Washington, D.C. residents, you dont have to holster your Second Amendment rights anymore. Unfortunately, residents of many other states like California dont have the same ability that D.C. residents now do to protect themselves.
In a stirring victory for those who live in the nationals capital, a panel of the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals recently threw out a D.C. ordinance that denied concealed-carry permits to anyone who could not show a special need for self-defense, what is referred to as a good reason requirement. The problem is that other courts of appeal have upheld such restrictive laws and the U.S. Supreme Court has turned down appeals of those decisions, refusing to take up the issue of the Second Amendments application to carrying a weapon outside of the home.
This happened most recently at the very end of the Supreme Courts 2017 term in June when it refused to take up Peruta v. California, an appeal of a decision of the Ninth Circuit upholding Californias good reason requirement.
In a scathing dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas (joined by Neil Gorsuch) castigated the other justices for treating the Second Amendment as a disfavored right. He said it was long-past time for the Court to decide this issue and that he found it extremely improbable that the Framers understood the Second Amendment to protect little more than carrying a gun from the bedroom to the kitchen.
In the opinion over the District of Columbias concealed carry law written by Judge Thomas Griffith of the D.C. Circuit, Griffith pointed out that the U.S. Supreme Courts first in-depth examination of the Second Amendment occurred in 2008 in District of Columbia v. Heller, where the Court threw out D.C.s complete ban on handguns as unconstitutional.
That decision is younger than the first iPhone. The Supreme Court did not outline how the Second Amendment applies to the carrying of a weapon in public, but as Griffith says, Heller reveals the Second Amendment erects some absolute barriers than no gun law may breach.
After Heller, D.C. implemented a complete ban on concealed carry. That was struck down in 2014 in Palmer v. District of Columbia. D.C. responded by restricting concealed-carry permits only to those who could show a good reason to fear injury. That required showing a special need for self-protection distinguishable from the general community as supported by evidence of specific threats or previous attacks.
Living in a high-crime neighborhood wasnt a good enough reason for a concealed-carry permit under D.C.s regulation. In essence, you had to prove you had a good reason to exercise your constitutional right, a bizarre situation unique in American constitutional jurisprudence.
D.C. argued, absurdly enough, that its ordinance did not violate any constitutional right because the Second Amendment doesnt apply outside of the home.
Judge Griffith dismissed this claim, saying that the fact that the need for self-defense is most pressing in the home doesnt mean that self-defense at home is the only right at the [Second] Amendments core.
Obviously, the need for self-defense might arise beyond as well as within the home. Further, the Second Amendments text protects the right to bear as well as keep arms. Thus, it is natural that the core of the Second Amendment includes a law-abiding citizens right to carry common firearms for self-defense beyond the home.
Even under Heller, governments can apply regulations on the possession and carrying of firearms that are longstanding, such as bans on possession by felons or bans on carrying near sensitive sites such as government buildings. But preventing carrying in public is not a longstanding tradition or rule.
This opinion goes into detail discussing the long American and English history applicable to weapons and self-defense, going back as far as the Statute of Northampton of 1328 -- whose text, as the court says, will remind Anglophiles of studying Canterbury Tales in the original. But the state of the law in Chaucers England or for that matter Shakespeares or Cromwells is not decisive here.
What is decisive is that the Supreme Court established in Heller that by the time of the Founding, the preexisting right enshrined by the Amendment had ripened to include carrying more broadly than the District contends based on its reading of the 14th-century statute. According to Griffith, the individual right to carry common firearms beyond the home for self-defense even in densely populated areas, even for those lacking special self-defense needs falls within the core of the Second Amendments protections.
Unfortunately, other federal courts of appeals have upheld similar good reason laws for concealed carry permits. But as Judge Griffith points out, those courts dispensed with the historic digging that would have exposed that their toleration of regulations restricting the carrying of a weapon is faulty.
The constitutional analysis that should be applied to all government gun regulations is that they must allow gun access at least for each typical member of the American public. Because D.C.s restrictive good reason concealed-carry law bars most people from exercising their Second Amendment right at all, it is unconstitutional. At a minimum, the Second Amendment must protect carrying given the risks and needs typical of law-abiding citizens.
The court drew together all the pieces of its analysis in this way:
At the Second Amendments core lies the right of responsible citizens to carry firearms for personal self-defense beyond the home, subject to longstanding restrictions. These traditional limits include, for instance, licensing requirements, but not bans on carrying in urban areas like D.C. or bans on carrying absent a special need for self-defense. In fact, the Amendments core at a minimum shields the typically situated citizens ability to carry common arms generally. The Districts good-reason law is necessarily a total ban on exercises of that constitutional right for most D.C. residents. Thats enough to sink this law under Heller I.
One of the judges on the D.C. panel, Karen LeCraft Henderson, dissented, arguing that the core right in the Second Amendment is only to possess a firearm in ones home and she saw no problem with D.C.s good-reason requirement.
That dissent, along with the contrary decisions of other appeals courts, shows why the Supreme Court needs to follow Justice Thomass admonition and finally settle this issue. As Thomas scolds in his dissent in Peruta:
For those of us who work in marble halls, guarded constantly by a vigilant and dedicated police force, the guarantees of the Second Amendment might seem antiquated and superfluous. But the Framers made a clear choice: They reserved to all Americans the right to bear arms for self-defense. I do not think we should stand by idly while a State denies its citizens that right, particularly when their very lives may depend on it.
Hans A. von Spakovsky is a Senior Legal Fellow at The Heritage Foundation and former Justice Department official. He is coauthor of Whos Counting? How Fraudsters and Bureaucrats Put Your Vote at Risk.
See the original post here:
The Second Amendment has won (again) in Washington. So why won't the Supreme Court fully enforce it? - Fox News
- The Second Amendment and Gun Control - ThoughtCo - December 12th, 2019
- PRO: Second Amendment sanctuaries reflect the will of people who value the Constitution - Chicago Tribune - December 12th, 2019
- Second Amendment - NBC Bay Area - December 12th, 2019
- Virginia counties move to become 'Second Amendment sanctuaries' - CNN - December 12th, 2019
- Speakers call on city to become 2nd Amendment sanctuary - The Winchester Star - December 12th, 2019
- 'Good news' doesn't need guns to survive, thrive - The News Leader - December 12th, 2019
- Virginia AG responds to 2nd Amendment sanctuary resolutions: Gun safety laws will be followed - WTKR News 3 - December 12th, 2019
- Dozens of Virginia counties declare themselves 'Second Amendment sanctuaries' after Democrats win state legislature | TheHill - The Hill - December 12th, 2019
- Prince William to vote on '2nd Amendment sanctuary' measure, Fauquier takes a different tack - Prince William Times - December 12th, 2019
- Martinsville City Council's busy night: Second Amendment 'sanctuary' and then a public hearing on reversion - Martinsville Bulletin - December 12th, 2019
- 8 in 10 Collier, Lee residents fighting to keep their guns under Floridas red flag law had no lawyer to defend them - Naples Daily News - December 12th, 2019
- Meghan McCain Touts Her 2nd Amendment Right While Handling Assault Rifle - Yahoo Entertainment - December 12th, 2019
- SCOTUS Is Hearing Its First Big Gun Case in 9 Years. Heres How It Might Play Out. - The Trace - November 27th, 2019
- The Supreme Court Shouldn't Disrupt the Judicial Consensus on the Second Amendment - brennancenter.org - November 27th, 2019
- Collin County Passes Resolution Supporting the Second Amendment - NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth - November 27th, 2019
- Hundreds of residents turn out to support 'Second Amendment Sanctuary' in Bedford County - Lynchburg News and Advance - November 27th, 2019
- Williams: The "Second Amendment Sanctuary" movement is a sham. But more local control is a good idea. - Richmond.com - November 27th, 2019
- Fannin County joins other Texas counties as Second Amendment sanctuary movement - KXII-TV - November 27th, 2019
- "Meet Me in the Middle" Podcast on the Second Amendment - Reason - November 27th, 2019
- Former Brady Campaign President Dan Gross, Stands with Second Amendment Supporters - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - November 27th, 2019
- 19 States Now Have Counties with Second Amendment Sanctuaries in Place - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - November 27th, 2019
- LETTERS: City driving habits are awful; impact of the Second Amendment - Colorado Springs Gazette - November 27th, 2019
- Readers sound off on ad hominem attacks, the Second Amendment, and Mutts (again) - New York Daily News - November 27th, 2019
- Augusta County Board of Supervisors schedules special meeting to discuss second amendment sanctuary - WHSV - November 27th, 2019
- Florence County becomes first Second Amendment Sanctuary County in Wisconsin - UpperMichigansSource.com - November 17th, 2019
- Self-proclaimed Second Amendment auditor bonds out of jail after judge refuses bond reduction - KFOR Oklahoma City - November 17th, 2019
- Florida county is first in the state to become a 'Second Amendment Sanctuary' - Yahoo News - November 17th, 2019
- Original intent and the Second Amendment - Post Register - November 17th, 2019
- Kaufman, Palo Pinto, and Stephens Counties Become Second Amendment Sanctuaries - The Texan - November 17th, 2019
- Readers sound off on New York Health Act, the Second Amendment and the Mets - New York Daily News - November 17th, 2019
- Speaking at the House of Amazon, Joe Biden gently raises companys role in middle-class job losses - Seattle Times - November 17th, 2019
- Opinion/Letter: 2nd Amendment was all about militia - The Daily Progress - October 27th, 2019
- Go Plinking. The Second Amendment Depends On It. - Shooting Illustrated - October 27th, 2019
- Former NC Justice Orr to speak on 2nd Amendment - BlueRidgeNow.com - October 27th, 2019
- Letter to the Editor | Second Amendment is under attack - Champaign/Urbana News-Gazette - October 27th, 2019
- Opinion: What the gun lobby gets wrong about the Second Amendment - Middletown Press - October 27th, 2019
- Chatting With The Speakers Of The 2nd Amendment Rally - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - October 27th, 2019
- Jefferson and Sevier Counties added to the list of Tennessee 'gun sanctuaries' - WBIR.com - October 27th, 2019
- Don't Judge Me: Why We Need the Second Amendment - The Beacon - October 27th, 2019
- RICAGV: Tiverton voters recall town councilors who championed 'second amendment sanctuary' resolution - Uprise RI - October 27th, 2019
- As election nears, candidates in Lynchburg-area delegate contests offer competing messages on gun reform - Lynchburg News and Advance - October 27th, 2019
- What's standing in the way of new gun restrictions in Texas? Here are the key players - Times Record News - October 27th, 2019
- UK Terror Serves as a Warning to United States: Protect The 2nd Amendment! - Newstalk1290 - October 27th, 2019
- Van Ens: Hit the Second Amendment's bull's-eye - Vail Daily News - October 20th, 2019
- Why Don't People and Vogue Celebrate the Second Amendment? - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - October 20th, 2019
- Gun advocates seek 'friend' to take over Fish and Game - The Union Leader - October 20th, 2019
- 2020 Dem candidate opposes mandatory gun buybacks not because of the 2nd Amendment, but because of police brutality - TheBlaze - October 20th, 2019
- Sturbridge gun rights advocate is Blogger of the Year - Worcester Telegram - October 20th, 2019
- The art of the boast: Trump's a master - Star Tribune - October 20th, 2019
- Marianne Preger-Simon: Why is half of the Second Amendment ignored? - GazetteNET - October 16th, 2019
- Opinion: What the gun lobby gets wrong about the 2nd Amendment - Los Angeles Times - October 16th, 2019
- CEO talks second amendment freedom - The Branding Iron - October 16th, 2019
- Weiser: Sheriffs Will Enforce Red Flag Orders When Faced With Reality Of Dangerous People - Colorado Public Radio - October 16th, 2019
- Sheriff Leads Charge for Hood County to Become Fifth 'Second Amendment Sanctuary' in Texas - The Texan - October 16th, 2019
- Attend the 2nd Amendment Rally: November 2, 2019 - NOQ Report - October 16th, 2019
- Grassroots Spotlight: NRA-ILA Fighting the Bloomberg Money In Virginia 2019 Elections - NRA ILA - October 16th, 2019
- Supreme Court gun case: the biggest Second Amendment case in years - Vox.com - September 29th, 2019
- Opinion/Letter: 'Militia' key to 2nd Amendment - The Daily Progress - September 29th, 2019
- '2nd Amendment Rally' Planned Nov. 2 in Washington, DC - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - September 29th, 2019
- Gregory L. Schmidt: The true meaning and purpose of the Second Amendment - Madison.com - September 29th, 2019
- The second amendment was about national security - Herald Review - September 29th, 2019
- 'Federalist Papers' explain the Second Amendment | News, Sports, Jobs - Maui News - September 29th, 2019
- What's At Stake In The Guns Case At The Supreme Court? - KCUR - September 29th, 2019
- Q&A of the Day Supreme Court's ruling regarding the 2nd Amendment - On Air With Ryan Seacrest - September 29th, 2019
- Letter to the Editor: Rebuttal to letter about the Second Amendment - Northern Virginia Daily - September 29th, 2019
- Join Us for the 2019 NRA-ILA Firearms Law & The Second Amendment Symposium Next Saturday October 5th - NRA ILA - September 29th, 2019
- Breyer: Second Amendment Not About 'the Right of an Individual to Keep a Gun Next to His Bed' - PJ Media - August 25th, 2017
- D.C. attorney general wants federal judges to look at city's strict gun ... - Washington Post - August 25th, 2017
- 'The Gun Guy': Radio host Guy Relford defends 2nd amendment from Carmel office - Current in Carmel - August 22nd, 2017
- After Charlottesville, the First and Second Amendments Are Under Fire - National Review - August 20th, 2017
- ACLU Refuses to Defend Protesters Exercising First and Second Amendments Together - Breitbart News - August 20th, 2017
- Second Amendment | Wyoming County Free Press - Wyoming County Free Press - August 18th, 2017
- Ban the Open Carry of Firearms - New York Times - August 18th, 2017
- Armed private militias like Charlottesville's offend the Founding Fathers' intent: This is not what the Second ... - New York Daily News - August 16th, 2017
- Collins says his bill would restore New Yorkers' Second Amendment rights - Wyoming County Free Press - August 16th, 2017
- The Guns Won - Slate Magazine - August 15th, 2017
- State faces lawsuit over guns in foster homes - WSYM-TV - August 15th, 2017
- Commentary: The dangerous new threat to gun ownership: 'Gun Violence Taxes' - Elko Daily Free Press - August 15th, 2017
- Second Amendment Author and Attorney Documents Lethal Government Actions - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - August 13th, 2017
- Collins: My bill would restore New Yorkers' 2nd Amendment rights - Lockport Union-Sun & Journal - August 13th, 2017