Identical twins have nothing on black holes. Twins may grow from the same genetic blueprints, but they can differ in a thousand ways from temperament to hairstyle. Black holes, according to Albert Einsteins theory of gravity, can have just three characteristics mass, spin and charge. If those values are the same for any two black holes, it is impossible to discern one twin from the other. Black holes, they say, have no hair.
In classical general relativity, they would be exactly identical, said Paul Chesler, a theoretical physicist at Harvard University. You cant tell the difference.
Yet scientists have begun to wonder if the no-hair theorem is strictly true. In 2012, a mathematician named Stefanos Aretakis then at the University of Cambridge and now at the University of Toronto suggested that some black holes might have instabilities on their event horizons. These instabilities would effectively give some regions of a black holes horizon a stronger gravitational pull than others. That would make otherwise identical black holes distinguishable.
However, his equations only showed that this was possible for so-called extremal black holes ones that have a maximum value possible for either their mass, spin or charge. And as far as we know, these black holes cannot exist, at least exactly, in nature, said Chesler.
But what if you had a near-extremal black hole, one that approached these extreme values but didnt quite reach them? Such a black hole should be able to exist, at least in theory. Could it have detectable violations of the no-hair theorem?
A paper published late last month shows that it could. Moreover, this hair could be detected by gravitational wave observatories.
Aretakis basically suggested there was some information that was left on the horizon, said Gaurav Khanna, a physicist at the University of Massachusetts and the University of Rhode Island and one of the co-authors. Our paper opens up the possibility of measuring this hair.
In particular, the scientists suggest that remnants either of the black holes formation or of later disturbances, such as matter falling into the black hole, could create gravitational instabilities on or near the event horizon of a near-extremal black hole. We would expect that the gravitational signal we would see would be quite different from ordinary black holes that are not extremal, said Khanna.
If black holes do have hair thus retaining some information about their past this could have implications for the famous black hole information paradox put forward by the late physicist Stephen Hawking, said Lia Medeiros, an astrophysicist at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey. That paradox distills the fundamental conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics, the two great pillars of 20th-century physics. If you violate one of the assumptions [of the information paradox], you might be able to solve the paradox itself, said Medeiros. One of the assumptions is the no-hair theorem.
The ramifications of that could be broad. If we can prove the actual space-time of the black hole outside of the black hole is different from what we expect, then I think that is going to have really huge implications for general relativity, said Medeiros, who co-authored a paper in October that addressed whether the observed geometry of black holes is consistent with predictions.
Perhaps the most exciting aspect of this latest paper, however, is that it could provide a way to merge observations of black holes with fundamental physics. Detecting hair on black holes perhaps the most extreme astrophysical laboratories in the universe could allow us to probe ideas such as string theory and quantum gravity in a way that has never been possible before.
One of the big issues [with] string theory and quantum gravity is that its really hard to test those predictions, said Medeiros. So if you have anything thats even remotely testable, thats amazing.
There are major hurdles, however. Its not certain that near-extremal black holes exist. (The best simulations at the moment typically produce black holes that are 30% away from being extremal, said Chesler.) And even if they do, its not clear if gravitational wave detectors would be sensitive enough to spot these instabilities from the hair.
Whats more, the hair is expected to be incredibly short-lived, lasting just fractions of a second.
But the paper itself, at least in principle, seems sound. I dont think that anybody in the community doubts it, said Chesler. Its not speculative. It just turns out Einsteins equations are so complicated that were discovering new properties of them on a yearly basis.
The next step would be to see what sort of signals we should be looking for in our gravitational detectors either LIGO and Virgo, operating today, or future instruments like the European Space Agencys space-based LISA instrument.
One should now build upon their work and really compute what would be the frequency of this gravitational radiation, and understand how we could measure and identify it, said Helvi Witek, an astrophysicist at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. The next step is to go from this very nice and important theoretical study to what would be the signature.
There are plenty of reasons to want to do so. While the chances of a detection that would prove the paper correct are slim, such a discovery would not only challenge Einsteins theory of general relativity but prove the existence of near-extremal black holes.
We would love to know if nature would even allow for such a beast to exist, said Khanna. It would have pretty dramatic implications for our field.
Correction: February 11, 2021The original version of this article implied that theorists are unable to simulate black holes closer than 30% away from being extremal. In fact, they can simulate near-extremal black holes, but their typical simulations are 30% away from being extremal.
- Helgoland by Carlo Rovelli - read an exclusive extract - RTE.ie - April 17th, 2021
- Researchers Visualize the Motion of Vortices in Quantum Superfluid Turbulence - SciTechDaily - April 17th, 2021
- Will we ever know exactly how the universe ballooned into existence? - Livescience.com - April 17th, 2021
- 'The Disordered Cosmos', A Contemplation of the Exclusionary Culture of Physics - The Wire Science - April 17th, 2021
- Albert Einstein Death Anniversary: How did the greatest physicists of all time die? - Free Press Journal - April 17th, 2021
- Half Life traces family complexities for a Milwaukee physics teacher - The Globe and Mail - April 17th, 2021
- Scott Aaronson Winner of 2020 ACM Prize In Computing - iProgrammer - April 17th, 2021
- Book Review: A Cosmologist Throws Light on a Universe of Bias - Undark Magazine - April 17th, 2021
- The God Equation by Michio Kaku review the quest to find the theory of everything . . . and save humanity - The Times - April 17th, 2021
- Realization of an ideal Weyl semimetal band in a quantum gas with 3D spin-orbit coupling - Science Magazine - April 17th, 2021
- Einsteins Fridge by Paul Sen the heart of the matter - Financial Times - April 17th, 2021
- Quantum computers are revealing an unexpected new theory of reality - New Scientist - April 15th, 2021
- Student's physics homework picked up by Amazon quantum researchers - News - The University of Sydney - April 15th, 2021
- The Big Theoretical Physics Problem At The Center Of The 'Muon g-2' Puzzle - Forbes - April 15th, 2021
- 615 Million Euros Awarded to Quantum Delta NL for Quantum Research in the Netherlands - HPCwire - April 15th, 2021
- The God Equation Review: One String Theory to Rule Them All - The Wall Street Journal - April 15th, 2021
- The Disordered Cosmos review: An insider take on physics and injustice - New Scientist News - April 15th, 2021
- Course explores 'Magic, Witchcraft and Healing' > News > USC Dornsife - USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences - April 15th, 2021
- How matters hidden complexity unleashed the power of nuclear physics - Science News Magazine - April 15th, 2021
- Scientists Perform First-ever Ultracold Atom Interferometry in Space, Leading to Possible Physics Breakthroughs - Science Times - April 15th, 2021
- The windswept German island that inspired quantum physics - Spectator.co.uk - April 6th, 2021
- Junior wins Goldwater scholarship | The Source | Washington University in St. Louis - Washington University Record - April 6th, 2021
- Raytheon Technologies Announces $500 Million Social Impact Initiative - PRNewswire - April 6th, 2021
- Raytheon Technologies to release first quarter results on April 27, 2021 - CapeNews.net - April 6th, 2021
- An Interstellar Trip with Einstein, Newton, and Tesla - EE Times India - April 6th, 2021
- Searching for New Physics in the Subatomic World - SciTechDaily - April 6th, 2021
- QCI Expands Sales and Marketing Team to Accelerate Growth and Advance Enterprise Adoption of Quantum Computing - GlobeNewswire - April 6th, 2021
- Quantum Physics to Disrupt Geospatial Industry over the Coming Decade - GIM International - April 4th, 2021
- Imaginarity: New Paper Says The Imaginary Part Of Quantum Mechanics Can Be Observed - Science 2.0 - April 4th, 2021
- The mystery of the muon's magnetism | symmetry magazine - Symmetry magazine - April 4th, 2021
- Your Guide to Products and Technologies That Are Pseudoscience - Interesting Engineering - April 4th, 2021
- 6 Quantum Computing Stocks to Invest in This Decade - Investment U - April 4th, 2021
- What if youre living in a simulation, but theres no computer? - The Next Web - April 4th, 2021
- Quantum physics: what to expect - Study International News - March 31st, 2021
- Helgoland by Carlo Rovelli review a meditation on quantum theory - The Guardian - March 31st, 2021
- 'Spacekime theory' could speed up research and heal the rift in physics - Big Think - March 31st, 2021
- Some Black Holes Are Impossible In Our Universe - Forbes - March 31st, 2021
- Scientists Have Simulated The Primordial Quantum Structure of Our Universe - ScienceAlert - March 31st, 2021
- Post-Doctoral Research Associate Experimental Condensed Matter Physics job with ROYAL HOLLOWAY, UNIVERSITY OF LONDON | 250229 - Times Higher Education... - March 31st, 2021
- No free will, no ideas: Physicist Brian Greene reduces everything to 'particles and fields' - National Catholic Reporter - March 31st, 2021
- Carlo Rovelli on his search for the theory of everything - Prospect - March 31st, 2021
- Do Alternate Realities Exist? This Artist's Machines Are Ready to Find Out - PCMag - March 31st, 2021
- After 50 Years, Physicists Confirm The Existence of an Elusive Quasiparticle - ScienceAlert - March 25th, 2021
- Helgoland by Carlo Rovelli review the mysteries of quantum mechanics - The Guardian - March 25th, 2021
- Quantum Week 2021 Unveils the Latest in Quantum Computing and Engineering - PRNewswire - March 25th, 2021
- QMAP Will Have Data Science and AI as Downstairs Neighbors - UC Davis - March 25th, 2021
- Has the black hole information paradox evaporated? - Symmetry magazine - March 25th, 2021
- Ultracold Quantum Collisions Have Been Achieved in Space for the First Time - Scientific American - March 25th, 2021
- Measuring the invisible - MIT News - March 25th, 2021
- Einsteins Fridge Review: Heated Arguments - The Wall Street Journal - March 25th, 2021
- I'm Agonizing over My Naive Realism - Scientific American - March 25th, 2021
- Crucial Milestone for Scalable Quantum Technology: 2D Array of Semiconductor Qubits That Functions as a Quantum Processor - SciTechDaily - March 25th, 2021
- Letter to the Editor: Too many satellites could obscure the stars - pressherald.com - March 16th, 2021
- Netflix scores 35 Oscar nominations in year dominated by streaming - ETTelecom.com - March 16th, 2021
- Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou to appear in Canada court for final phase of extradition hearings - ETTelecom.com - March 16th, 2021
- Quantum Mechanics, the Chinese Room Experiment and the Limits of Understanding - Scientific American - March 11th, 2021
- Welcome To The Future: Navigating The Rich, Intertwined Quantum Software Ecosystem - Forbes - March 11th, 2021
- Quantum Mischief Rewrites the Laws of Cause and Effect - Quanta Magazine - March 11th, 2021
- Physicists have measured gravity on the smallest scale ever - New Scientist News - March 11th, 2021
- Mindblowing Approach to Electromobility: Is nanoFlowcell Overtaking the Future? - autoevolution - March 7th, 2021
- Physicists Just Found 4 New Subatomic Particles That May Test The Laws of Nature - ScienceAlert - March 7th, 2021
- New History of the Physics Department by Raj Gupta and Paul Sharrah Published - University of Arkansas Newswire - March 3rd, 2021
- New research indicates the whole universe could be a giant neural network - The Next Web - March 3rd, 2021
- Roivant Grows Computational Drug Discovery Engine with Acquisition of Silicon Therapeutics - Business Wire - March 3rd, 2021
- Physics - The Tiniest Superfluid Circuit in Nature - Physics - February 27th, 2021
- Can god be disproved using the laws of physics? An expert explains how it depends on perspective - Scroll.in - February 27th, 2021
- How philosophy blends physics with the idea of free will - Big Think - February 27th, 2021
- Exclusive! Ashwin Sanghi on his dream to cast Sushant Singh Rajput in 'Keepers Of The Kalachakra' series: He was like an excited child when it came to... - February 27th, 2021
- SD Times Open-Source Project of the Week: PennyLane - SDTimes.com - February 27th, 2021
- Google Teams With D-Wave in Massive Quantum Computing Leap, Cracking Simulation Problem - The Daily Hodl - February 27th, 2021
- Tech Talk: Universe or multiverse? | Free - Ashland Daily Press - February 27th, 2021
- Physicists Show a Speed Limit Also Applies in the Quantum World - SciTechDaily - February 25th, 2021
- Can the laws of Physics help settle the debate over the existence of God? - Firstpost - February 25th, 2021
- OU appoints three to rank of Distinguished Professor - 2021 - Office of the Provost - News - OU Magazine - News at OU - February 25th, 2021
- Mid-Atlantic Quantum Alliance Expands Impact and Reach with Addition of 10 New Partners - PR Web - February 25th, 2021
- Everything you need to know about quantum physics (almost ... - February 22nd, 2021
- Quantum mechanics - Wikipedia - February 22nd, 2021
- Six Things Everyone Should Know About Quantum Physics - February 22nd, 2021
- A new Approach Could Tease out the Connection Between Gravity and Quantum Mechanics - Universe Today - February 22nd, 2021
- And So It Begins Quantum Physicists Create a New Universe With Its Own Rules - The Daily Galaxy --Great Discoveries Channel - February 22nd, 2021