Who would have thought that a virus would make us reflect deeply on what it means to be the church? Yet COVID-19 has brought into sharp relief the basic divide in North American Christianity between those who think of the church as a voluntary association of like-minded individuals and those who believe it is the real body of Christ, into which we are incorporated. The emphasis on the individual in large swaths of contemporary culture results in an anemic ecclesiology, as the recent crisis makes clear.
John Williamson Nevin, one of the key representatives of German Reformed Mercersburg theology, sharply attacked the revivalism of his day, commenting in his 1849 article on The Sect System: The sect mind . . . in proportion as it has come to be unchurchly and simply private and individual is always necessarily to the same extent unsacramental.
Abraham Kuyper, the great Dutch Reformed theologian and statesman, observed in his 1898 Lectures on Calvinism that Calvinism, by praising aloud liberty of conscience, has in principle abandoned every absolute characteristic of the visible Church. He described it as a liberty of conscience, which enables every man to serve God according to his own conviction and the dictates of his own heart.
Baptist theologian Curtis Freeman, in his 2014 book Contesting Catholicity, similarly laments soul competencythe radical emphasis on individual consciencewhich, beginning in the nineteenth century, has come to dominate Baptist theology.
Nevin, Kuyper, and Freeman all share the same concern about the inversion of the relationship between the church and the believer.
The Internet has been abuzz lately about virtual communion: Why not have the priest do his thing in front of the camera, while we partake by ourselves looking into the screenwith social distance serving as one of the few remaining ritual demands? Why forgo the heavenly manna now that we have the technological know-how to make it rain down virtually into the privacy of our homes?
The Jesuit patristic scholar Henri de Lubac has a few things to teach us about virtual communion in his 1947 book Catholicism. It is a lengthy broadside against individualism in the Catholic tradition. It may seem odd for a Catholicespecially a pre-Vatican II Catholicto worry about people prioritizing the individual over the church. But he did, and his worries are eerily relevant to the rush toward virtual communion among todays tech-savvy evangelicals.
De Lubac was troubled by a Eucharistic individualism that he believed had shaped the mindset of many of his Catholic contemporaries. Convinced as they were that the body of Christ in the Eucharist was the true body (corpus verum), all that seemed to matter was to partake. Once the miraculous medicine of immortality had been ingested, one might as well turn back down the aisle and walk out of church, for the one and only reason for going to Mass had now been performed. De Lubac was agitated, rightly I think, with the individualismyes, the selfish consumerism and greedin this Eucharistic spirituality.
The underlying premise of the embrace of virtual communion is that form and matter, media and message can (and perhaps ought to) be disentangled from each other. Our technological age makes its own, unique demands, and so, for many, to insist on eating the body (the Eucharist) as a body (the church) betrays unhealthy Luddite technophobia.
De Lubac countered the gnostic demon at work. He asked his readers to think about what it means to eat the body (the Eucharist) as a body (the church), pointing out the close link between embodiment and community. Turning to 1 Corinthians 10:1617 (The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread), de Lubac pointed out that for Saint Paul, participation (koinnia, communion) of the body of Christ (the Eucharist) turns us into the body of Christ (the church).
All this talk of the body of Christ is no mere metaphor. Saint Augustine, in his famous Sermon 227, writes about the Eucharist: If you have received worthily, you are what you have received, for the Apostle says: The bread is one; we though many, are one body. The African bishop seems to suggest that believers, by partaking of communion, are transubstantiated (well, changed) into the body of Christ. When we eat Christ, we become Christ.
The Christian tradition has typically treated body and body (Eucharist and church) as mutually dependent. On the one hand, the Eucharist makes the church. This seems to be the Pauline logic of 1 Corinthians 10 and of Augustine in Sermon 227. On the other hand, the church makes the Eucharist: We offer up our giftsour entire livesin Christ on the altar. Body and body depend on each other. Neither can go it alone. The reason is simple: The two are one flesh (Eph. 5:31).
Eating and drinking in front of the screen usually indicates a theology of real absence: Neither consecrated bread nor epicletic invocation of the Spirit is required if communion is a mere mental exercise. Indeed, a memorialist communion celebration is virtual by definition, even if it takes place in a church.
Which raises an interesting question: Could we do virtual consecration? True, the priest would not be able to put his hand on the bread and the wine on my coffee table at home, but hey, such pesky manual acts predate YouTube and Zoom by quite a few centuries, and surely by now theyve become obstacles that stand in our way? How central could the sense of touch really be?
Come to think of it, why did it take us so long to get with the times? Why limit YouTube to the COVID-19 pandemic? If consecration works regardless of place, why set physical foot in the church ever again? Heres a modest proposal: Lets have one clericwe could ask the archbishop of Canterbury or the bishop of Romedo his consecrating thing, while the rest of us chill in our TV rooms, giving thanks for the great sacrifice. Actually, is it even necessary to turn to the screen for Franciss latest clip? Surely, watching him elevate the host isnt of the essence of things, as long as I know that he has consecrated also the bread on my plate.
I agree. Its a gnostic argument ad absurdum. But the reason it works is that every stepincluding the very first oneis an exercise in spirituality that treats the Eucharist as a consumer service satisfying my individual religious demands rather than as the chief act of divine worship through which were transfigured so as to become the body of Christ that we eat.
The individualism of pre-Vatican II Catholics is different from that of contemporary evangelicals. The former stems from an over-reliance on real presence: As long as I myself have partaken of the true, Eucharistic body of Christ, I might as well discount the mystical body of the church. The latter is (most of the time) connected to a belief in real absence: If Christ is not bodily present, then our communal, bodily presence can hardly be of significance.
In truth, the bodily presence of Christ in the wafer and the bodily presence of the believers in church are two sides of the same coin. Eucharist via Zoom evacuates the (ecclesial) body even while confecting the (Eucharistic) body. Its a practice that puts asunder what God has joined together.
Catholic and evangelical expressions of consumerist individualism may be located on opposite sides of the theological spectrum, but both fail to recognize that body and body, Christ and the church, are one and the same. When it comes to prioritizing the individual over the church, the difference is, well, wafer-thin.
Hans Boersmais the Saint Benedict Servants of Christ Professor in Ascetical Theology at Nashotah House.
Read more here:
A Wafer-Thin Practice | Hans Boersma - First Things
- AgeX Therapeutics and Pluristyx Announce Manufacturing, Marketing, and Distribution Agreement to Expand Access to Clinical-Grade Human Pluripotent... - June 17th, 2020
- Avoid eating these artificial preservatives whenever possible - Yahoo Lifestyle - June 17th, 2020
- Young Blood and Old Blood | In the Pipeline - Science Magazine - June 13th, 2020
- BLM's anti-Semitism must be addressed - San Diego Jewish World - June 13th, 2020
- Writing History on the Banks of Spoon River - Patheos - June 13th, 2020
- These are the Winners of the 2020 Sony World Photography Awards - PetaPixel - June 13th, 2020
- Ramdesivir, hailed as cure for COVID-19: is history repeating itself? - National Herald - May 14th, 2020
- COVID-19: Ministry of Ayush starts clinical trials for Ashwagandha and 4 other Ayurvedic herbs for coronavirus treatment; Here is what you need to... - May 14th, 2020
- Promising technologies that will change cancer testing in India - Express Healthcare - April 21st, 2020
- The Medicine of Immortality | Eucharist :: Evangelization ... - April 11th, 2020
- William Wordsworth was the supreme bard of nature and solitude - The Economist - April 9th, 2020
- 5 Ways Scientists Hope to Achieve Immortality for Humanity - March 31st, 2020
- Medicine of Immortality | Dominicana - March 31st, 2020
- Scientists Claim We Might Be Immortal in 17 Years This ... - March 31st, 2020
- The Medicine of Immortality - Spectrum - March 31st, 2020
- St. Ignatius of Antioch and the Medicine of Immortality ... - March 31st, 2020
- India has played a vital role in the fight against coronavirus - WION - March 31st, 2020
- Celebrating International Women's Day in the industry - The Shout - March 12th, 2020
- The science of senolytics: breakthroughs in the future of ageing - Health Europa - January 27th, 2020
- Taking Sermon Notes Why Jesus Called a Man a Fool- Listening to and Learning from the Reverend Doctor King (4/7) - Patheos - January 27th, 2020
- Learn the longevity secrets of this Chinese city which houses over 1,200 centenarians - The Tribune - January 18th, 2020
- Adrienne Martini Reviews The History of Living Forever by Jake Wolff - Locus Online - December 13th, 2019
- Boy, 9, to move to U.S. university after conflict with TU Eindhoven, father says - NL Times - December 13th, 2019
- The Story Of The Quickening: Mercurial Metal - Hackaday - December 13th, 2019
- Breakthrough discovery in plants' DNA may lead to slowing aging process in humans - CNN - November 23rd, 2019
- Missing Link To Longevity Discovered In The Plant Kingdom - Texas A&M University - November 23rd, 2019
- Study Finds Over 55 Million Deaths Could Be Prevented Annually By Some Sort Of Immortality Serum - The Onion - October 12th, 2019
- Whats the mark of a real friend? - Aleteia EN - October 12th, 2019
- Raising the Dead: Ketch Secor Talks Old Crow Medicine Show's Live at The Ryman, Ken Burns' 'Country Music' and Playing with Bob Weir - jambands.com - October 7th, 2019
- FMA: The Top 10 Symbols and Logos, Explained | CBR - CBR - Comic Book Resources - October 7th, 2019
- Why Are Some Americans Paying $8000 For A Shot Of Teenage Blood? - IFLScience - August 25th, 2017
- Immortality Medicine Part 8456 | Prometheism.net - August 22nd, 2017
- Seeking A Glimpse Of Immortality In The Waters Of India's ... - August 22nd, 2017
- How to live forever - TechRadar - August 20th, 2017
- When thoughts often turn to death - The Economist - August 20th, 2017
- Two-step process leads to cell immortalization and cancer - Medical Xpress - August 18th, 2017
- Time Travel for Beginners - National Catholic Register (blog) - August 18th, 2017
- Surprising benefits of aloe vera - WOTV4women.com - August 18th, 2017
- Researchers discover potential cancer treatment breakthrough - Medical Xpress - August 13th, 2017
- Digital Immortality, The Future of Memory, and Sci-Fi Utopias: An Interview With Dr. Phil Frana - Outer Places - August 9th, 2017
- THE NEW CLASSICS | 'The Fountain' - artsBHAM - August 8th, 2017
- The Elixir of Immortality May Reside Deep Within Our Brains - ExtremeTech - August 3rd, 2017
- Scientists Make Old Cells Young Again Using Groundbreaking New Technique - IFLScience - August 1st, 2017
- Science says it might actually be possible to live forever - The Loop (blog) - August 1st, 2017
- Letters to the Editor - July 30 - Herald-Mail Media - July 30th, 2017
- Websites launched to help people live forever through social media - NEWS.com.au - July 21st, 2017
- Aspen Times Weekly: How Long Do You Want to Live? - Aspen Times - July 20th, 2017
- A Son's Race to Give His Dying Father Artificial Immortality - WIRED - July 19th, 2017
- WELLBEING: Seven reasons to fall in love with aloe vera this summer - NW Evening Mail - July 19th, 2017
- We Will Extend Our Lives but Not Attain Immortality, Says Anti-Aging Researcher - Futurism - July 18th, 2017
- 'Miracle plant' aloe vera is versatile and powerful | Irish Examiner - Irish Examiner - July 14th, 2017
- THe Secret To A Longer Life - Midweek - July 12th, 2017
- On The Eucharist: Part One - Patheos (blog) - July 10th, 2017
- This Study Could Help Extend the Human Lifespan - Futurism - July 8th, 2017
- Billionaires dream of immortality. The rest of us worry about healthcare - The Guardian - July 5th, 2017
- There's No Upper Limit to Human Lifespan, Argue Scientists - Inverse - July 4th, 2017
- Living to 125 and beyond: Scientists dispute there's a limit to our lifespans - kfor.com - July 3rd, 2017
- Living to 125 and beyond: Scientists dispute there's a limit to - KMOV.com - KMOV.com - July 2nd, 2017
- Forget the Blood of Teens. This Pill Promises to Extend Life for a Nickel a Pop. - WIRED - July 1st, 2017
- You Can Live Forever, No Maximum Age-Limit Found - Doctor NDTV - June 30th, 2017
- How doctors get sucked into inappropriate care - 6minutes - June 29th, 2017
- Why the super-rich are ploughing billions into the booming 'immortality industry' - Evening Standard - June 29th, 2017
- Exhibits examine 15th- and 16th-century ideas in Harry Potter ... - The Spokesman-Review - June 29th, 2017
- Nature and human nature intersect in a crowdsourced exhibition - New Scientist - June 29th, 2017
- Seven 'ideal' goals to maintain healthy heart - Gulf Times - Gulf Times - June 28th, 2017
- Hitting cardiovascular health targets can help elderly live longer - Reuters - June 28th, 2017
- Times of Malta The seven ideal cardiovascular health goals ... - Times of Malta - June 26th, 2017
- Black, Gwendolyn - The Daily Progress - June 25th, 2017
- Hitting cardiovascular health targets can help elderly live longer ... - KFGO - June 24th, 2017
- Trees, Science and the Goodness of Green Space - Truth-Out - June 24th, 2017
- Lazarus. A Fringe Peek - DC Theatre Scene - June 22nd, 2017
- Toward Immortality: The Social Burden of Longer Lives - June 19th, 2017
- 'Immortality mushroom' discovered in mountains of western Turkey's anakkale - Daily Sabah - June 19th, 2017
- Israeli Researchers Find Male-Only Longevity Gene MutationThe ... - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 19th, 2017
- The Ethical Dilemmas of Immortality - June 18th, 2017
- Study: Daily Dose of THC Can Reverse Aging of Brain - Green Rush Daily - June 16th, 2017
- John Robson: A radical future isn't just coming. It's arriving, now, and perhaps we should give some thought to it? - National Post - June 15th, 2017
- Inside Ambrosia: Could infusions of millennial blood make you ... - Mic - Mic - June 15th, 2017
- 6 Health Benefits and Uses for Sage - Care2.com - June 11th, 2017
- Lo, the full, final sacrifice - Church Times - June 9th, 2017