 12 - EarthSky - April 13th, 2021
- 'Looking Up' Podcast Explores Cincinnati's Connection to Space, the Final Frontier - Cincinnati CityBeat - April 13th, 2021
- Here's how to catch a star-studded April thanks to these astronomy events - woman&home - April 13th, 2021
- Limerick Astronomy Club: The Moons of Jupiter - Limerick Leader - April 13th, 2021
- International astronomy team reveal images of star-forming galaxies - Yahoo Eurosport UK - April 13th, 2021
- From fireballs in the sky to a shark in the stars: the astronomical artistry of Segar Passi - The Conversation AU - April 13th, 2021
- Written in the Stars: April astronomy calendar The Rocky Mountain Collegian - Rocky Mountain Collegian - March 31st, 2021
- Light pollution from satellites 'poses threat' to astronomy - The Guardian - March 31st, 2021
- Astrotourism: These resorts will have you seeing stars - USA TODAY - March 31st, 2021
- Hubble Team Releases Reprocessed Image of Veil Nebula | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - March 31st, 2021
- Astronomers find the 'safest place' to live in the Milky Way - Livescience.com - March 31st, 2021
- YSU's star of the stars remembered | News, Sports, Jobs - Youngstown Vindicator - March 31st, 2021
- Cygnus X-1's Stellar-Mass Black Hole is More Massive than Astronomers Thought | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - February 25th, 2021
- Astronomers Make a Weird Discovery: A Concentration of Smaller Black Holes Lurking Where They Expected a Single Massive Black Hole - SciTechDaily - February 25th, 2021
- Is there an angry baby neutron star in the middle of Supernova 1987A? - SYFY WIRE - February 25th, 2021
- Planetary defense plan activated: astronomers appeal to observe Apophis asteroid, which will graze Earth in... - Business Insider - February 25th, 2021
- 'Super Bowl of Astronomy' kicks off online due to global pandemic - Space.com - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomers document the rise and fall of a rarely observed stellar dance - UW News - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomers observe the death of a distant galaxy for the first time - CBS News - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomers have witnessed a distant galaxy die for the first time - PennLive - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomers see a Hint of the Gravitational Wave Background to the Universe - Universe Today - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomy 2021: The biggest events including a super moon lunar eclipse - The Know - January 17th, 2021
- Astronomers Rewind the Clock to Calculate Age of Supernova Blast From Massive Star Explosion - SciTechDaily - January 17th, 2021
- Researchers find strong hints of background 'sea' of gravity waves - Astronomy Now Online - January 17th, 2021
- From meteor showers to New Moons: The astronomy calendar for 2021 - IamExpat in the Netherlands - January 17th, 2021
- The Music Of The Stars: Sounds From Space Teaching Astronomy To The Blind - Greek City Times - GreekCityTimes.com - January 9th, 2021
- Astronomers just discovered the oldest and most distant galaxy ever - The Next Web - January 9th, 2021
- Astronomers Discover Hundreds of High-Velocity Stars, Many on Their Way Out of the Milky Way - Universe Today - January 9th, 2021
- Astronomers set a new Record and Find the Farthest Galaxy. Its Light Took 13.4 Billion Years to Reach us - Universe Today - January 9th, 2021
- Indigenous astronomies and 'astro-colonialism' - CBC.ca - January 9th, 2021
- Super moons, meteor showers and other stargazing and astronomy dates in the UK for 2021 - Manchester Evening News - January 9th, 2021
- Morehead's Teen Science Cafe to focus on how astronomical questions are answered - WRAL.com - January 9th, 2021
- George Robert Carruthers: Astronautical Engineer and Astronomer - National Air and Space Museum - January 9th, 2021
- Astronomy: The bizarre planet: Uranus - RTL Today - January 9th, 2021
- Colliding stars reveal fundamental properties of matter and space-time - UMN News - December 19th, 2020
- Exploring the Wonders of the Night Sky - Smith College Grcourt Gate - December 19th, 2020
- Astronomers Are Now Obsessed With a Particular Gas on Venus - The Atlantic - December 19th, 2020
- GN-z11 Confirmed as Farthest Galaxy Ever Observed | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - December 19th, 2020
- Astronomers Locate the Oldest and Most Distant Galaxy in the Universe Defines the Very Boundary of the Observable Universe - SciTechDaily - December 19th, 2020
- These new smart telescopes aim to open up stargazing and astronomy to all - ZDNet - December 19th, 2020
- The best gift in the galaxy: an astronomers guide to buying a home telescope - The Conversation AU - December 19th, 2020
- Sloan survey gives Yale astronomers an eye in the sky - Yale News - December 19th, 2020
- It's official! Astronomers confirm GN-z11 is the most distant galaxy ever seen - SYFY WIRE - December 19th, 2020
- Scientists thrilled with asteroid treasure returned by Japanese spacecraft - Astronomy Now Online - December 19th, 2020
- China is opening the world's largest radio telescope up to international scientists - Space.com - December 19th, 2020
- Astronomers measured the distance to an ancient galaxy - Tech Explorist - December 19th, 2020
- Photographers and astronomy lovers invited to reach for the stars - The Irish Times - December 19th, 2020