About a month ago, I discussed a rather disturbing development, namely the initiative by Dr. Andrew Weil to set up something he was going to call the American Board of Integrative Medicine, all for the purpose of creating a system of board certification for physicians practicing “integrative medicine” (IM), or, as I prefer to call them, physicians who like to integrate pseudoscience with their science, quackery with their medicine. Harsh? Yes. Accurate? Also yes. Unfortunately, many medical centers, both academic and community, are hopping on the IM bandwagon while more and more medical schools are “integrating” pseudoscience into their curricula. While one might expect Josephine Briggs of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to be cozy with IM, depressingly, even current director of the National Institutes of Health, Francis Collins, seems to have fallen into the trap.
As was admitted by Dr. Weil and his colleagues, this decision to create a board certification in IM was a huge about-face in that Weil had always argued that IM should be infused into all specialties of medicine. What happened, of course, is that once again marketing won out over idealism. Dr. Weil was concerned that there were lots of physicians and practitioners out there claiming to practice “integrative” medicine, many of whom had no qualifications in the field. At this point, the wag in me can’t resist pointing out that, given that IM “integrates” pseudoscience with science and that there really are no standards, scientific or otherwise, to guide IM practitioners (mainly because so much of IM is rank pseudoscience), why would this matter? The answer, again, comes down to branding and turf protection.
All of this is why seeing the reactions to Dr. Weil’s initiative from members of the “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and IM community is very instructive. Fortunately, John Weeks of the Integrator Blog has come through again, quoting over twenty different people, including physicians, naturopaths, chiropractors, journalists, and other IM practitioners in an article entitled, appropriately enough, Integrator Forum: 20 Voices on Weil/U. Arizona and the American Board of Integrative Medicine. Yours truly is even mentioned (disparagingly, of course).
Uncharacteristically (for me), I’ll cut to the chase and tell you the results before I show you some of the quotes (with, of course, my own translation of what the IM-speak really means). Basically, physicians practicing IM tend to love what Dr. Weil is doing. All other practitioners (chiropractors, naturopaths, etc.) hate it. Of course, that’s not a big surprise given that Weil’s plan would in essence cut out all non-physician IM practitioners from being able to call themselves “integrative physicians” or, at the very least, to relegate them to a lower, non-board-certified rung in the practice hierarchy, which, I suspect, was the point all along. Andrew Weil wants IM to be “respectable,” and to him it will only become so if the riff-raff (i.e., non-physicians) are excluded.
A typical reaction from MDs can be found from doctors like Patrick Massey, MD, PhD, the medical director for complementary and alternative medicine for the Alexian Brothers Hospital Network. (Remind me never to use an Alexian Brothers-affiliated hospital) In any case, Dr. Massey, a graduate of Dr. Weil’s IM residency, is very happy:
Certification is a topic that is long overdue.
Integrative medicine is a complex area of medicine that incorporates many aspects of traditional and nontraditional medicine: formal education is important. Considering how many people are blending medicine on their own, it is important for them to have qualified physicians to make sure they are not doing anything dangerous.
It cannot be done by primary care physicians. They are barely able to keep abreast of the recommendations for diabetes, HTN and CAD. Integrative medicine is not remotely in their sphere of expertise, nor the expertise of PAs and NPs, unless specifically trained in integrative medicine.
Again, one wonders what science-based standards exist to guide IM practitioners. I’ve asked the question before many times: When do you choose acupuncture versus, say, homeopathy? Or will MD IM practitioners finally admit that homeopathy is nothing more than pure quackery with no basis in basic or clinical science but a huge basis in prescientific magical beliefs? Or how do you know what herb you should use? Or when is chiropractic more appropriate than other therapies? They don’t know. There’s no real science behind many of the modalities that fall under the rubric of IM.
One physician, Richard “Buz” Cooper, MD, pointed out something that, quite frankly, hadn’t occurred to me but should have:
This is just one more of example of Weil’s entrepreneurial reach. It will enhance his 1,000 hour costly and profitable training program. He is pursuing it through a rump group, the American Board of PHYSICIAN Specialties [ABPS], which “certifies” a few marginal specialties (e.g., urgent care), rather than through the American Board of MEDICAL Specialties [ABMS], the recognized authority, which certifies legitimate specialties and which apparently has turned down the idea of certifying Weil’s Integrative Medicine. Tainting the emerging discipline of Integrative Medicine with ‘Weil’s Entrepreneurism’ will push it in the wrong direction and be a disservice to generations of patients.
You know, I really should have thought of this one myself when I wrote my first post on this issue. Dr. Cooper makes a devastatingly accurate point about how Dr. Weil has chosen to seek board certification for IM through a less-than-respected board, namely the American Board of Physician Specialties. It’s very obvious that the ABMS wouldn’t be interested in Dr. Weil’s plan; so he looked elsewhere. Weeks, ever the Weil apologist, criticizes Dr. Cooper for “personalizing” his commentary against Dr. Weil. While this is to some extent a legitimate point, it’s also legitimate to point out that Dr. Weil’s residency program in IM would become a whole lot more desirable, both to graduating medical students and, more importantly, to the medical schools and residency programs to which Weil franchises his program, if IM became more respected as a specialty and especially if there were a real board certification in the specialty. (The two, of course, often go together.) Moreover, there’s more to personal interest than just money. Weil is an ideologue who wants to spread his “faith” of IM to as many people as possible. Indeed, Weeks basically admits this in response to Dr. Cooper when he points out, “He is investing in something that may swell the historic importance of his work. Big egos are often associated with good things. Who isn’t seeking to have more rather than less positive impact?” And IM is lucrative, as are Weil’s many, many other business interests related to IM.
Interestingly, and perhaps not surprisingly, those most vociferously opposed to Dr. Weil’s program were all chiropractors. I say “not surprisingly” because of the history of battles between chiropractic and the American Medical Association. For example. chiropractor Lou Sportelli comments:
Look at the Medical board of this proposed group, I care not who they are, but what they know. It will take a lot of convincing to get me to believe that this is nothing more than the old medical model at work in three stages.
- Take over
The AMA was notorious for doing this to any thing that was not allopathic. This is their modus operandi and they had been successful with it until folks got wise.
Dr. Weil and his new idea are not so novel, but are highly suspect. Sounds like a lot of hype and no substance
Chiropractor James Winterstein:
[This is] an interesting move on their part. Down deep, I fear it is more of the same – dominance at all costs – in a circumstance over which they have had little control (the interest by the public in alternative medicine). Now, they form a specialty and take it [over]. I hate to say it, but I think that is a likely probability. We have already seen them work toward usurping our ‘tools.’ I don’t like the sound of this, John.
Chiropractor and homeopath Nancy Gahles:
You KNOW [the MDs] will get the juice because they are the REAL doctors. The ones you can trust. What do they even study to make them ‘integrative’? Homeopathy? NO. Functional medicine…betcha! Little nutraceutical is now the new Big Pharma. Please tell me I am dead off base here, please!
My comment is that this looks like a duck, walks like a duck and acts like a duck: co-opting integrative healthcare, calling it integrative MEDICINE and creating a Board Specialty will identify integrative healthcare with medical doctors and they will own it, be reimbursed for it and thereby drive consumers to use them only as they will get insurance for it.
One notes that Gahles is described as someone who “has been the modern leader in pushing the field of homeopathy into the nation’s health policy dialogue” as the president of the National Center for Homeopathy. I never thought I’d be in partial agreement with a homeopath, but what Gahles says is more or less what I said in my previous post when I pointed out that Weil’s desire to infuse all medical specialties with his woo apparently can’t stand up to the cold, hard reality of how medicine really works. I’ve also pointed out that excluding the real woo, such as homeopathy, from IM is but a tiny first step in trying to make the specialty into something respectable.
Perhaps the most amusing retort from a chiropractor comes from Stephen Marini. Unfortunately, it’s not amusing because it’s a devastating criticism of Andrew Weil and the concept of board certification for IM. It’s unintentionally hilarious because…well, just read for yourself how he describes himself as “a vitalist trained in classical science and conventional medicine” who appreciates “the role of energy/information on an individual’s health and healing processes.” Also note that the link to information on Marini used by Weeks comes from an entry on that repository of all pseudoscience and conspiracy theories Whale.to and that Marini is on the board of directors for the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association (ICPA). With that background, you can truly appreciate Marini’s criticism of Dr. Weil in its proper context:
The concept of a medical specialty in integrative medicine is inherently contradictory. The paradigm of conventional medicine is reductionistic, hierarchical, & mutually exclusive to other paradigms of health and healing. So to ponder the concept of such a medical doctor would require drastic changes on a medical, anthropologic, sociologic, political levels etc…..
What is needed within a complementary system is a new species of health care provider that can appropriately triage a patient with regard to Era 1, Era 2 & Era 3 health care components.
If Era III reminds you of this, you will be forgiven. So what does Marini mean by “Era 3″? Apparently this:
- Era I Medicine: Allopathic Therapies. Paradigm: CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
- ERA II Medicine: Holistic/Holoenergetic Therapies. Paradigm: ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
- ERA III Medicine: Intercessory Therapies. Paradigm: UNIFIED – ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION FIELDS
I say this in particular because following another link from the Whale.to entry on Marini leads to a statement that Marini provided to Jochim Shafer, who apparently wrote a book entitled The Trial of the Medical Mafia, in which Marini states bluntly that there ” is no credible scientific evidence to negate the hypothesis that vaccines cause immediate or delayed damage to the immune and nervous systems of children resulting in a rise in auto-immune and neurological disorders including asthma, learning disabilities, hyperactivity, autism, chronic fatigue syndrome, lupus, diabetes, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis, Guillain-Barre Syndrome, and other diseases.” He concludes that the “universal compulsory vaccination of all healthy children should be halted.”
You know, I think I’ll stick with Era 1 medicine, thank you very much, especially if in Era 3 medicine I have to rely in intercessory therapies and am not allowed to vaccinate children against infectious disease. After all, intercessory prayer has been shown more than once not to work, and vaccines have arguably saved more lives than all other science-based medical interventions combined. Say what you will about Andrew Weil (and we at SBM have certainly said a lot), I’ve never perceived him as being anti-vaccine. Marini clearly is.
In the five weeks or so since I wrote the first installment about Dr. Weil’s initiative to develop a board certification for IM, I’ve thought a bit about what the intent might be and what the consequences might come to be. The more I think about this, the more I think that the chiropractors and naturopaths who don’t like the plan are probably perceiving it quite correctly. It is a dagger aimed right at their hearts, and it is MDs who are holding the hilt. Dr. Weil’s denials notwithstanding, led by Dr. Weil, the pro-woo physician contingent is trying to make sure that no non-physician specialty can claim to be “integrative physicians.” It’s a big deal, too. If you don’t believe just how much it matters to non-physician CAM/IM practitioners to be able to claim the title “physician,” read this revealing article by John Weeks himself.
As I said before, this in and of itself might not be that bad a thing in that many of the practitioners being targeted base their practices on nothing more than prescientific vitalism tarted up with science-y-sounding language. Certainly acupuncturists, chiropractors, homeopaths, and, yes, naturopaths do this. Making it harder for them to practice their non-science-based placebo medicine is probably a good thing, as would be increasing the scientific rigor of what passes for “integrative medicine” now.
Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening. What I do see happening is that, like the Thing in John Carpenter’s famous 1982 movie of the same name, Weil will try to kill off the non-physician “integrative” practitioners but after doing so he will take on their appearance, just as the monster in The Thing took on the appearance of the people it killed. (Hey, it’s Halloween; I had to pick a horror movie metaphor.) In doing so, he will then permanently infect the entire body of academic medicine with the virus that is IM. At least, that is his plan. He has, after all, said as much.
- Homeless Find a Champion in Canada's Medicine Hat - The New ... - New York Times - February 27th, 2017
- Medicine in the 4th Industrial Revolution: the third entity of the new doctor-patient relationship - The European Sting - February 27th, 2017
- Dr. David Katz: Preventive Medicine: The fasting and the furious - New Haven Register - February 27th, 2017
- Donkeys hides smuggled from SA to China for medicine - News24 - February 27th, 2017
- Doctors urged to avoid 'over-treating' - BBC News - February 27th, 2017
- Wayne State | School of Medicine - February 25th, 2017
- Pill-sized device could revolutionise medicine by sending health ... - The Sun - February 25th, 2017
- Lisa Nicole Cloud Shuts Down Her Haters at the Married to Medicine Reunion: 5 Emotional Moments You Need to ... - Bravo (blog) - February 25th, 2017
- The yin and yang of traditional Chinese medicine - EUobserver - February 25th, 2017
- SD's top family medicine physician hopes for improved rural access to health care - WDAZ - February 25th, 2017
- How World War I Revolutionized Medicine - The Atlantic - February 24th, 2017
- Kevin Jones: Can Embracing Uncertainty Lead To Better Medicine? - NPR - February 24th, 2017
- Syrian Doctors And The American Dream: Practicing Medicine In A New Immigration Landscape - Health Affairs (blog) - February 24th, 2017
- Canada Today: South Korean Hockey, Biking to the Border and Medicine Hat's Money - New York Times - February 24th, 2017
- Food: Powerful Medicine to Defend Against Cancer - Environmental Working Group - February 24th, 2017
- Nurse allegedly stole boy's medicine, his death ruled a homicide - KXAN.com - February 24th, 2017
- SoutheastHEALTH, Washington University School of Medicine announce collaboration - Southeast Missourian - February 24th, 2017
- The best medicine for ADHD might not be medicine, at least at first - Washington Post - February 24th, 2017
- Chutes & Ladders: FDA's personalized medicine head leaves for Grail - FierceBiotech - February 24th, 2017
- Jen Widerstrom's Medicine Ball Workout Will Get You Toned from Head to Toe - Health.com - February 24th, 2017
- Shinyribs Has Got Your Medicine - Texas Monthly - February 24th, 2017
- Wellness Family Medicine closes after doctor's license suspended - Spartanburg Herald Journal - February 24th, 2017
- Incredible Medicine: Dr Weston's Casebook is a watchable series about cutting-edge medical science: review - Telegraph.co.uk - February 23rd, 2017
- The Brilliant Drone That'll Deliver MedicineThen Rot Away | WIRED - WIRED - February 23rd, 2017
- The Future of Medicine is Artificial Intelligences And a Virtual World - Futurism - February 23rd, 2017
- NBCBLK28: Christen Johnson is Pushing For Diversity In Medicine - NBCNews.com - February 23rd, 2017
- Medicine Hat mumps outbreak prompts alert as virus hits hockey team - CBC.ca - February 23rd, 2017
- New facility brings together fitness, wellness and medicine - Orlando Sentinel - February 23rd, 2017
- Red Deer man arrested in Medicine Hat drug bust - rdnewsnow.com - February 23rd, 2017
- Stanford Medicine magazine looks at what arts, humanities bring to ... - Stanford Medical Center Report - February 22nd, 2017
- Anti-epilepsy medicine taken by pregnant women does not harm the ... - Science Daily - February 22nd, 2017
- Lisa K. Nolan named dean of UGA College of Veterinary Medicine - Online Athens - February 22nd, 2017
- Old Crow Medicine Show Ready Bob Dylan Tribute Album - Rolling ... - RollingStone.com - February 22nd, 2017
- Benefits to having a family physician, promoting family medicine week - UpperMichigansSource.com - February 22nd, 2017
- Jeffrey V. Ravetch receives 2017 Ross Prize in Molecular Medicine - The Rockefeller University Newswire - February 22nd, 2017
- CU collaboration produces health 'game-changer' - CU Anschutz Today (press release) - February 22nd, 2017
- Home | New York Academy of Medicine - February 21st, 2017
- Cincy students get a glimpse into medicine - Cincinnati.com - February 21st, 2017
- Virginia Board of Medicine adopts regulations to address opioid epidemic - WRIC - February 21st, 2017
- Clemson researchers work toward brighter future in medicine, security - Greenville News - February 21st, 2017
- What it's like in preventive medicine: Shadowing Dr. Blumenthal - American Medical Association (blog) - February 21st, 2017
- Holistic medicine, what you need to know - Arizona Sonoro News - February 20th, 2017
- New provider joins Samaritan Lebanon Health Center Family Medicine clinic - Lebanon Express - February 20th, 2017
- Precision medicine's Holy Grail: Anticipate cancer's next step - Healthcare IT News - February 20th, 2017
- 3D-printed prosthetic limbs: the next revolution in medicine - The Guardian - February 20th, 2017
- Definitions relating to regenerative medicine studies at the Steadman Philippon Research Institute - The Denver Post - February 20th, 2017
- Dr. David Katz, Preventative Medicine: Diet Trial Tribulations - New Haven Register - February 20th, 2017
- Dear Sports Medicine Counsel #4 - The Argus.ca - February 20th, 2017
- Smartphones are revolutionizing medicine - Phys.Org - February 18th, 2017
- Request For Abstracts: The Practice Of Medicine - Health Affairs (blog) - February 18th, 2017
- Slow Medicine: Good Reads - MedPage Today (blog) - February 18th, 2017
- Was Andy Cohen the Shadiest Person at the Married to Medicine Reunion? 5 Fierce Moments You Need to Check Out - Bravo (blog) - February 18th, 2017
- Family Medicine Faculty More Diverse Than Most, but Still Wanting - AAFP News - February 18th, 2017
- Medicine Hat unveils proposal to assist residents dealing with poverty - The Globe and Mail - February 18th, 2017
- Married to Medicine's Quad Webb-Lunceford Aims to Prove She's ... - E! Online - February 18th, 2017
- Mercy Health joins forces with Michigan Medicine - Grand Haven Tribune - February 17th, 2017
- Maine's HealthInfoNet taps Orion Health for precision medicine platform - Healthcare IT News - February 17th, 2017
- Hospitals, Hospital Medicine, And Health For All - Health Affairs (blog) - February 16th, 2017
- Medicine Rocks State Park - Atlas Obscura - February 16th, 2017
- What a dying patient taught me about the limits of medicine - Crain's Chicago Business - February 16th, 2017
- Five-day fasting diet could fight disease, slow aging - Science Magazine - February 16th, 2017
- Medicine: Discovery through doing - Nature.com - February 16th, 2017
- Brookhaven Police offer medicine disposal collection unit - Atlanta Journal Constitution - February 16th, 2017
- A Canadian City Thrives on Gas, Like a 'Wealthy Little Country' - New York Times - February 16th, 2017
- Paul Ryan: Democrats Want To Go Down 'Socialized Medicine Path' - TPM - February 16th, 2017
- Why Fortress Investment Group, Editas Medicine, and Hertz Global Holdings Jumped Today - Motley Fool - February 16th, 2017
- Capitalism, race and medicine are topics this spring at Crispus Attucks Community Academy - LancasterOnline - February 16th, 2017
- The Daily Pennsylvanian | Penn Medicine has developed a vaccine ... - The Daily Pennsylvanian - February 15th, 2017
- Mt. Sinai Merger Shuts New York's Integrative Medicine "Crown Jewel" - Huffington Post - February 15th, 2017
- UI teaching future doctors the business of medicine - Iowa City Press Citizen - February 15th, 2017
- Virdis Medicine comes to Chambersburg Town Hall meeting to inform residents about their company - WHAG - February 15th, 2017
- Chambersburg Council hears a presentation from Virdis Medicine at Monday's council meeting - WHAG - February 14th, 2017
- Dr. Virginia Apgar: Changing perceptions in medicine - Medical News Today - February 13th, 2017
- This medicine-toting drone flew where no one thought it could - CNET - February 13th, 2017
- 'Women With Heart' to advocate for Volunteers in Medicine - Florida Times-Union - February 13th, 2017
- Corn, milk proteins make medicine easier to swallow -- ScienceDaily - Science Daily - February 13th, 2017
- HIMSS Precision Medicine Summit: Call-for-presentations now open - Healthcare IT News - February 13th, 2017
- The Father of Electrical Medicine - San Francisco Examiner - February 12th, 2017
- Medicine flourishing in Lilac City - The Columbian - February 12th, 2017
- Medicine turns to solar energy - Rutland Herald - February 11th, 2017