Since I have a master’s and doctoral degree in health education and since I’m a professor in a department of public health with an undergraduate curriculum that includes substantial attention to health education, I participate in the email discussion group of HEDIR, the Health Education Directory. On August 16th, I received a message to the discussion group from the American Association for Health Education inviting participants to complete an online survey from the Joint Committee on Health Education and Promotion Terminology with results to be analyzed at the Committee’s meeting in September 2011.
The survey items include various terms used by health educators, the currently approved terminology, and three choices followed by a type-in box:
- This term should remain as defined
- This term should remain in the report but modified in definition
- This term is no longer commonly used in health education/health promotion literature
If modify, please provide the suggested wording and reference for that definition if you are citing it from a specific source.
For one of the terms, my preferred response would have be have been a fourth choice that was not offered: The term is commonly used in health education/health promotion and elsewhere, but it should not be used because its use only serves to distort our thought processes and promote quackery.
Here is the term along with the definition presented in the survey:
Complementary and Alternative Health Practices: These practices generally include natural substances, physical manipulations, and self-care modalities. These approaches often incorporate aspects of interventions derived from traditional practices. The approach in Western societies has been to select specific approaches from these systems and apply them to health maintenance, health enhancement, or disease management. Such approaches can be used to compliment[sic] conventional allopathic care (complementary therapy), or as an alternative to conventional approaches (alternative therapy). Many of these complementary and alternative approaches have not been validated through experiential research, but those that have, such as acupuncture for pain, are being integrated into conventional health practices (integrative medicine).
And here are my objections to the term and to the definition given:
“Complementary and alternative health practices” is marketing doublespeak that conceals how promoting (via advertising, publicity, direct selling, word-of-mouth, etc.) non-validated or invalidated practices is unethical. When a practice is science-based, it is simply part of good healthcare or health promotion. “Complementary and alternative” jargon is never necessary to describe validated practices in health promotion or health care delivery. Science-based uses of natural substances, physical manipulations, and self-care modalities are all part of regular medicine.
Science-based natural products medicine is called pharmacognosy. Labels like “complementary and alternative” are used to give the impression of legitimacy, not to pharmacognosy, but to superstitious and often ecologically destructive uses of natural products such as herbalism (particularly paraherbalism), gruesome extractions of bile from living bears, shark cartilage, and rhinoceros horns.
Physical manipulations with a rational basis such as many of those included in personal exercise programs and physical therapy do not require euphemistic labels such as “complementary” or “alternative.” However, the labels “complementary” or “alternative” are often applied to give the appearance of legitimacy to superstition-based or pseudoscience-based physical manipulation treatments such as those used in chiropractic. Many chiropractors falsely claim that the spine requires periodic maintenance “adjustments” of health compromising “subluxations” that only chiropractors can supposedly detect. Such adjustments don’t complement anything else and they aren’t a viable alternative for health promotion or disease prevention.
Many of the manipulations promoted as “complementary” or “alternative” are actually non-physical; they are rooted in vitalism, which is defined as: “a doctrine that the functions of a living organism are due to a vital principle distinct from physicochemical forces” or “a doctrine that the processes of life are not explicable by the laws of physics and chemistry alone….” Different health cults have different names for the supposed vital principle. In anthroposophy, the names are the divine element in nature, astral body, formative force, or either body. In Ayurvedic medicine, it’s prana. In chiropractic, it’s innate intelligence. In Reichian psychotherapy, it’s orgone energy. In homeopathy, it’s vital energy. In naturopathy, it’s vis medicatrix naturae. In Traditional Chinese Medicine and acupuncture, it’s chi or qi or ki.
The vital principle was popularized in Star Wars as “the force.” But in the real universe, nothing like “the force” is reliably detectable and there are no Jedi-like masters who can manipulate anything akin to it for healing or any other purposes. In the movie Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me, the vital principle was called mojo. The idea that some people have skills as mojo detectors or mojo manipulators is as absurd as the movie, but “there are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them.”
Self-care modalities have been promoted as “complementary” and “alternative,” but what useful distinction is there to be made between supposed “complementary” or “alternative” self-care modalities and those that don’t qualify and are therefore implicitly non-complementary or non-alternative? If the distinction is to be based on validation for safety and efficacy, why introduce euphemistic language like “complementary” or “alternative”? Categories such as validated, non-validated, and invalidated should suffice to give consumers useful information for deciding what modalities of self-care are worth trying out.
It’s true that many tradition-based practices are promoted as “complementary” or “alternative.” Scholars who attempt to advance “complementary and alternative medicine” often like to emphasize traditional systems of care and ignore other practices marketed as “complementary and alternative.” Since it is often considered rude to be judgmental about traditions associated with particular cultures, fallacious appeals to traditional wisdom are useful in public relations. But numerous practices, products, and services marketed to consumers as “complementary” or “alternative” are promoted as “innovative,” “advanced,” “cutting edge,” “modern,” “scientific,” and the like, not as tradition-based. Examples include such so-called complementary and alternative medicine approaches (sCAMs) as metabolic therapy, chelation therapy, oxygenation treatments, insulin potentiation therapy, clinical ecology, anti-aging medicine, attachment therapy, various other mental health therapies, antineoplastons, cellular therapy, and syncrometers & zappers.
Referring to the selection of specific approaches from traditional systems in Western societies as “complementary” or “alternative” implies an East-West dichotomy that is simply false. Tradition-based systems and supposed whole-system care are not uniquely Eastern. Is it only in Western societies that approaches from traditional systems get used separately from whole-system care?
Medical anthropologists, medical sociologists, educated laypersons, health educators, and even physicians often make the mistake of describing standard medical practices of today and recent decades as “conventional allopathic care.” Allopathy is a term coined by Samuel Hahnemann (formulator of homeopathic treatment principles) as a label for medical practices of his day that were based upon ancient Greek humoral theory of disease such as bleeding and purging and blistering to manipulate the four so-called body humors: blood, phlegm, black bile, and yellow bile. As medicine became more science-based, it discarded treatment based upon the convention of manipulating body humors and progressed by developing healthcare consistent with progress in biological and physical sciences. Nevertheless, approaches to healthcare based upon humoral theory—what Hahnemann called allopathy—persist today in parts of India, Pakistan and elsewhere as Unani medicine, which, ironically, the World Health Organization recognizes as a type of “CAM.” Unani is an Arabic adjective meaning Greek.
Since modern medicine makes progress by relying on science, it is iconoclastic—the antithesis of conventional. By contrast, the real allopathy practiced today as Unani medicine is bound to its ancient conventions. Like much of what gets promoted as “complementary” and “alternative,” Unani medicine reflects conventional wisdom of healing traditions rather than the rigor of scientific testing and the iconoclasm of scientific discovery.
I have previously explained that calling an approach to healthcare “complementary” implies that it adds to the outcome when combined with some other treatment and that calling an approach to healthcare “alternative” implies that it can be successfully used in lieu of some other approach. However, this is misleading labeling. Simply calling an approach “complementary” doesn’t mean it actually complements anything else and calling an approach “alternative” doesn’t make it a viable alternative. The jargon “complementary and alternative” serves to distract attention away from questions of utility based upon scientific merit.
Professor Richard Dawkins has explained: “Either it is true that a medicine works or it isn’t. It cannot be false in the ordinary sense but true in some ‘alternative’ sense.”
Drs. John E. Dodes and Marvin Schissel put it this way: “Erythromycin is an alternative to penicillin, but a pogo stick is not an alternative to an automobile.”
Drs. Marcia Angell and Jerome Kassirer wrote: “There cannot be two kinds of medicine—conventional and alternative. There is only medicine that has been adequately tested and medicine that has not, medicine that works and medicine that may or may not work.”
Dr. George Lundberg explains it this way:
There is no “alternative medicine.” There is only medicine:
- Medicine that has been tested and found to be safe and effective. Use it; pay for it.
- And, medicine that has been tested and found to be unsafe or ineffective. Don’t use it; don’t pay for it.
- And, medicine for which there is some plausible reason to believe that it might be safe and effective. Test it and then place it into one of the other two categories.
Although many people believe that acupuncture for pain is medicine that fits Dr. Lundberg’s first category, the weight of evidence places it in the second category, especially considering the lack of a plausible rationale for acupuncture as a therapy. Few, if any, health practices that have been promoted as “complementary” and “alternative” also belong in Dr. Lundberg’s first category. More than ten years of research funding by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine has failed to contribute to medical progress.
The term integrative medicine is superfluous and should not be used by responsible health professionals. Palliative care and adjunctive care are meaningful and useful terms for efforts to provide rational modalities of humane care, comfort, and support addressing the diverse needs of patients. The term “integrative medicine” adds nothing to describe approaches strongly supported by scientific evidence, but serves as an income-generating mechanism for attracting patients to seemingly special modalities that typically lack support beyond cherry-picked evidence or tradition. The term “integrative medicine” is not needed to offer science-based psychological approaches for managing health problems, but it does help in marketing when you are offering modalities based on vitalism. “Integrative medicine” represents branding, not a meaningful medical specialty. It projects a misleading image of academic seriousness that serves only to obscure its hype and help secure funding for clinical research of dubious need.
Terms such as “alternative,” “complementary,” and “integrative” have become popular euphemisms for non-validated and invalidated approaches to health enhancement—especially approaches with farfetched rationales. The use of such euphemisms facilitates quackery: the promotion of health products, services, or practices of questionable safety, effectiveness, or validity for an intended purpose. Today quackery is a far less popular term than the euphemisms. In some circles, it is politically incorrect to refer to quackery. But if we cannot refer to quackery as quackery, we can expect it to persist as a neglected public health scandal. I suggest that there are better alternatives to using currently popular euphemisms of alt-speak.
William M. London is a professor in the Honors College and in the Department of Public Health in the College of Health and Human Services at California State University, Los Angeles. He co-authored the sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth (in press) editions of the college textbook Consumer Health: A Guide to Intelligent Decisions. Since 2002, he has been associate editor of the free weekly e-newsletter Consumer Health Digest. Since 2005, he has been co-host of the Credential Watch web site. He tweets as @healthgadfly.
- Medicine | Define Medicine at Dictionary.com - August 22nd, 2017
- medicine | science | Britannica.com - August 22nd, 2017
- UAB Medicine - UAB Medicine - August 22nd, 2017
- WVU Medicine | West Virginia's Largest Healthcare Provider - August 22nd, 2017
- My Medicine - WebMD - August 22nd, 2017
- 'Smart' Pill Bottles Aren't Enough To Help The Medicine Go Down - NPR - August 22nd, 2017
- Japan's latest Kit Kat is medicine flavour - CNET - CNET - August 22nd, 2017
- Trump's Kill and Cure Medicine for Afghanistan - HuffPost - August 22nd, 2017
- Northwestern Medicine Caregivers Practice Having Difficult Conversations - Northwestern University NewsCenter - August 22nd, 2017
- Generic medicine law 'may hurt patients' - The Nation - August 22nd, 2017
- NMSU's Burrell College of Osteopathic Medicine welcomes second class - El Paso Proud - August 22nd, 2017
- Tully Family Medicine opens in Athol - The Recorder - August 22nd, 2017
- Drugs.com | Prescription Drug Information, Interactions ... - August 21st, 2017
- Medicine | Define Medicine at Dictionary.com - August 21st, 2017
- medicine | science | Britannica.com - August 21st, 2017
- Medicine bawl - Inquirer.net - August 21st, 2017
- Drugmaker Hikma's US unit raises medicine prices - Financial Times - CNBC - August 21st, 2017
- Tully Family Medicine opens in Athol - The Recorder - August 21st, 2017
- Stanford Medicine magazine reports on the future of vision - Stanford Medical Center Report - August 21st, 2017
- I wish someone had told me about the challenges of being a woman in medicine - STAT - August 21st, 2017
- Gwinnett Medical Center unveils Sports Medicine and Concussion ... - Gwinnettdailypost.com - August 20th, 2017
- Top UCSD researchers pitch yoga, massage and integrative medicine for healing - The San Diego Union-Tribune - August 20th, 2017
- Is it too easy to get pain medicine? - Fredericksburg.com - August 20th, 2017
- Justin Sports Medicine helps Cowboys at CNR - 6 On Your Side - August 20th, 2017
- WRCF, Inova Sports Medicine Host Third Annual High School Coaches Clinic - Redskins.com - August 20th, 2017
- WSU's Elson S. Floyd College of Medicine welcomes inaugural class - The Spokesman-Review - August 20th, 2017
- Danbury dentist accredited in dental sleep medicine - Danbury News Times - August 19th, 2017
- Saints elevated Beau Lowery to director of sports medicine during the offseason - The Advocate - August 19th, 2017
- Dr. Harmon: The moment I knew medicine was my calling - American Medical Association (blog) - August 19th, 2017
- 'Insecure' Actor Jay Ellis Talks New Web Series 'Hard Medicine' And Lawrence Hive - Essence.com - August 19th, 2017
- Northwestern Medicine scientists develop novel method to track HIV infection - News-Medical.net - August 19th, 2017
- Hervert a resident in internal medicine at St. Bernards in Arkansas - Kearney Hub - August 19th, 2017
- Authors believe gender gap in veterinary medicine is fixable - Purdue Exponent - August 19th, 2017
- Women doctors set to take center stage at World Extreme Medicine Conference - News-Medical.net - August 18th, 2017
- Surgeon suspended from practicing medicine dies of overdose - New York Post - August 18th, 2017
- Nebraska Medicine to close inpatient burn unit - KETV Omaha - August 18th, 2017
- Penn Medicine CIO weighs in on precision medicine - MedCity News - August 18th, 2017
- Nebraska Medicine to close burn center, send patients to St. Elizabeth - Lincoln Journal Star - August 18th, 2017
- Researchers Used Tiny Autonomous Vehicles to Deliver Medicine to the Stomach of Mice - Futurism - August 18th, 2017
- 'Micromotors' alter your gut's chemistry to safely deliver medicine - Engadget - August 16th, 2017
- Washington Redskins Charitable Foundation & Inova Sports Medicine To Host High School Coaches Clinic - Redskins.com - August 16th, 2017
- NIH gives nod to Vibrent Health for precision medicine work - Healthcare IT News - August 16th, 2017
- Swimmer drowns in river near Medicine Hat - CBC.ca - August 16th, 2017
- Oly Ortho's Sports Medicine Team Keeps Thurston County Moving - ThurstonTalk - August 16th, 2017
- Ranch Medicine subject of talk at Phippen Museum - The Daily Courier - August 16th, 2017
- Alternative medicine for cancer more than doubles death risk - New York Daily News - August 15th, 2017
- Stanford Medicine X conference to focus on creating positive change in health care - Stanford Medical Center Report - August 15th, 2017
- Precision Medicine for Preventing Suicide - Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News - August 15th, 2017
- University to offer 50 places to study medicine through clearing this week - GP online - August 15th, 2017
- Restoring loss: Bio-inspired materials give boost to regenerative medicine - Arizona State University - August 15th, 2017
- Alternative Medicine Doesn't Work for Cancer Treatments - Gizmodo - August 14th, 2017
- Food Is Not Medicine, And We Have To Stop Calling It That - Huffington Post Canada - August 14th, 2017
- Marijuana as medicine - Inquirer.net - August 14th, 2017
- Retired Las Vegas doctor talks about fitness, state of medicine - Las Vegas Review-Journal - August 14th, 2017
- Maryland school of alternative medicine to offer new naturopathic program - Baltimore Sun - August 14th, 2017
- Police: At Little Rock pharmacy, thief stuffs cold medicine down pants, threatens to kill employee - Arkansas Online - August 14th, 2017
- Dr. David Katz, Preventive Medicine: Saturated fat on trial - New Haven Register - August 13th, 2017
- Police called to Nebraska Medicine for shooting victim - KETV Omaha - August 13th, 2017
- Editas Medicine's (EDIT) CEO Katrine Bosley on Q2 2017 Results - Earnings Call Transcript - Seeking Alpha - August 12th, 2017
- UR Medicine performs 3 heart transplants in 1 week - Spectrum News - August 12th, 2017
- Obsession With Studying Medicine - Financial Tribune - August 12th, 2017
- MyCode genetics program brings predictive medicine to South Jersey - Press of Atlantic City - August 12th, 2017
- Baby medicine much stronger in 1800s - Ricentral.com - August 12th, 2017
- WVU Medicine | West Virginia's Largest Healthcare Provider - August 11th, 2017
- Sanofi's Zika Standoff: Bad Medicine? - Seeking Alpha - August 11th, 2017
- Using only alternative medicine for cancer linked to lower survival rate - Yale News - August 11th, 2017
- Local professor receives prestigious sports medicine award. - Kirkland Reporter - August 11th, 2017
- After On Podcast #2: Video Games as Medicine? - Boing Boing - August 11th, 2017
- MAPS to Accept Altcoins for Research on MDMA Psychedelic Medicine - Bitcoin News (press release) - August 10th, 2017
- Using alternative medicine only for cancer linked to lower survival rate - Yale News - August 10th, 2017
- Bill would name Billings VA clinics after Ben Steele, Joe Medicine Crow - Billings Gazette - August 10th, 2017
- 4 steps to clear, radiant skin, according to Traditional Chinese Medicine - Well+Good - August 10th, 2017
- Research continues on Medicine Lake turtles | KARE11.com - KARE - August 10th, 2017
- 'Is food medicine? The question has never been so current or so contentious' - The Guardian - August 9th, 2017
- 'Origami organs' could be the future of regenerative medicine - New York Post - August 9th, 2017
- What it's like to specialize in emergency medicine: Shadowing Dr. Clem - American Medical Association (blog) - August 9th, 2017
- Collagen & Gelatin Market for Regenerative Medicine Worth 679.9 and 94.9 Million USD Respectively, by 2022 - Markets Insider - August 9th, 2017
- Ohio State researchers develop regenerative medicine breakthrough - The Ohio State University News (press release) - August 9th, 2017
- Here's Why Editas Medicine Rose as Much as 15.9% Monday - Motley Fool - August 9th, 2017
- Medicine's gender revolution: how women stopped being treated as 'small men' - The Conversation AU - August 7th, 2017