Dont these orders go beyond the Commerce Clause, infringe the Privileges or Immunities Clause, or violate one of the other constitutional provisions Im constantly banging on about? Surely Icant approve such extreme impositions on economic liberty, the right to travel, and just the basic freedom to go about your daily life as you choose so long as you dont get in the way of others freedom to do the same?
Well, thats the rub. As Iexplained during Catos online forum on Coronavirus and the Constitution, in apandemic when we dont know whos infected and infections are often asymptomatic, these sorts of restrictions end up maximizing freedom. The traditional libertarian principle that one has aright to swing ones fists, but that right ends at the tip of someone elses nose, means government can restrict our movements and activities, because were all fistswingers now.
This isnt like seatbelt mandates or soda restrictions, where the government regulates your behavior for our own good, becausesetting aside the issue of publicly borne health care coststhe only person you hurt by not wearing aseatbelt or drinking too much sugar is yourself. With communicable diseases, you violate others rights just by being around them.
The federal government is one of enumerated and thus limited powersat least in theory, if observed largely in the breach since the New Dealbut states have police powers to govern for the public health, safety, welfare, and morals (the last one having fallen away in recent decades). Accordingly, in light of the best epidemiological data we have, state and local executives ordered shut downs to prevent people from being around too many other people and thus spreading the disease.
Interestingly, despite the infamous pictures of springbreakers and St. Patricks Day revelers, these government actions were lagging indicators. Restaurant traffic and airline travel fell off acliff before any official action. Airports are still open, even though the president has total authority to shut them down, as George W. Bush did on 9/11.
People began socialdistancing and wearing masks without any edicts. Sports leagues canceled their seasons without so much as a dont play ball from state umpires.
Not being satisfied with this largescale recognition of the threat we face and compliance with commonsense rules for the new normal, however, governors and mayors have begun to overreach. Although Ihad been telling reporters that nobody was going to get arrested for reading in the park or enjoying wildlife with her family, police were indeed telling people to move along if they were in apublic space, even if they were nowhere near anybody else.
When we got questions at that Cato forum about restrictions on the sale of nonessential products or prohibitions on fishinga right going back to Magna Carta!I thought these were farfetched hypotheticals, but it turns out they were all too real.
Then came the bans on parking at achurch and staying in your car to hear asermon, ahead of Easter Sunday, no less, which led toone of the best district court opinionsIve read in along time, reversing such an order in Louisville. (Full disclosure: Judge Justin Walker is afriend, and Im advising the Mississippi Justice Institute on one of these cases in Greenville, Miss.)
Look, this isnt about religious liberty, or any other constitutional right in particular. Assuming that socialdistancing is required to flatten the curve and fight COVID-19, such rules are fine so long as theyre applied equally everywhere, whether to yoga studios or churches, hackathons or street protests.
But theyre not fine when theyre arbitrarily targeted at some businesses and not others, as if coronavirus spreads more in gun shops than liquor stores. Theyre also not fine when they have nothing to do with socialdistancing, as with the fatwas against drivein liturgy or closing only aisles three and five of abigbox store. Or when tennis courts are closed even if the players wear allwhite masks and promise not to both go to the net at the same time. Or that video of the cop chasing that poor guy going for arun on the beach by his lonesome.
These ridiculous examples of petty tyranny led to mymost viral tweet ever: Angered by citations for being in park with nuclear family, or in car at church, or running on the beach. Or nonessential goods roped off in stores. These things have nothing to do with fighting the virus and everything to do with powerhungry politicians and law enforcement.
Just because significant restrictions on our daytoday lives are warranted doesnt mean its afreeforall for government coercion. To borrow alegal standard from adifferent context, the rules have to be congruent and proportional to the harm being addressed. As amatter of law, judges will give executives awide berth to deal with acrisis, but their enforcement measures still have to pass the constitutional smell test.
More fundamentally, any regulations that dont make common sense, that arent seen as reasonable by most people, are simply not going to be taken as legitimate, and they wont be followed. The American people will decide what restrictions are reasonable, and for how long. Just like they decided when to shut down, they have total authority to decide when to reopen.
- Salter: The principles of '76: libertarianism and the Declaration of Independence - LubbockOnline.com - July 25th, 2021
- Living with Covid and extreme individualism - The Guardian - July 25th, 2021
- Bye-bye, bitcoin: It's time to ban cryptocurrencies | TheHill - The Hill - July 25th, 2021
- Man charged in Capitol riot investigation said Trump asked me to be here, documents show - KRON4 - July 25th, 2021
- Nancy Mace Called Herself a New Voice for the G.O.P. Then She Pivoted. - The New York Times - July 25th, 2021
- Major conservative group spotlights Sanders health care heist in new ad blitz - Fox News - July 25th, 2021
- Healthcare | Libertarian Party - July 23rd, 2021
- Faulconer Campaign in Dispute With State Over Title on Recall Ballot - NBC San Diego - July 23rd, 2021
- Social partitioning - The Nevada Independent - July 23rd, 2021
- Why a 19th-century Russian anarchist is relevant to the mask and vaccine debate - The Conversation US - July 23rd, 2021
- Viewpoint: If not the Municipal Auditorium, what could become the next City Hall? - Uptown Messenger - July 23rd, 2021
- Protest and Contest - Splice Today - July 23rd, 2021
- Here's Who's Running For CA Governor In The Upcoming Recall Election, So Far - LAist - July 18th, 2021
- Opinion: The parties to political irrelevance - Juneau Empire - July 18th, 2021
- The yoga and wellness worlds have a conspiracy problem - Vox.com - July 18th, 2021
- Conspiracy theories fuel French opposition to Covid-19 health pass - FRANCE 24 English - July 18th, 2021
- Conservative Radio Talk Show Host Larry Elder Officially In the Recall Race Against Newsom - Newsweek - July 14th, 2021
- LETTER: IRR not continuing the legacy of its founders - Business Day - July 14th, 2021
- Marginal Revolutionaries - by Jonah Goldberg - The Remnant - The Dispatch - July 14th, 2021
- Kentucky's Senators Have Long Differed On Afghanistan. Their Hunches Are Being Tested. - WUKY - July 14th, 2021
- After NYC, where will ranked-choice voting go next? - The Fulcrum - July 14th, 2021
- The stability of stablecoins is just another financial illusion - Mint - July 14th, 2021
- Schmidt; The real identity of liberty, and the Libertarian Party - Seguin Gazette-Enterprise - July 7th, 2021
- Libertarians of Mississippi to host rally on navigating politics - DeSoto Times-Tribune - July 7th, 2021
- One man's journey to the nexus of Libertarianism and Christianity - Shelbynews - July 7th, 2021
- Get ready for the Sept. 14 recall election - San Bernardino County Sun - July 7th, 2021
- Leo Morris column: Indiana - an independent state it its own way - The Herald Bulletin - July 7th, 2021
- Cryptocurrencies dream of escaping the global financial system is crumbling - The Guardian - July 7th, 2021
- Gov. DeSantis and the need for viewpoint diversity in higher education | Column - Tampa Bay Times - July 7th, 2021
- Letter: Writer doesn't know what the Tea Party was - INFORUM - July 7th, 2021
- With Capitalists Like These - Splice Today - July 7th, 2021
- Supreme Court to Hear Case on Government Aid to Religious Schools - The New York Times - July 2nd, 2021
- Rep. Kelly Sponsors Bill Seeking To End Non-Profits Funding Election Offices - ButlerRadio.com - Butler, PA - butlerradio.com - July 2nd, 2021
- Rep. Kelly, Members of the House Election Integrity Caucus Unveil Legislation to Keep Big Tech from Thumbing the Scales in US Elections - Mike Kelly - July 2nd, 2021
- How the Critical Race Theory Debate Misses the Mark - Reason - June 28th, 2021
- Stun and dismay follow Wyoming political espionage revelations - Oil City News - June 28th, 2021
- LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Based on relationship | Solve issues together - Arkansas Online - June 20th, 2021
- How the Houses Silicon Valley smackdown is dividing conservatives - POLITICO - June 20th, 2021
- Joe Biden's meeting with Putin, vaccine passports, nightclub shootings, and other top columns - USA TODAY - June 20th, 2021
- Louis Marinelli: Is Europe's interest in the 2014 Vrbetice Explosions driven by the Biden-Putin meeting? - PRNewswire - June 20th, 2021
- Anthony Bland affirms plan to run for governor - Arkansas Times - June 20th, 2021
- Why the Texas ACA Suit Was Always Destined to Fail (Even on a 6-3 Court) - Reason - June 20th, 2021
- Biden Likely to Patch Things Up With Putin at Summit - Libertarian Party - UrduPoint News - June 20th, 2021
- How the Right Is Dividing over the Nature of Power - National Review - June 15th, 2021
- Colorado legislation could mean up to $617 million in tax and fee increases, think tank says - The Grand Junction Daily Sentinel - June 15th, 2021
- Meet the Conservative Evangelicals Practicing 'Strategic Hibernation' in the American Northwest - ChristianityToday.com - June 15th, 2021
- Finance Colombia The Reason Foundation's Daniel Raisbeck On What Peru's Election Can Tell Us About Economic Liberty In Colombia & Latin America -... - June 15th, 2021
- You can't tell the Republicans from the Democrats in state Legislature - Gaston Gazette - June 11th, 2021
- Paul Krugman's 10-Year History of Being Wrong About Bitcoin - Reason - June 11th, 2021
- Rossi holds big lead in 59th Legislative District special election - TribDem.com - May 22nd, 2021
- A Top Rand Paul Donor Is Dropping Big Bucks to Elect Andrew Yang Mother Jones - Mother Jones - May 22nd, 2021
- Wingfield: Reagan's words on government programs still ring true - Savannah Morning News - May 22nd, 2021
- Georgia Lawmakers Grapple With Role Of Social Media Companies And Free Speech | 90.1 FM WABE - WABE 90.1 FM - May 22nd, 2021
- Will a Coalition of Hawks, Mormons, and Libertarian-Leaners Form a New Third Party? - Reason - May 18th, 2021
- Johnson the civil libertarian wants to have his voter ID card and eat it - MSN UK - May 18th, 2021
- Special interests flood the mayor's race as candidates race to the finish line - Politico - May 18th, 2021
- Matthew McConaughey is 'making calls' as he mulls a run for Texas governor - The Independent - May 18th, 2021
- 3 candidates vie to fill vacancy in 59th district special election - TribLIVE - May 14th, 2021
- Robb Luther to appear as Libertarian candidate on ballot for 59th District seat - latrobebulletinnews.com - May 14th, 2021
- Election roundup: Essaibi George gets the nod from Gross; Libertarians jump into council race - Universal Hub - May 14th, 2021
- The Rise of the Thielists - The New Yorker - May 14th, 2021
- Government accused of nutty nanny statism over junk food ad ban - Evening Standard - May 14th, 2021
- Hart: Biden and Carter are two peanuts in the same shell game - Chattanooga Times Free Press - May 14th, 2021
- LETTER: It's time to look for another party - Meadville Tribune - May 14th, 2021
- PURPLE IS THE NEW PARTY | What is a Republican today? - Ventura County Reporter - May 14th, 2021
- Top fiscal conservative group targeting Bidens infrastructure proposal with new campaign - Fox Business - May 14th, 2021
- Public records law that ignores reality will always fall short - The Nevada Independent - May 14th, 2021
- Covid, Liberty and Responsibility: Where's the Line? - Bloomberg - May 9th, 2021
- Judge: Arizona political parties don't have to be invited to extra election recounts - Your Valley - May 9th, 2021
- Why Trump is more likely to win in the GOP than to take his followers to a new third party - The Conversation US - May 9th, 2021
- Meet the Dream Team Suing the Biden Administration Over Your Right To Sell Your Kidney - Reason - May 9th, 2021
- The 'Post-Covid-19 World' Will Never Come. - Scoop.co.nz - May 9th, 2021
- The Red Flags in Biden's State of the Union Address - Reason - May 9th, 2021
- Letter to the editor: Thoughts on Charen, Biden, race relations, military - TribLIVE - May 1st, 2021
- Editorial: On women in office, we're still only getting there - Plattsburgh Press Republican - May 1st, 2021
- Top elections official admits fundraising error - The Herald - May 1st, 2021
- Bring civility back to politics -- and to life in general - darnews.com - May 1st, 2021
- McNeely: McConaughey for governor? | Opinion | news-journal.com - Longview News-Journal - April 29th, 2021
- Candidates seeking 48th Senatorial District seat put their differences on display - PennLive - April 23rd, 2021
- Pellerin: Don't flout COVID rules in the name of 'freedom' - London Free Press (Blogs) - April 21st, 2021