Seven years ago Elizabeth Kolbert wrote The Sixth Extinction. In her new book about climate, Under a White Sky, she finds a middle ground between optimism and apocalyptic bleakness.
Soon it would be too hot J G Ballard, The Drowned World (1962)
The real problem is the sun. It warms the earth which is nice, the basis of all life but over the past 200 years weve altered our planets atmosphere so that it captures too much warmth. And weve failed to reduce our carbon emissions, or even slow their rapid growth, and it seems obvious that well continue to fail, that the problem defies our economic and political systems. So the atmosphere will continue to capture more and more warmth with increasingly dire consequences.
The solution is obvious. Dim the sun.
Elizabeth Kolbert is the climate reporter for the New Yorker. She won the Pulitzer prize for her 2014 book The Sixth Extinction, a collection of essays describing the accelerating mass extinctions of the modern era, comparing them to previous large scale extinction events in our planets remote past, caused by super volcano eruptions and meteor strikes. The book helped popularise the term the anthropocene, an informal description for our current geological era, a period in which human activity is the most significant actor on the planets ecosystems.
Most climate writing takes an activist approach. It wants to influence politics and policy, and it does this by warning people what might happen if humanity doesnt change our ways in the next six months or 18 months, or three years or 12 years. Those warnings are usually apocalyptic. But the public has remained unpersuaded, and even elected politicians who described themselves as progressive on climate delivered very little action, preferring to set emissions targets for dates decades in the future, which would then get pushed even further out by their replacements.
So The Sixth Extinction wasnt an activist book. It was journalism; calmly and objectively describing a global mass extinction event that was already well underway when it was published seven years ago. Under a White Sky is Kolberts equally detached attempt to imagine the future in a climate changed world; a future that is now inevitable. And she does this by reporting on the present.
In 2019 the journalist David Wallace-Wells published The Uninhabitable Earth, a book that peered beyond scientific reticence by outlining the most dire imaginable consequences of climate change: a planet that is incapable of sustaining human life, a state that Wallace-Wells predicted wed arrive at very soon. No matter how frightened you are of climate change, he warned, you are not nearly frightened enough. Then, in late 2020 the science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson published The Ministry for the Future describing the next stages of the climate apocalypse millions dying in heat waves, vast coastal cities flooded. But he then imagined the progressive/activist response, which leads to the transformation of the global economy into a Piketty-esque zero carbon egalitarian post-nation state techno-utopia.
Robinsons book is dedicated to Frederic Jameson, the literary theorist who claimed it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. Robinson imagines both, ending on a vision of wild optimism. (Along the way he wonders why the worlds central banks dont do carbon quantitative easing, printing money to pay people to sequester carbon instead of using QE to inflate their share markets and metropolitan house prices which is what most western governments are currently doing, including ours. Which might be the most important question in the world right now.) His solutions are partly political, partly economic, mostly technological; the heroes use distributed ledgers to invent new carbon currencies and drone swarms to assassinate the heads of energy companies.
For some climate activists Naomi Klein is the most prominent opting out of the carbon economy is easy. The problem is ideological, and we solve it by waking up and accepting that economic theory is wrong and economic growth is bad. Climate change is useful, in Kleins view: its the catalyst for realising that our real problem is capitalism. The radical transformation of our economy that the climate crisis forces upon us is the path to a better world.
Kleins logic found its way into the degrowth movement of the mid to late 2010s, championed by the Swedish activist Greta Thunberg, in which the consequences of climate change are prevented by halting and then reversing economic growth. But its hard to imagine a political climate in which citizens of developed nations willingly dismantle most of their energy infrastructure to reach emissions parity with the developing world. And its even harder to imagine states like China, India, Brazil or Nigeria scaling back their economic development to meet a global carbon budget that was almost entirely blown out by western nations over the previous hundred years.
For the novelist and former environmental activist Paul Kingsnorth whom Kolbert quotes in Under a White Sky, and who became a harsh critic of the environmental movement for its obsession with carbon accounting and tendency to see the natural world as an engineering challenge and not a sacred entity both technology and degrowth are illusions. There is no way out. Climate change is not ideological but systemic. Humanity has created a trap it cannot escape, a machine that sustains eight billion lives, more every day, who all will fight to keep it running. But its a machine with no pause, and no off switch. Economists merely describe this machine, which will continue to consume the planet and everything on it until the collapse of the ecosystem causes the destruction of our civilisation. Kingsnorths advice: move to the country. Buy a compost toilet. Learn to use a scythe.
Under a White Sky suggests a middle ground between the utopian optimism of writers like Robinson and Klein, and the apocalyptic bleakness of Wallace-Wells and Kingsnorth. Although theres a way in which her conception of the future is more depressing. There is, after all, something romantic about Kingsnorths vision: the terrifying chaos of modernity comes crashing down and the wise survivors live contemplative pastoral lives in the ruins. But what if modernity all the capitalism, globalisation, technological transformation doesnt stop? What if it keeps going? What if the apocalypse never comes? Or, what if it comes but nothing really changes? Kolbert sketches out what Ive come to think of as the boring apocalypse.
She starts with a river. Back in the 1960s Rachel Carson published Silent Spring, a foundational text for the modern environmental movement. It described the devastating impacts of synthetic chemicals on the natural environment. As an alternative to industrial chemicals, Carson suggested, we should be using natural solutions. Instead of spraying a waterway with toxic chemicals to wipe out insects, turning them into rivers of death, we could merely introduce a new species that would consume the insects. It was in this spirit that several species of Asian carp were introduced to lakes in the American south, to control the aquatic plants, algae and molluscs causing problems in the waterways.
The carp were aquafarmed in China for centuries, but when transported to US waterways they found themselves in a new environment with abundant food and no natural predators. They spread rapidly, either eating or outcompeting almost every other aquatic species they encountered. Which was bad for the rivers and lakes of the US south and midwest, but would be disastrous if they reached the great lakes ecosystem of the Atlantic northeast.
For millions of years the Great Lakes basin was separated off from the waterways of the rest of North America, but in the late 19th/early 20th century these systems were linked by the US Army Corps of Engineers, who were charged with redirecting the Chicago River. At the time the river carried Chicagos sewage directly into Lake Michigan, which caused routine outbreaks of cholera and typhoid. The Corps dug a gigantic canal and used it to reverse the rivers flow, carrying the effluent south into the Mississippi river delta. One hundred years later, it became the entry point for the endemic carp, moving upstream, to access the great lakes.
The same Engineer Corps that created the canal were given the job of preventing this, but they couldnt dam or block the waterway because it was still a vital part of Chicagos infrastructure. They looked at a variety of solutions: dosing the canal with poison, irradiating it with UV light, zapping it with ozone, superheating it, turning it anoxic by flooding it with nitrogen. In the end they decided the simplest solution was electricity. Kolbert, inspecting the canal on a pleasure craft called City Living, captures the surreal creepiness of floating down a deliberately electrified river: the dire warning signs, the flights of birds gathering to consume any fish that have been stunned or killed. If a human fell into the river, an engineer informed her, theyd probably die.
Its easy to say that its crazy to electrify an entire river, or that invasive new species shouldnt have been introduced to the US ecosystem, or that the Chicago River shouldnt have been reversed. But Kolberts book is about path dependency. All of those things happened. Theyre locked in and cant be rolled back. Rachel Carsons alternate title for Silent Spring was The Control of Nature, an idea Carson was firmly against. It was grounded in arrogance, she argued, in a worldview in which nature existed for the convenience of man. But what if relinquishing control is no longer an option? What if the attempt to control is already there, and all you have left is trying to control the control, in an endless layering of improvisations and feedback loops?
What will happen to the worlds coastal megacities when the sea levels rise and they begin to flood? Climate stories are often illustrated with drawings of drowned cities; the streets transformed into lagoons beneath the skeletons of abandoned skyscrapers. Kolbert suggests they might look like New Orleans, already a flood-prone city, already below sea level and sinking a little lower every year.
Some of the hydrologists and geologists Kolbert interviews no longer refer to the Mississippi River delta around New Orleans as a landscape, or a natural environment. Instead it is a CHANS: a Coupled Human and Natural System. The scale of the engineering works the levees, floodgates, canals and pumping stations needed to keep the city dry are so vast, so denaturing, the results require a new acronym, a new framework for thinking about humanitys relationship with nature. The section of the Mississippi running through the CHANS is so regulated it can no longer be thought of as a river, in any meaningful way. And, of course, these attempts to control nature have unintended consequences, requiring further interventions.
Some of this is simple. Relatively. Because most of New Orleans is below sea level, any rain falling on it needs to either evaporate or be pumped away by the massive network of pumping stations and canals distributed across the city. But marshy soils compact through dewatering so the city itself is sinking even deeper as a result of all the pumping. Which increases the danger, both from flooding and storm surges, which requires more levees and more pumping. The city is trapped in a loop, each iteration of which escalates both the problem and the solution required.
But the real headache is the river. The Mississippi is regulated to prevent it from drowning the city but its annual flooding once deposited millions of tons of sediment across the delta, and in its absence the land around New Orleans is eroding. It is, Kolbert informs us, one of the fastest-disappearing places on Earth, with the government officially retiring the names of its bays and bayous because theyve been consumed by the Gulf of Mexico. Kolbert flies over the area, observing the roads and fields still visible beneath the slowly rising waters.
Of course there is a plan to fix this, with the Engineer Corps and other agencies dreaming up grand plans to sledge vast amounts of sediment and divert it to the coastline. More control. The coastal cities of the future might not drown but theyll be radically transformed, with pharaonic flood control infrastructure rising to join the skyscrapers and motorways. It will fail, sometimes, as New Orleans does. Residents will get used to storms that scatter fishing boats across the roads and hang dead cows in the branches of trees. And the regions of the landscape that cant be saved because they have no economic value and their residents have no political capital will gradually disappear.
30 August, 2005; New Orleans in the aftermath of Katrina (Photo: Michael Appleton for the New York Daily News Archive, via Getty Images)
The best way to dim the sun to turn down the heat it casts onto our planet is by scattering vast amounts of small reflective particles into the stratosphere. Tiny (manufactured) diamonds are a strong candidate: theyre non-reactive and wont absorb any energy at all; the light scatters harmlessly back into space. But once you spray them into the atmosphere theyll eventually fall back to earth, and no ones quite sure what would happen to any or all of the planets lifeforms when we start inhaling or otherwise metabolising diamond dust.
The scientists Kolbert talks to at the Harvard Solar Geoengineering Research Program like calcium carbonate. Its natural: the main component of eggshells, snail shells, pearls. The air is already full of it; the ecosystem is saturated with it. And it has the right optical properties. Build enough specialised planes, dump enough of it in the atmosphere and itll reduce the energy of the incoming sunlight enough to offset the increased warmth from the greenhouse effect.
This was, Kolbert explains, almost the first technological solution proposed to the problem of climate change. Way back in the 1960s, when American and Soviet scientists first diagnosed the consequences of increased atmospheric carbon, they grimly predicted that nation states were highly unlikely to reduce their emissions, so youd have to counteract the warming some other way, and this seemed like the best answer.
Is it, though? Climate systems are famously hard to model so no one knows what will happen when you dump hundreds of thousands of tons of reflective particles into the atmosphere. The main concern is that itll disrupt rainfall patterns causing droughts in Africa and Asia. It will probably make solar panels less effective so it might increase the demand for fossil fuels. It will probably turn the sky white: that empty, bleached-out colour you already see in skies over megacities like Cairo or Delhi on a hot clear day.
But the biggest problem with solar geoengineering is that unless your atmospheric CO2 drops you have to keep doing it. It doesnt solve the climate crisis; it just addresses one of its symptoms. Imagine the heater in your house is broken: it keeps getting hotter and hotter. You can use an air conditioning unit to cool the rooms down but you havent fixed the heater. So you need to keep turning the air con up, and up, and up, just to maintain a stable temperature.
All those particles diamonds, or calcium carbonate, or whatever gradually fall to earth, but if CO2 levels continue to rise you need more particle dispersal; more flights. And if those flights are powered by fossil fuels you need even more flights to offset the emissions from those flights. And if you stop doing it, for whatever reason, the compounded heat hits very quickly a scenario that climate modellers refer to as a termination shock. So solar engineering is another trap; another loop. Another path dependent attempt to control a system thats too complex to adequately predict or control.
The Spinoff could not exist without the support of its members. Click here to make your contribution.
The Harvard physicists understand all of these problems. In most cases theyre the ones who figured them out. Their argument is that weve already blown past the CO2 level that would see a 1.5C increase in global temperature. Were already locked into a trajectory that will see catastrophic climate change. And emissions arent going down. Itll take decades for the planet to transition to renewable energy economies, even if every country in the world starts now, which most of them wont.
Many of the IPCC pathways that see emissions reduce over the 21st century rely on widespread adoption of an industrial process called BECCS: Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage. In the simplest implementation: you grow a forest, chop it down, burn the wood for energy and separate out the CO2 as its emitted. Then you store this captured carbon by injecting it deep underground, where it soaks into rocks deep in the planets crust. Climate modellers and economists love BECCS because it lets us have things both ways. We generate the energy that powers most economic growth and remove carbon from the atmosphere at the same time.
As of 2019 there were five BECCS facilities around the world, sequestering roughly 0.0004% of the worlds annual carbon emissions (my calculation; not Kolberts). So it needs to scale up by many orders of magnitude, at the same time that were transitioning the worlds 1.5 billion combustion engine vehicle fleet to electric and all the coal plants to solar and nuclear and wind.
The argument for solar geoengineering is that it buys the world time to carry out the transition to carbon neutrality: the transition we should have been working on for the last 30 years. Critics of the idea wonder if humans even have the right to do this. Were already geoengineering, its advocates reply: Thats what climate change is. But right now were geoengineering in this completely unplanned, uncontrolled way. Is it really worse to do it in a planned way to try and correct that? Kolbert quotes Lampedusa: Everything must change for everything to remain the same.
Towards the end of the book Kolbert contrasts three very different environmentalists on the subject of godhood. The technophile Stewart Brand, who said of humanity, We are as gods and might as well get good at it, the biologist EO Wilson who responds, We are not as gods. We are not yet sentient or intelligent enough to be much of anything, and Kingsnorth who commented, We are as gods but we have failed to get good at it. We are Loki, killing the beautiful for fun. We are Saturn, devouring our children.
In one of his most famous essays Kingsnorth wrote:
When I was young, I thought that the world was divided into good and bad people, and that I was one of the good ones. Later, slightly older, I thought it was divided into informed and ignorant people, and that I was one of the informed ones. Older still, though still not nearly old enough, I thought it was divided into Bad Elites and Good Masses, and that since I had no money or power, I must belong to the second category.
Now I think that humans like ease, material comfort, entertainment, and conformity, and they do not like anyone who threatens to take these things away. I think that even the people who say these things should be taken away in order to prevent the collapse of life on Earth do not really mean it The collapse of the industrial economy is, in all likelihood, the only remaining way to prevent the mass destruction of life on Earth.
Some people love this strain of fatalistic nihilism; they relish the prospect of humanity being destroyed for its sins. But Ive met more people whove read Kingsnorth or The Uninhabitable Earth, or other climate doom literature and found themselves overwhelmed with despair. Theyve abandoned environmentalism because whats the point? or decided not to have children, because why bring new life into a world that is about to end?
Under a White Sky points towards a vision of the future that is far from utopian but there is still a future. And it is a future that looks a lot more like the IPCCs higher probability intermediate pathways than the rapid extinction scenarios which have captured so many imaginations, but which weve been steadily moving away from over the last 10 years. Its a future where problems have been caused by people who arent bad, or ignorant or addicted to material ease; theyre smart and well intentioned but working with systems that were too complex for them to predict the consequences of their actions, which are now irreversible. And those problems are partly solved by that same class of people, who are creating further problems downstream. Its a future in which some things are better while others are horrible (the rivers are electrified, the skies are white, Elon Musk is the worlds first carbon currency trillionaire) but both the terrible and miraculous have become banal to those who live in it. A future we still have agency to influence, for better or worse.
Under a White Sky: The Nature of the Future, by Elizabeth Kolbert (Bodley Head, $37) is available from Unity Books Auckland and Wellington.
Subscribe to Rec Room a weekly newsletter delivering The Spinoffs latest videos, podcasts and other recommendations straight to your inbox.
Go here to see the original:
- Plastic waste-to-energy tech is being unrolled in Hungary and Greece - Power Technology - May 11th, 2021
- Powerhouse's waste-to-hydrogen technology to roll out in Greece and Hungary - H2 View - May 11th, 2021
- China's Tianwen-1 mission getting set to try and land Zhurong rover on Mars - ABC News - May 11th, 2021
- Letter: 'Origins of wokeness/critical race theory (CRT)' - Brown County Democrat - May 11th, 2021
- Where is Everybody? Are Big Incentives the Only Way to Attract Good Workers Post-Covid? - CEOWORLD magazine - May 11th, 2021
- HBO Max & Utopia Pick Up Sundance Coming-Of-Age Horror Were All Going To The Worlds Fair - Deadline - May 9th, 2021
- Farewell the utopian city. To cope with climate change we must learn from how nature adapts - The Conversation AU - May 9th, 2021
- A critique: Where Marx (1818-1883) was right and why he was wrong on the demise of capitalism - National Herald - May 9th, 2021
- Autonomous Vehicles Aren't the FuturePublic Transportation Is - The New Republic - May 9th, 2021
- Coldplay Says There 'Won't Not Be' A New Album On The Way - UPROXX - May 9th, 2021
- League of Legends Arcane, Riots new animated show, coming to Netflix - Polygon - May 9th, 2021
- Miranda Lamberts The Marfa Tapes tops this weeks new releases - cleveland.com - May 9th, 2021
- Frieze New York is kicking off: heres what not to miss - Wallpaper* - May 9th, 2021
- Masks on, or hands off the library - Bonner County Daily Bee - May 9th, 2021
- Bath Mats Market to Enjoy 'Explosive Growth' by 2025 The Shotcaller - The Shotcaller - May 9th, 2021
- Broadway re-opening dates: Here's the latest updates on shows' returns - Asbury Park Press - May 9th, 2021
- COLUMN: Politics and markets - St. Albert Today - May 9th, 2021
- Down to earth: how escaping to the country isnt always what it seems - The Guardian - May 9th, 2021
- The pro-life movement has much to celebrate this Mother's Day - Washington Examiner - May 9th, 2021
- Malaysia in dystopia while seeking the Utopian dream - Free Malaysia Today - May 9th, 2021
- Van Herk: Is defiance of authority embedded in the DNA of Albertans? - Calgary Herald - May 9th, 2021
- Features | In Conversation | Modular Therapy: Daniel Miller And Steve Davis In Conversation - The Quietus - May 9th, 2021
- Silver coins unearthed in New England may be loot from one of the 'greatest crimes in history' - Livescience.com - April 25th, 2021
- Revolutionaries and their shadowy networks come alive in Tim Harpers new book - The Indian Express - April 25th, 2021
- A New Front in the Fight for Reproductive Rights - Global Press Journal - April 25th, 2021
- China invokes mythic god of war and fire for its Mars rover name - New York Post - April 25th, 2021
- Before the Oscars On Sunday Check Out This Top 10 List - KPBS - April 25th, 2021
- Where Every Coupling Depends on Lies, and Men Are Aliens - The New York Times - April 21st, 2021
- Sun Ra's Chicago: Afrofuturism And The City - Jazz Journal - April 21st, 2021
- Offspring's first new album in nine years, 5 Things to Know - The Oakland Press - April 21st, 2021
- Broadway Baby: Michael Kors on 50 Years of Opening Nights, Diva Crushes and a Dream Revival - WWD - April 21st, 2021
- '60 Songs That Explain the '90s': How Bjrk Became a Genre Unto Herself - The Ringer - April 21st, 2021
- TODAY in SUPES: Cautious Optimism on Local COVID Conditions, Plus the Latest Measure Z Awards and a Bracing Dose of Pension Funding Policy Talk - Lost... - April 21st, 2021
- A New Try With UBI: As Wrongheaded As Before - Forbes - April 21st, 2021
- Brexit uncertainty and inconsistency means UK-EU food trade is still in limbo - The Grocer - April 21st, 2021
- 17.04.2129.05.21, Cape Town | Art of Everyday Things - ZAM - ZAM Magazine - April 21st, 2021
- Local events planned in honor of Earth Day - goskagit.com - April 21st, 2021
- Qurans verses need to be reviewed. But by Islamic scholars, not Supreme Court of India - ThePrint - April 21st, 2021
- San Franciscans still live in 1906 earthquake shacks. Here's why they matter more than ever - San Francisco Chronicle - April 21st, 2021
- From dystopia to utopia: How UK co-working spaces are redefining the new normal - UKTN (UK Technology News - April 15th, 2021
- Artist Danny Cole on Dreams of A Utopia of Creatures and Vandalism - Observer - April 15th, 2021
- New England has one of the most epic national park bike rides in America, according to Bicycling magazine - Boston.com - April 15th, 2021
- Offspring guitarist Noodles explains why the bands new album took 9 years to finish - San Bernardino County Sun - April 15th, 2021
- Gagarin's March: 60th Anniversary of the First Human in Space - National Air and Space Museum - April 15th, 2021
- Roxy Ball Room Merrion Street set to reveal supersize gaming utopia | TheBusinessDesk.com - The Business Desk - April 15th, 2021
- Yugoslav architect Svetlana Kana Radevi is saluted at the Venice Architecture Biennale - The Architect's Newspaper - April 15th, 2021
- As a Cultural War Continues to Cause Waves in France, Art Has Become a Lighthouse for Progressive Views - artnet News - April 15th, 2021
- The Sonic Extremes of the MaerzMusik Festival - The New Yorker - April 15th, 2021
- Top 10 Female Life Coaches That Will Impact Your Life in 2021 - GlobeNewswire - April 15th, 2021
- When the newest big name addition to Nuneaton's Ropewalk Shopping Centre will open - Coventry Live - April 15th, 2021
- How to get on board Nottingham's Grub Run - fitness with a tasty reward - Nottinghamshire Live - April 15th, 2021
- Letters to the editor April 15 - Daily Inter Lake - April 15th, 2021
- Belfast is ready to bounce back | Insight - Property Week - April 15th, 2021
- Is the Music Over at Mills College? - The New York Times - March 31st, 2021
- NFTs are leading to a new financial dystopia. Here's why you should care. - America Magazine - March 31st, 2021
- The Victorian Utopia Hidden In The Middle Of Tennessee - TravelAwaits - March 31st, 2021
- Why I am a communist: Activist Kobad Ghandy on ideology and Utopia - Scroll.in - March 31st, 2021
- 'Diana: The Musical' Will Premiere on Netflix This October - Decider - March 31st, 2021
- Shut out: Why the United Nations is no utopia - Stuff.co.nz - March 31st, 2021
- Greater Manchester town dubbed 'utopia' and named one of the best places to live in the country - Manchester Evening News - March 31st, 2021
- How things will have changed a century from now - www.ekathimerini.com - March 31st, 2021
- Jury out on link between new NRL rules and spate of injuries - The Guardian - March 31st, 2021
- Director Wayne Che Yip joins Amazon's The Lord of the Rings series - Televisual - March 31st, 2021
- Big Hits new ventures might just reshape the music industry worldwide and for the better - NME.com - March 31st, 2021
- Ryuho Okawa, World Teacher and Happy Science CEO, Publishes The True Eightfold Path: Guideposts for Self-Innovation - PR Web - March 31st, 2021
- 2nd international conference on Utopian and Sacred Architecture Studies - Winnipeg Free Press - March 31st, 2021
- Montreal filmmaker Peter Wintonick is the subject of a very personal new film - Cult MTL - March 26th, 2021
- Speaking of Religion | Nancy Thompson: The Journey Out of Slavery - Bennington Banner - March 26th, 2021
- The Long March Through the Corporations - Heritage.org - March 26th, 2021
- Graz Museum imagines the city in the future through a new exhibition - TheMayor.EU - March 26th, 2021
- Theater Review: Polis/Reset at the Volksbhne in Berlin - The New York Times - March 26th, 2021
- Green spaces aren't just for nature they boost our mental health too - New Scientist - March 26th, 2021
- 'Invincible' Is Packed With Pulpy, Visceral Thrills And Lots Of Pulpy Viscera - Capital Public Radio News - March 26th, 2021
- Talentopia Announces Merger of Impactian and Aims to Recruit Top Remote Technology and Legal Writers - Law.com - March 26th, 2021
- Two Cheshire towns named among the best places to live in the North West - The Chester Standard - March 26th, 2021
- Kaitlyn Greenidge: Song of Solomon is "WAP" of the Bible' - Los Angeles Times - March 25th, 2021
- Diplomacy at the dinner table The Harvard-Westlake Chronicle - The Harvard-Westlake Chronicle - March 25th, 2021
- Looking back at the lockdown - The New Indian Express - March 25th, 2021
- UVA and the History of Race: The Era of Massive Resistance - University of Virginia - March 25th, 2021
- The 'woke' 63rd Grammys in review The Miscellany News - Miscellany News - March 25th, 2021