Most citizens in the United States take the First Amendment guaranteeing freedom of speech as a source of patriotic pride. We have been taught that all speech is protected. Bad speech is overcome with good speech. No matter how much harm speech inflicts, when the First Amendment is in question, the Supreme Court feels it is its duty to defend all speech.
Thane Rosenbaum, a lawyer, novelist and Distinguished University Professor at Touro College, disagrees. In his informative and highly readable book, Saving Free Speech from Itself (Fig Tree Books), he explains how many of our assumptions about freedom of speech and the law are either incorrect as a matter of history or rest on a thin scaffolding of flawed reasoning. At the same time he shows there are many instances where America is shutting down free speech. In Rosenfelds view the time has come to save free speech from itself. His book deserves serious consideration in our current political and educational climate.
I must admit to being surprised to learn how little I understood the First Amendment. The Founding Fathers implicitly assumed free speech to mean that the government could not suppress any expression against the government, nor could private individuals be coerced into propagating government propaganda. In other words, free speech was initially a buffer against dictatorship and limited to freedom from government control. In 1919, this changed with Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.s stirring dissent in Abrams v. United States, which won over the American public by arguing that restraints on private speech were permissible only when speech constituted a present danger of immediate evil or an intent to bring it about essentially, the dont shout fire in a crowded theater test.
Rosenbaum attempts to reframe our assumptions about freedom of speech.
As Rosenbaum shows, free speech protection for private individuals is now used to violate peoples privacy and dignity. He describes how in 2011, the Supreme Court, in an 8-to-1 decision, overturned a jury verdict against the Westboro Baptist Church. The church set up a protest at the funeral of Marine Lance Cpl. Matthew Snyder, chanting slurs against gays and holding up signs reading God hates America and Thank God for dead soldiers.
Get Jewish Week's Newsletter by email and never miss our top stories Free Sign Up
Heartbroken by the fiasco of a funeral, the soldiers father sued. The 8-1 majority set aside all consideration for the family, piously invoked the right to free speech and further ordered that Snyder pay the churchs $16,000 in costs.
In other instances, Rosenbaum shows how the First Amendment is used to protect hate speech. Holocaust deniers and KKK members as well as possibly more benign flat earth and fake moon landing believers have all advanced their agendas under the umbrella of free speech. And most alarmingly he gives examples of how it is used to protect potentially fatal substances. Purveyors of, say, fake coronavirus cures and treatments can be sued on product claims, but anybody can get up on a street corner and make any claim that they want.
The coronavirus outbreak has also reminded us of the necessity of free speech as the Founding Fathers defined it. Dr. Li Wenliang, the Wuhan ophthalmologist who early on tried to warn the Chinese medical community about the virus potency, was forced by Communist Party authorities to recant his false comments. How many lives might have been saved if his speech had been free.
Dr. Lis warning is exactly the kind of free speech the First Amendment was trying to protect. Rosenbaum shows, however, that todays free speech is too often serving a different function. He writes: Here is what the First Amendment should never be called upon to protect: groups of nativists shouting Muslims Go Home; neo-Nazis marching through a hamlet [of] Holocaust survivors ; burning crosses on the lawns of African Americans; showing up to a military funeral to make ones hatred of homosexuals plainly known. They are, in fact, neither ideas nor debates. They are orgies of hate that amount to non-speech. Lets stop pretending we cannot tell the difference.
While this is not an explicitly Jewish book, Rosenbaums exploration of the harm caused by current applications of free speech will resonate with Jewish readers. His arguments about human dignity and free speech echo within the biblical notion of the image of God. Likewise he shows how Talmudic dictates that compare slander to physical harm and even death are backed up by modern scientific research that demonstrates that false speech can cause physical harm.
In an era in which American society has become radically polarized, Rosenbaum sets out to bridge the liberal-conservative divide, at least when it comes to permitted speech. He asks us to address some of our core ideas about American ideals. Not a bad thing to do when the government is ordering us to stay sheltered in place for the good of all Americans.
Scott A. Shay is chairman and co-founder of Signature Bank of New York and is the author of In Good Faith: Questioning Religion and Atheism (Post Hill Press, 2018).
Read more from the original source:
A Contrarian's View of the Uses, and Abuses, of Free Speech - Jewish Week
- Freedom of speech according to the gospel of Koch - University World News - July 21st, 2021
- U.K. Free-Speech Bill a Sound Solution to Censorship - National Review - July 21st, 2021
- She Hates Biden. Some of Her Neighbors Hate the Way She Shows It. - The New York Times - July 21st, 2021
- Academic freedom must include the right to criticise employers - Times Higher Education (THE) - July 21st, 2021
- Proposed Polish Bill Further Restricts Media Freedoms in a Climate of Civil Rights Activism - The Organization for World Peace - July 21st, 2021
- Professors enjoy academic freedom, but it doesnt allow them to teach or say whatever they want in class - San Francisco Chronicle - July 21st, 2021
- Candace Owens backs the Freedom Phone thats designed to promote free speech in fight against Big Tech... - The US Sun - July 16th, 2021
- SCOTUS Gets It Right In 'Mahanoy' With Measured Response To Student Speech - Government, Public Sector - United States - Mondaq News Alerts - July 16th, 2021
- Is Gender Wokeism the New Religion of the West? - Heritage.org - July 16th, 2021
- Ghost of Section 66A - The Indian Express - July 16th, 2021
- Trump's Big Tech lawsuit: Freedom of speech vs. the First Amendment | TheHill - The Hill - July 10th, 2021
- Letters: is it free speech or hate speech? - The Guardian - July 10th, 2021
- The rise of a generation of censors: Law schools the latest battlement over free speech | TheHill - The Hill - July 10th, 2021
- OCMD Police Say Profanity-Laced Biden Flags On The Boardwalk Are Considered Freedom Of Speech - CBS Baltimore - July 10th, 2021
- North Carolina Public Universities Arent Preparing Students Well on Free Speech - National Review - July 10th, 2021
- Gwen Berry, 'The Star Spangled Banner' and free speech in the world of sports | Opinion - NorthJersey.com - July 10th, 2021
- North Carolina Finds That Banning Indoctrination Is Hard - The Atlantic - July 10th, 2021
- Section 230 Continues To Not Mean Whatever You Want It To - Above the Law - July 10th, 2021
- Does Trump have a legitimate First Amendment case? - The Fulcrum - July 10th, 2021
- Conservatives Are the Ones Attacking Free Speech at Universities - Jacobin magazine - June 28th, 2021
- Commentary: How 'freedom of speech' is weaponized to fight anti-racism - Johnson City Press (subscription) - June 23rd, 2021
- Selective Free Speech: Academics Discussing Race Face the Real Cancel Culture Byline Times - Byline Times - June 23rd, 2021
- Celebrating the most American of freedoms | Ken Paulson - Wisconsin Newspaper Association - June 23rd, 2021
- Higher ed access, speech on campus bill moves on for House review - Ohio Capital Journal - June 23rd, 2021
- LGBTQ+ Need Not Apply - The Regulatory Review - June 23rd, 2021
- Ending hate speech starts with all of us - SC Times - June 13th, 2021
- If Critical Race Theory Is Banned, Are Teachers Protected by the First Amendment? - Education Week - June 13th, 2021
- Free speech and the culture wars The Justice Gap - thejusticegap.com - June 13th, 2021
- Free speech matters for all at UCL, and so does disruptive thinking - Jewish News - June 13th, 2021
- Twitter needs India and Nigeria to grow. It's running into trouble in both - KCTV Kansas City - June 13th, 2021
- Monday Morning Thoughts: Has the ACLU Lost Its Way in Protecting Speech They Hate? - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - June 13th, 2021
- The free speech law will make university debate harder, not easier - The Guardian - May 24th, 2021
- 'Tool for censorship': Newly effective regulation could curb free speech in Indonesia - Jakarta Post - May 24th, 2021
- 'Attempt to 'murder' freedom of speech': Cong on Twitter India office searches - Hindustan Times - May 24th, 2021
- JIM SPENCE: Abertay University vagina row is no joke the free speech Stasi are threatening to silence us all - The Courier - May 24th, 2021
- What is the First Amendment? US right to free speech explained, after Prince Harry says its bonkers - iNews - May 20th, 2021
- The New Campus Free Speech Bill What Universities Need To Know And Need To Do - Consumer Protection - UK - Mondaq News Alerts - May 20th, 2021
- The Government is in a mess with its free speech bill it has already sabotaged its own legal definition - iNews - May 20th, 2021
- The new Campus Free Speech Bill - what universities need to know and need to do - Lexology - May 20th, 2021
- Cutting costs and cultivating free speech will put higher education on the right path | TheHill - The Hill - May 20th, 2021
- Academics And Officials Have Questioned The Evidence Behind Gavin Williamson's Excessive University Free Speech Bill - PoliticsHome - May 20th, 2021
- Letters to the Editor: May 20-26, 2021 - Blaine Northern Light - May 20th, 2021
- Federal lawsuit targets Georgia voting law, citing threat to voting, speech rights - Online Athens - May 20th, 2021
- Culture wars, identity politics and free speech: Rod Liddle and Peter Tatchell in conversation - Spectator.co.uk - May 20th, 2021
- Argumentative Essays on Importance of Freedom of Speech ... - May 9th, 2021
- Does Freedom of Speech Exist - Emerging Media - Loyola ... - May 9th, 2021
- Opinion: The past year has underscored the need for vigilance in defending the First Amendment - Poynter - May 9th, 2021
- Big Tech and freedom of speech | News, Sports, Jobs - The Sentinel - Lewistown Sentinel - April 23rd, 2021
- House Bill 22 Raises Concerns for Police Reform Efforts and Freedom of Speech - WKSU News - April 23rd, 2021
- The Supreme Court Justices Are Set to Hear Two Very Different Free Speech Cases What You Should Know - Law & Crime - April 23rd, 2021
- The Russell Group's statement of principles on universities protecting freedom of speech - FE News - April 23rd, 2021
- Should satire be protected as free speech? - Aliran - April 23rd, 2021
- James Acaster Never Wants to Make an Audience Member Cry Again - Vulture - April 23rd, 2021
- Wave of New 'Anti-Riot' Legislation Threatens Free Speech - The Daily Beast - April 19th, 2021
- A Festival takes on the complicated topic of Freedom of Speech in the U.S. and France - Frenchly - April 19th, 2021
- Historic Figures Who Recognized That Speech Is Freedom's First Line of Defense | Lawrence W. Reed - Foundation for Economic Education - April 19th, 2021
- My Turn: What does a paper owe its readers? - The Recorder - April 19th, 2021
- Analyzing the Recent Sixth Circuits Extension of Academic Freedom Protection to a College - Justia Verdict - April 19th, 2021
- Does Daniel Andrews have new bars on free speech coming? - The Spectator Australia - April 19th, 2021
- Lessons on Free Speech from the Soviet Union - kvor - March 31st, 2021
- When Neville Chamberlain tried to 'no-platform' the Yorkshire Post - The Conversation UK - March 31st, 2021
- The precedent of free speech on campus | The Record - The Record - March 21st, 2021
- Intermediary Liability and Why Free Speech in Software Matters - The Wire - March 21st, 2021
- A look back at a conversation with Carl Hiaasen on free speech - WMFE - March 21st, 2021
- Holmes' defense of Freedom of Speech | Columnists | willistonherald.com - Williston Daily Herald - March 18th, 2021
- My Turn: Our biggest threats to free speech - Concord Monitor - February 14th, 2021
- Q&A: Sociologist with Specialty in Right-Wing Movements on Free Speech and the First Amendment | Newsroom - UC Merced University News - February 14th, 2021
- Gavin Williamson set to appoint free speech champion with power to fine universities - iNews - February 14th, 2021
- Letters: The limits of free speech and the dangers of violence and insurrection - The Advocate - February 14th, 2021
- Free Speech Arguments Against Trump's Impeachment Dishonor The First Amendment - People For the American Way - February 6th, 2021
- The Wall Street Journal Misreads Section 230 and the First Amendment - Lawfare - February 6th, 2021
- After Thomas furore, Bar says to balance free speech and fair trial - Free Malaysia Today - February 6th, 2021
- Reggie Jackson blasts Curt Schilling over Hall controversy: Freedom of speech got you freed out of the Hall of Fame - The Boston Globe - February 2nd, 2021
- Opinion: What the Biden Administration Can Expect To Meet in Court - Prescott eNews - February 2nd, 2021
- Academics should put freedom of speech in the context of other values (opinion) - Inside Higher Ed - January 29th, 2021
- Forum: Freedom of speech should be exercised with responsibility - The Straits Times - January 29th, 2021
- Free Speech and the Question of Race - Los Angeles Review of Books - lareviewofbooks - lareviewofbooks - January 29th, 2021
- Free speech and the responsibilities of social media companies: When should political speech lose its protection? - ABC News - January 29th, 2021
- Does Freedom of Speech Exist in Cryptocurrency Communities? - hackernoon.com - January 29th, 2021
- Absolute Freedom to Tweet? Employers (and the NLRA) May Have Something to Say About It - Lexology - January 29th, 2021